User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Lots of atheists on the internet. Especially younger people. Kind of sad.

Atheists = theists

DUCY


This needs to be quoted again.


Needs to be explained more imo.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
The wheel in the sky keeps on turning
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Any atheist who wants to try to bury Christianity (or any religion) over minor details in a book like the Bible that was translated twice from the original language and is filled with metaphors and stories..... should try a different avenue.



Now, I might be reading into the bible a little too literally here, but when I'm a father, and I love my son (as all fathers do) but he disobeys a rule of mine, and doesn't ask for my forgiveness- how long should I put him into an oven for? I mean, eternity seems a little harsh on the little tyke, I think a good four hours at 325 degrees ought to sort him out.


Also, should I use an electric oven, or is gas good enough?


What about just using the broiler, or do you need even heating from both sides to assure proper redemption?


I'm quoting this because I think it is relevant to where we have went.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Asheme


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Lots of atheists on the internet. Especially younger people. Kind of sad.

Atheists = theists

DUCY


This needs to be quoted again.


Needs to be explained more imo.


Anyone who claims to be sure, and worse ACTS based on that certainty, of what happens to us when we die is a fool. An absolute unquestionable fool.

The only correct answer is "I don't know".

It is a well-documented failure of the human mind to try and seek order out of chaos. We see it in people that think things like the Kennedy assassination or 9/11 were conspiracies. Of course they weren't, but without a massive conspiracy, the human mind would have to accept the fact that a single peon like Oswald could kill a titan like Kennedy, and that's something the human mind is often to frail to do.

In short, humans are dumb, and we've always made up stories about messiahs and gods (You realize of course that the story of Jesus is almost identical to the story of Horus from Egyptian methology).
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 18:32:52
 
DT35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yeremiah
The wheel in the sky keeps on turning


 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Asheme



Originally posted by SteelersInsider




Lots of atheists on the internet. Especially younger people. Kind of sad.

Atheists = theists

DUCY


This needs to be quoted again.


Needs to be explained more imo.


Anyone who claims to be sure, and worse ACTS based on that certainty, of what happens to us when we die is a fool. An absolute unquestionable fool.

The only correct answer is "I don't know".

It is a well-documented failure of the human mind to try and seek order out of chaos. We see it in people that think things like the Kennedy assassination or 9/11 were conspiracies. Of course they were, but without a massive conspiracy, the human mind would have to accept the fact that a single peon like Oswald could kill a titan like Kennedy, and that's something the human mind is often to frail to do.

In short, humans are dumb, and we've always made up stories about messiahs and gods (You realize of course that the story of Jesus is almost identical to the story of Horas from Egyptian methology).


Horace Grant from the Bulls?
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

I admit that I am just as much of an asshole as many Christians. The difference is, I admit it, and they claim that they "love their fellow man". Religion doesn't grant you some kind of everlasting love for the human race. It makes you be nice to people who it is convenient to be nice to, and cruel to people who is it convenient to be cruel to. Just like atheists, just like Muslims, just like Scientologists, just politicians, just like everyone else on the face of the planet. Christianity doesn't teach and encourage love. Christianity doesn't create compassion for the human race. To act like it does is utter bullshit.

It sounds like your beef is with ignorance and hypocrisy, then. I agree that it is rarely as insidious as when coupled with religion, but don't conflate the two.

Christianity does engender compassion. As does Buddhism, Islam or any other religion, as they function, ideally, as paths to harmony for their people. Taken as a collection of teachings (speaking specifically about Christianity here), there is no incentive given. That's something that has been emphasized by our culture because we're a reward-based species.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Asheme



Originally posted by SteelersInsider




Lots of atheists on the internet. Especially younger people. Kind of sad.

Atheists = theists

DUCY


This needs to be quoted again.


Needs to be explained more imo.


Anyone who claims to be sure, and worse ACTS based on that certainty, of what happens to us when we die is a fool. An absolute unquestionable fool.

The only correct answer is "I don't know".

It is a well-documented failure of the human mind to try and seek order out of chaos. We see it in people that think things like the Kennedy assassination or 9/11 were conspiracies. Of course they were, but without a massive conspiracy, the human mind would have to accept the fact that a single peon like Oswald could kill a titan like Kennedy, and that's something the human mind is often to frail to do.

In short, humans are dumb, and we've always made up stories about messiahs and gods (You realize of course that the story of Jesus is almost identical to the story of Horas from Egyptian methology).


I'm not exactly sure that was what Ash was getting at. I was reading that more as atheism is theistic because it is a belief system which I categorically disagree with.

To your point, though, VT, I certainly agree with you. Religions are a human construct created to serve some base needs of individuals and societies. Which is why there are countless many of them yet they all exhibit some base characteristics.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
http://www.skepticsannotatedbible.com/abs/long.htm

That is also a pretty fun read.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


In short, humans are dumb, and we've always made up stories about messiahs and gods (You realize of course that the story of Jesus is almost identical to the story of Horus from Egyptian methology).



I agree with you. Humans are dumb compared to all the knowledge that could be out there. That doesn't have anything to do with there being a higher power. You could just as easily say that humans are flawed into believing that no God exists. That doesn't prove one way or the other.

And just because there is a similar story doesn't make one wrong or the other right. For all we know, all of these different religions might be close to the truth and just be distorting the truth a little over a misunderstanding, bad teaching, or bad translation.

I'm not so worried about the details. I believe that there is a higher power that started this all. I believe that we all have eternal souls. I believe that your eternal soul could suffer because of how you act on this planet. Even if there is no hell "as dumb humans try to comprend it", then I still believe in the "way" Christianity teaches you to live you life.

Last edited Oct 12, 2008 18:47:52
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by Asheme




Originally posted by SteelersInsider





Lots of atheists on the internet. Especially younger people. Kind of sad.

Atheists = theists

DUCY


This needs to be quoted again.


Needs to be explained more imo.


Anyone who claims to be sure, and worse ACTS based on that certainty, of what happens to us when we die is a fool. An absolute unquestionable fool.

The only correct answer is "I don't know".

It is a well-documented failure of the human mind to try and seek order out of chaos. We see it in people that think things like the Kennedy assassination or 9/11 were conspiracies. Of course they weren't, but without a massive conspiracy, the human mind would have to accept the fact that a single peon like Oswald could kill a titan like Kennedy, and that's something the human mind is often to frail to do.

In short, humans are dumb, and we've always made up stories about messiahs and gods (You realize of course that the story of Jesus is almost identical to the story of Horus from Egyptian methology).



I agree with you. Humans are dumb compared to all the knowledge that could be out there. That doesn't have anything to do with there being a higher power.

You could just as easily say that humans are flawed into believing that no God exists. That doesn't prove one way or the other.

And just because there is a similar story doesn't make one wrong or the other right. For all we know, all of these different religions could all be close to the truth and just be distorting the truth a little over a misunderstanding, bad teaching, or bad translation.

I'm not so worried about the details. I believe that there is a higher power that started this all. I believe that we all have eternal souls. I believe that your eternal soul could suffer because of how you act on this planet. Even if there is no hell "as dumb humans try to comprend it", then I still believe in the "way" Christianity teaches you to live you life.



If there was a god he wouldn't have let my kitten die.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheists aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as belief that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 18:51:11
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.



This is true.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.


It's the most logical in the same way a raindrop compares to the ocean. That is to say, you're dealing with something so huge, that the info we have is as close to useless as possible.

A firm belief in anything on that level is pretty lol.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.