User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The new promotion system
Page:
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami


It defies logic, how are you ready to be promoted because you have won games against non playoff teams?


Scrimmages are against the teams that lost in the same round that you did. So the Alpha Championship loser plays the Zeta Championship loser. There's obvious benefit to considering that game.
 
Loco Moco
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I'm also adding a way to "flag" teams for the same demotion who are not sold but are really terrible or way too low leveled, such as slow build teams and such. We'll be doing some cleaning up this season using this as well, to get the super low leveled teams together at the bottom so they can compete with each other.


I'm assuming there is no decision yet as to how this will be done.
I'm sure it won't be easy.

I'm also assuming they won't be put in capped leagues and that they will get to keep their existing stadiums.
That's just a guess though.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:00:39
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami

I may be misunderstanding how it works correct me if I'm wrong, but basically if an 8-8 team gets lucky in their first playoff game and wins they will move up instead of a 16-0 team that got unlucky in their first playoff game?


The 8-8 team could have held off on boosts and therefore be better than a 16-0 team.

With the old rules the 8-8 team could have won conference and been promoted anyways over a 16-0 team, basically the same concept as before.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
What about re-alignment? When will that happen or won't it happen?

When will teams be able to apply for flagging and demotion? Can we nominate teams in our division for flagging or does the owner have to do that? There are some owners who don't/won't care how competitive they are since they're the slow builders. I think other teams in the division should be able to flag teams so an admin at least looks at the roster. Of course, that's all a moot point if there's also a realignment this offseason.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:09:22
 
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Buckeyechamp3124

Bort - This has prob. been covered but I missed it.

You said that a champion will move up in front of a runner up but you also said that the two conferences below it will fill in spots.

Does that mean that if their are comp. teams in USA Pro and they get dropped that a USA AA champ will move up over a USA AAA Runner up?


Please explain this as well Bort. very Important.


Could we get this answered?
 
DAKING
offline
Link
 
Slow-Building teams should go there with gutted teams
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by ShamsTron

Originally posted by nfratami


I just don't understand why post season scrimmage wins are valued above anything regular season and/or postseason.


Yea I am with you on that one. On the team I GM once we got taken out of the playoffs we did not care about the final scrimmages.


I agree. This is the only part that makes zero sense to me.

If you want people to take scrimmages seriously, there needs to be some motivation other than slightly improving your odds to move up. Most of us use scrimmages as a testing ground for AI and roster changes. Especially after the season is over, who cares?

Makes no sense include scrimmages at all.


Here's the point: YOU KNOW AHEAD OF TIME. THE SCRIMMAGES THIS YEAR MATTER. ACT ACCORDINGLY.

How is this unfair or nonsensical? Now the games mean something, and everybody knows. Use the scrimmages at the beginning of the year to test tactics.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buckeyechamp3124
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Buckeyechamp3124


Bort - This has prob. been covered but I missed it.

You said that a champion will move up in front of a runner up but you also said that the two conferences below it will fill in spots.

Does that mean that if their are comp. teams in USA Pro and they get dropped that a USA AA champ will move up over a USA AAA Runner up?


Please explain this as well Bort. very Important.


Could we get this answered?


He said it processed at once so that no one would get double promoted. So no AA to Pro jumps. Period.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
Originally posted by nfratami


I may be misunderstanding how it works correct me if I'm wrong, but basically if an 8-8 team gets lucky in their first playoff game and wins they will move up instead of a 16-0 team that got unlucky in their first playoff game?


The 8-8 team could have held off on boosts and therefore be better than a 16-0 team.

With the old rules the 8-8 team could have won conference and been promoted anyways over a 16-0 team, basically the same concept as before.


I didn't say that, I said a team that got lucky.



Originally posted by tjking82


Here's the point: YOU KNOW AHEAD OF TIME. THE SCRIMMAGES THIS YEAR MATTER. ACT ACCORDINGLY.

How is this unfair or nonsensical? Now the games mean something, and everybody knows. Use the scrimmages at the beginning of the year to test tactics.


This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.

Also, no need to get angry about it I really don't see a need for the caps.

 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buckeyechamp3124
You said that a champion will move up in front of a runner up but you also said that the two conferences below it will fill in spots.


I think you're getting something confused.

Every league has 2 leagues directly below it. Pro has two AAAs. AAA1 has AA1 and AA2. Etc etc etc.

Originally posted by Bort
...promotion order will be sorted by the following criteria and season stats, in order, amongst the eligible teams in the 2 leagues below them...


So Pro will be filled by the two AAAs, not AAA and AA.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.

Also, no need to get angry about it I really don't see a need for the caps.



Don't lose to the #8 seed and you don't have that problem. If you do lose to that #8 seed (who clearly is either 8-8 or worse in your scenario, because they're the worst team that made the playoffs) then why shouldn't they promote ahead of you.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.


If the 16-0 team lost that fast maybe they don't deserve to be promoted, eh?
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by nfratami

This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.


If the 16-0 team lost that fast maybe they don't deserve to be promoted, eh?


I've seen crazy stuff happen in the playoffs. Sometimes a really good team has a single bad game in the playoffs and doesn't get promoted. Last year, this happened in Oceania -- The Barossa Grapestompers came in as a #8 seed and managed to knock off the #1 seed Sth Queensland Crushers, who had beaten them solidly in the regular season. The crushers (who got sold to a new owner in the offseason and aren't quite the same now) were, by far, the better team, while Barossa likely wasn't ready for the pros. Yet Barossa would have been promoted over Sth Queensland. Note that, in AAA, Barossa is 8-5 this season so far, while a team that did really well in AAA last season is fighting for a low-rung playoff spot in the pros. Would Barossa really have been more ready than last year's dominant Crushers team? I don't think a team losing one game in the playoffs suddenly makes them a team undeserving of promotion while an 8-8 team lucking out and winning makes them worthy.

I think regular season record needs to factor higher in the list. Like, you should have the conference champ, conference runner up, then best record, all in that order.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:26:42
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose

I think regular season record needs to factor higher in the list. Like, you should have the conference champ, conference runner up, then best record, all in that order.


Regular season means nothing really, except which teams make the playofs and which get relegated.

Other than that, playoffs are the only games that have meaning.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:30:03
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
Originally posted by MrMoose


I think regular season record needs to factor higher in the list. Like, you should have the conference champ, conference runner up, then best record, all in that order.


Regular season means nothing really, only means what teams make the playofs and which get relegated.

Other than that, playoffs are the only games that mean anything.


Right, I realize that is how it currently is. Regular season NEEDS to mean something, though. Claiming regular season means nothing as a way to say that a 10-6 team last season was better than a very dominant 15-1 team is flawed. If regular season is that meaningless, why don't we just chuck out those 16 games and have constant tournament brackets on GLB instead?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.