Agree with it should be fixed.
Forum > Suggestions > How to improve Pass Blocking Assignments and still allow realistic levels of Pass Rush Pressure
Ken1
offline
offline
I want to make two things clear from my perspective:
1) DE's without soft-capped Strength at higher levels (above 25ish) should be nerfed, period.
It wasn't just low yards per carry that bugged me before LB's with low Tackling and Strength were nerfed, but the fact that you could build an all-speed LB and he could succeed at all (there were posts about the LB's with "awful" builds because "They think LB's need 40 Tackling."), when real life LB's need Strength and Tackling above all.
I recognize that not all the super pass rushers are low-Strength builds, but the ones who need nerfing are the low-Strength ones; and it should be very rare that any get more than 3 sacks a game against a decent team (not counting random number generator flukes, which will of course happen).
2) OT's without much Speed should be okay. Maybe below 20 or even below 25 should be trouble, and maybe above 25 should be helpful in some ways (I have some above 25), but you can play real life OT all the way up to the NFL even while slow. OT's can require Agility, aka quickness, but OT's don't need Speed in real life and shouldn't need it here.
1) DE's without soft-capped Strength at higher levels (above 25ish) should be nerfed, period.
It wasn't just low yards per carry that bugged me before LB's with low Tackling and Strength were nerfed, but the fact that you could build an all-speed LB and he could succeed at all (there were posts about the LB's with "awful" builds because "They think LB's need 40 Tackling."), when real life LB's need Strength and Tackling above all.
I recognize that not all the super pass rushers are low-Strength builds, but the ones who need nerfing are the low-Strength ones; and it should be very rare that any get more than 3 sacks a game against a decent team (not counting random number generator flukes, which will of course happen).
2) OT's without much Speed should be okay. Maybe below 20 or even below 25 should be trouble, and maybe above 25 should be helpful in some ways (I have some above 25), but you can play real life OT all the way up to the NFL even while slow. OT's can require Agility, aka quickness, but OT's don't need Speed in real life and shouldn't need it here.
Last edited Oct 19, 2008 23:39:27
winchester
offline
offline
Hey Mike, are you sure it is not the tunnel vision that is doing all of this just like pump fake in the past? I have seen guys with the speed build not getting anything till they start loading up on tunnel vision. I can send you the builds if you want them. They are about the same exp one has 9+ TV.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by winchester
Hey Mike, are you sure it is not the tunnel vision that is doing all of this just like pump fake in the past? I have seen guys with the speed build not getting anything till they start loading up on tunnel vision. I can send you the builds if you want them. They are about the same exp one has 9+ TV.
A lot of people seem to think this. I don't know one way or the other, although I have a DE who does moderately well, who has a moderate amount of Tunnel Vision, so the only data point I have of a build I know would fit.
If the TV is overpowered (I'm not sure, but I've read enough posts that suggest it to make me think it could be), then it obviously would need to be toned down some, but not destroyed. It's very easy to overdo weakening an SA.
Basically (again, assuming it is TV, which isn't certain to me), making TV trigger less often, very sensitive to morale and fatigue (hurting most those who get pancaked on other plays), without weakening it when it does trigger, might be a solution.
Hey Mike, are you sure it is not the tunnel vision that is doing all of this just like pump fake in the past? I have seen guys with the speed build not getting anything till they start loading up on tunnel vision. I can send you the builds if you want them. They are about the same exp one has 9+ TV.
A lot of people seem to think this. I don't know one way or the other, although I have a DE who does moderately well, who has a moderate amount of Tunnel Vision, so the only data point I have of a build I know would fit.
If the TV is overpowered (I'm not sure, but I've read enough posts that suggest it to make me think it could be), then it obviously would need to be toned down some, but not destroyed. It's very easy to overdo weakening an SA.
Basically (again, assuming it is TV, which isn't certain to me), making TV trigger less often, very sensitive to morale and fatigue (hurting most those who get pancaked on other plays), without weakening it when it does trigger, might be a solution.
winchester
offline
offline
I know my friends build was 60 strength, 85 speed, and 70 agility when he was at LVL 29. He is a LVL 30 now and has 5 sacks. I think (not for sure) his vision is about 35+ and has a OK build. I will ask him for it again.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=413633
Without calling another friend out, he used the guide in the DE forum
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=654381
and has a guy with 70+ sacks the last time I checked with less of a build (faster) but with a ton of TV. That is what has me thinking it might have to do with TV.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=413633
Without calling another friend out, he used the guide in the DE forum
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=654381
and has a guy with 70+ sacks the last time I checked with less of a build (faster) but with a ton of TV. That is what has me thinking it might have to do with TV.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 00:06:20
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by turnerhero
I don't think very much at all is wrong with pass protection, aside from shitty builds OTs try to pass off as 'good'
I want to contest this comment, because OT's should not need much Speed. Real life OT's can be slow as hell. They should need good Agility, maybe even soft capped by Level 30ish. But there's no race going on. Speed DE's have that Speed to get to the QB. The OT only has to move a few steps. That's quickness (Agility), not Speed.
Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.
Yep, I've figured out some tricks and I also try to get specific builds on OT's. The team I GM has my LOT, with softcapped Agility, Blocking over Strength, and very high Protect.
But the team I own, whenever we face a monster pass rusher, it becomes the focus of our planning to prevent him from teeing off on us. It shouldn't be. I know how to adapt to the current balance fairly well, but it isn't a real balance as it should be.
I have to say, it seems to me that there are build related solutions to the vast majority of the sack issues in GLB.
Ken1, how can you possibly say that when you face a sack monster, it should not become your focus to keep him from getting to you? That makes no sense at all. Are you suggesting that defensive superstars should not affect your gameplanning? Or that there simply should not be defensive superstars?
Is there something I am missing here?
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by turnerhero
I don't think very much at all is wrong with pass protection, aside from shitty builds OTs try to pass off as 'good'
I want to contest this comment, because OT's should not need much Speed. Real life OT's can be slow as hell. They should need good Agility, maybe even soft capped by Level 30ish. But there's no race going on. Speed DE's have that Speed to get to the QB. The OT only has to move a few steps. That's quickness (Agility), not Speed.
Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.
Yep, I've figured out some tricks and I also try to get specific builds on OT's. The team I GM has my LOT, with softcapped Agility, Blocking over Strength, and very high Protect.
But the team I own, whenever we face a monster pass rusher, it becomes the focus of our planning to prevent him from teeing off on us. It shouldn't be. I know how to adapt to the current balance fairly well, but it isn't a real balance as it should be.
I have to say, it seems to me that there are build related solutions to the vast majority of the sack issues in GLB.
Ken1, how can you possibly say that when you face a sack monster, it should not become your focus to keep him from getting to you? That makes no sense at all. Are you suggesting that defensive superstars should not affect your gameplanning? Or that there simply should not be defensive superstars?
Is there something I am missing here?
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
I want to make two things clear from my perspective:
1) DE's without soft-capped Strength at higher levels (above 25ish) should be nerfed, period.
It wasn't just low yards per carry that bugged me before LB's with low Tackling and Strength were nerfed, but the fact that you could build an all-speed LB and he could succeed at all (there were posts about the LB's with "awful" builds because "They think LB's need 40 Tackling."), when real life LB's need Strength and Tackling above all.
I recognize that not all the super pass rushers are low-Strength builds, but the ones who need nerfing are the low-Strength ones; and it should be very rare that any get more than 3 sacks a game against a decent team (not counting random number generator flukes, which will of course happen).
2) OT's without much Speed should be okay. Maybe below 20 or even below 25 should be trouble, and maybe above 25 should be helpful in some ways (I have some above 25), but you can play real life OT all the way up to the NFL even while slow. OT's can require Agility, aka quickness, but OT's don't need Speed in real life and shouldn't need it here.
I don't disagree philosophically about speed for OTs, but your numbers are completely arbitrary. I could just as easily say "OT should not need much speed, not more than 40-45. They should certainly be punished for having low speed, below 35 for instance."
25 speed is dead slow. NFL OTs are not dead slow.
I agree though, that agility should be (and already is) much more important.
I want to make two things clear from my perspective:
1) DE's without soft-capped Strength at higher levels (above 25ish) should be nerfed, period.
It wasn't just low yards per carry that bugged me before LB's with low Tackling and Strength were nerfed, but the fact that you could build an all-speed LB and he could succeed at all (there were posts about the LB's with "awful" builds because "They think LB's need 40 Tackling."), when real life LB's need Strength and Tackling above all.
I recognize that not all the super pass rushers are low-Strength builds, but the ones who need nerfing are the low-Strength ones; and it should be very rare that any get more than 3 sacks a game against a decent team (not counting random number generator flukes, which will of course happen).
2) OT's without much Speed should be okay. Maybe below 20 or even below 25 should be trouble, and maybe above 25 should be helpful in some ways (I have some above 25), but you can play real life OT all the way up to the NFL even while slow. OT's can require Agility, aka quickness, but OT's don't need Speed in real life and shouldn't need it here.
I don't disagree philosophically about speed for OTs, but your numbers are completely arbitrary. I could just as easily say "OT should not need much speed, not more than 40-45. They should certainly be punished for having low speed, below 35 for instance."
25 speed is dead slow. NFL OTs are not dead slow.
I agree though, that agility should be (and already is) much more important.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by winchester
I know my friends build was 60 strength, 85 speed, and 70 agility when he was at LVL 29. He is a LVL 30 now and has 5 sacks. I think (not for sure) his vision is about 35+ and has a OK build. I will ask him for it again.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=413633
Without calling another friend out, he used the guide in the DE forum
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=654381
and has a guy with 70+ sacks the last time I checked with less of build (faster) but with a ton of TV. That is what has me thinking it might have to do with TV.
If it is TV, which I think Bort should at least look and see about (just see if all the super-sackers have super TV), how about-- again, keeping it as strong as now when it triggers, but making it's trigger:
X = the chance of it triggering now.
New Trigger Chance = X * sqrt(Morale / 100) * ((Strength + 30) / 150).
So, Morale loss through being pancaked would have a significant effect on it triggering on future plays (e.g. it loses 14% of triggers if Morale is lowered to 75, with .86 the square root of .75), and low Strength would really kill its triggering.
A Strength of 30 would only get 40% as many triggers as now and a Strength of 45 half as many triggers (even before counting those lost to poor Morale). A Strength of 60 would get 60% as many triggers (that might be "standard"), so between that and the morale effect, it would cut the triggers about in half for a typical well-built DE.
But if Strength is really high then it could trigger almost as often if Morale is fine or, if Strength is taken to the limit and eq is in Strength, then it could go all the way to fully triggering as now-- but to get that much Strength one has sacrificed other speed-rush factors.
Morale affecting it would be very realistic. You don't get as determined if you feel crappy. The direct effect of Strength may be less realistic, but it would force what I think is needed: DE's would need Strength to be effective.
I know my friends build was 60 strength, 85 speed, and 70 agility when he was at LVL 29. He is a LVL 30 now and has 5 sacks. I think (not for sure) his vision is about 35+ and has a OK build. I will ask him for it again.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=413633
Without calling another friend out, he used the guide in the DE forum
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=654381
and has a guy with 70+ sacks the last time I checked with less of build (faster) but with a ton of TV. That is what has me thinking it might have to do with TV.
If it is TV, which I think Bort should at least look and see about (just see if all the super-sackers have super TV), how about-- again, keeping it as strong as now when it triggers, but making it's trigger:
X = the chance of it triggering now.
New Trigger Chance = X * sqrt(Morale / 100) * ((Strength + 30) / 150).
So, Morale loss through being pancaked would have a significant effect on it triggering on future plays (e.g. it loses 14% of triggers if Morale is lowered to 75, with .86 the square root of .75), and low Strength would really kill its triggering.
A Strength of 30 would only get 40% as many triggers as now and a Strength of 45 half as many triggers (even before counting those lost to poor Morale). A Strength of 60 would get 60% as many triggers (that might be "standard"), so between that and the morale effect, it would cut the triggers about in half for a typical well-built DE.
But if Strength is really high then it could trigger almost as often if Morale is fine or, if Strength is taken to the limit and eq is in Strength, then it could go all the way to fully triggering as now-- but to get that much Strength one has sacrificed other speed-rush factors.
Morale affecting it would be very realistic. You don't get as determined if you feel crappy. The direct effect of Strength may be less realistic, but it would force what I think is needed: DE's would need Strength to be effective.
Ilok
offline
offline
what ever the change, the perfectly built Defensive end should never have 30+ sacks. It's unrealistic.
Originally posted by winchester
Hey Mike, are you sure it is not the tunnel vision that is doing all of this just like pump fake in the past? I have seen guys with the speed build not getting anything till they start loading up on tunnel vision. I can send you the builds if you want them. They are about the same exp one has 9+ TV.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RT step backwards too far.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RG move to the LT position to pick up a blitzing CB.
Tunnel Vision does not cause the LG C RG HB and FB to all block the NT.
The reason DEs with high Tunnel Vision are getting massive sack numbers is that their build makes the most of what is a error in the Pass porotection design.
Tunnel Vison is not over powered in and of itself, but it is contributing to exposing the real issues by magnifying the results.
Hey Mike, are you sure it is not the tunnel vision that is doing all of this just like pump fake in the past? I have seen guys with the speed build not getting anything till they start loading up on tunnel vision. I can send you the builds if you want them. They are about the same exp one has 9+ TV.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RT step backwards too far.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RG move to the LT position to pick up a blitzing CB.
Tunnel Vision does not cause the LG C RG HB and FB to all block the NT.
The reason DEs with high Tunnel Vision are getting massive sack numbers is that their build makes the most of what is a error in the Pass porotection design.
Tunnel Vison is not over powered in and of itself, but it is contributing to exposing the real issues by magnifying the results.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 00:15:48
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by turnerhero
I don't think very much at all is wrong with pass protection, aside from shitty builds OTs try to pass off as 'good'
I want to contest this comment, because OT's should not need much Speed. Real life OT's can be slow as hell. They should need good Agility, maybe even soft capped by Level 30ish. But there's no race going on. Speed DE's have that Speed to get to the QB. The OT only has to move a few steps. That's quickness (Agility), not Speed.
Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.
Yep, I've figured out some tricks and I also try to get specific builds on OT's. The team I GM has my LOT, with softcapped Agility, Blocking over Strength, and very high Protect.
But the team I own, whenever we face a monster pass rusher, it becomes the focus of our planning to prevent him from teeing off on us. It shouldn't be. I know how to adapt to the current balance fairly well, but it isn't a real balance as it should be.
Ken1, how can you possibly say that when you face a sack monster, it should not become your focus to keep him from getting to you? That makes no sense at all. Are you suggesting that defensive superstars should not affect your gameplanning? Or that there simply should not be defensive superstars?
Only to the extent that they exist in real life.
There aren't guys in real life that can get that many sacks consistently.
I'll defend guys sometimes breaking NFL records, even against non-gutted teams, because there isn't NFL-style parity either among players or among teams (even among non-gutted teams).
But there are guys who, as someone else researched, in an average game break the NFL sacks record. That's not a realistic defensive star. I checked to see how many QB's in an average GLB game, come near the NFL passing yards record. None do. The best get 380 or so, where the record is over 500. The ones near 380 are the offensive stars, and guys with comparable sack levels, like 3 per game (which no one in the NFL gets, just as no one in the NFL gets 380 passing yards per game), should be the defensive stars.
The current level can't be allowed to continue; and nearly everyone, no matter what their favored solution (and some components just about everyone agrees upon, such as better pass blocking AI), agrees on that point.
And I also realized, you used my teams' fairly good success in containing the monsters against me, which is strange-- because imagine if my teams had given up boatloads of sacks. You'd have cried sour grapes. Instead, I know how to limit them, and you use that to show...I'm not sure what. It shows to me that I'm fighting for the game rather than myself.
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by turnerhero
I don't think very much at all is wrong with pass protection, aside from shitty builds OTs try to pass off as 'good'
I want to contest this comment, because OT's should not need much Speed. Real life OT's can be slow as hell. They should need good Agility, maybe even soft capped by Level 30ish. But there's no race going on. Speed DE's have that Speed to get to the QB. The OT only has to move a few steps. That's quickness (Agility), not Speed.
Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.
Yep, I've figured out some tricks and I also try to get specific builds on OT's. The team I GM has my LOT, with softcapped Agility, Blocking over Strength, and very high Protect.
But the team I own, whenever we face a monster pass rusher, it becomes the focus of our planning to prevent him from teeing off on us. It shouldn't be. I know how to adapt to the current balance fairly well, but it isn't a real balance as it should be.
Ken1, how can you possibly say that when you face a sack monster, it should not become your focus to keep him from getting to you? That makes no sense at all. Are you suggesting that defensive superstars should not affect your gameplanning? Or that there simply should not be defensive superstars?
Only to the extent that they exist in real life.
There aren't guys in real life that can get that many sacks consistently.
I'll defend guys sometimes breaking NFL records, even against non-gutted teams, because there isn't NFL-style parity either among players or among teams (even among non-gutted teams).
But there are guys who, as someone else researched, in an average game break the NFL sacks record. That's not a realistic defensive star. I checked to see how many QB's in an average GLB game, come near the NFL passing yards record. None do. The best get 380 or so, where the record is over 500. The ones near 380 are the offensive stars, and guys with comparable sack levels, like 3 per game (which no one in the NFL gets, just as no one in the NFL gets 380 passing yards per game), should be the defensive stars.
The current level can't be allowed to continue; and nearly everyone, no matter what their favored solution (and some components just about everyone agrees upon, such as better pass blocking AI), agrees on that point.
And I also realized, you used my teams' fairly good success in containing the monsters against me, which is strange-- because imagine if my teams had given up boatloads of sacks. You'd have cried sour grapes. Instead, I know how to limit them, and you use that to show...I'm not sure what. It shows to me that I'm fighting for the game rather than myself.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ilok
what ever the change, the perfectly built Defensive end should never have 30+ sacks. It's unrealistic.
30+ sacks in a season is fine with me. I think 50+ is where it starts to be too much.
There are team and talent mismatches in GLB beyond those in the NFL or even the NCAA, so there will be players of all sorts who get more of whatever than any real life player.
The key is to keep them manageable and balanced between O and D and between run and pass, and to force builds to be reasonably realistic to succeed.
what ever the change, the perfectly built Defensive end should never have 30+ sacks. It's unrealistic.
30+ sacks in a season is fine with me. I think 50+ is where it starts to be too much.
There are team and talent mismatches in GLB beyond those in the NFL or even the NCAA, so there will be players of all sorts who get more of whatever than any real life player.
The key is to keep them manageable and balanced between O and D and between run and pass, and to force builds to be reasonably realistic to succeed.
Ilok
offline
offline
hopefully the way bort has addressed the level mismatch in leagues will hep resolve the unrealistic stats issue, but still some DEs are averaging 3+ stats against competitive teams. Seriously, who averages that?
The high number of sacks is a direct result of the errors in Pass protection design.
If a DE is gaining 100 sacks in a game by speeding OUTSIDE the OT and chasing down the QB thats fine.
If he is Bull rushing the OT into the QB and getting the sack that way even better.
If he is using spin, swim or rip moves to beat a OT after the first contact we have realism.
But having the RG and RT step away from him and allowing the inside path uncontested because of the errors in Pass protection is causing 50% or more of the sacks given up.
These are not sacks that can be stopped by build corrections.
Because there is not opportunity for the OT to engage the DE in any kind of contact at all.
Nobody wants the number of sacks limiting or capping or in any artificial way made to fit a NFL quota.
Just cut out the Sacks that are occuring through no fault other than the play design.
If a DE is gaining 100 sacks in a game by speeding OUTSIDE the OT and chasing down the QB thats fine.
If he is Bull rushing the OT into the QB and getting the sack that way even better.
If he is using spin, swim or rip moves to beat a OT after the first contact we have realism.
But having the RG and RT step away from him and allowing the inside path uncontested because of the errors in Pass protection is causing 50% or more of the sacks given up.
These are not sacks that can be stopped by build corrections.
Because there is not opportunity for the OT to engage the DE in any kind of contact at all.
Nobody wants the number of sacks limiting or capping or in any artificial way made to fit a NFL quota.
Just cut out the Sacks that are occuring through no fault other than the play design.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 00:30:25
Ilok
offline
offline
i'm not saying limiting or capping the number of sacks someone can get, there needs to be nerfs made to speed rush DEs and passing to compensate along with upgrades to pass protection. There needs to be no way the best built DE against similar competition to get 30+ sacks in a season. There are Des getting 100+ DEs in a season, and it's not just because of poor pass protection.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























