User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dirty Toilet Paper
Originally posted by Bort

I've added a little description to the tactics page to help everyone understand how it works a little better.



Ok another dumbass question. What is the link to this thread? I am just not finding it!


Anyone have the link?
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dirty Toilet Paper
Originally posted by Dirty Toilet Paper

Originally posted by Bort


I've added a little description to the tactics page to help everyone understand how it works a little better.



Ok another dumbass question. What is the link to this thread? I am just not finding it!


Anyone have the link?


It's not in a thread, he added the note to the team tactics page. If you own or gm a team, look at the tactics page and you'll see the note.
 
Link
 
Duhhh, got it!! Thanks for helping with my "dumbassness"
 
mykez
offline
Link
 
Here is my situation. My QB got 36 plays and my backup got 28. We are a passing team and depend on my starting QB. Like I said he got 36 plays, and after the game he still had 83 stamina. I don't get it at all. My guy plays 2 plays in the 4th quarter. 2 plays!!! When we need him most, my backups come in and throw 8/19 in the 4th quarter and get 1 first down the last 20+ minutes of the game. This needs to be fixed.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 11:31:41
 
KilgoFoSho
offline
Link
 
Not to mention, these stamina things were put into effect to stop the bare-bones rosters that a lot of teams were using to max out on XP for their players.

That's great, but it just happens to come at a time when over 1,000 new teams were released, leaving new new team to compete for players when there are basically 40,000 brand-new open roster spots, not to mention good teams looking for depth now.

I've spent probably 40 hours on here this week trying my damndest to find human players who want to sign a regular contract where my team won't be broke. And now my defensive players won't even be back to 100 for the next game.

I agree with the spirit of the changes. I just think it's really an awful time. I had six players last year, and I was hoping to have them all be on different teams, to get different experiences.

I always thought guys who created every player on their team were sort of gaming the system. I've now had to trade for four of my guys, just to have a fighting chance.

I honestly think this was just awful timing for this to take effect. And with the note on the front saying more expansion teams may be coming... well that's just scary. Players are harder to come by, and they're also less effective at the same time. But I guess the rich will get richer.
 
Chaos Theory
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mykez23
Here is my situation. My QB got 36 plays and my backup got 28. We are a passing team and depend on my starting QB. Like I said he got 36 plays, and after the game he still had 83 stamina. I don't get it at all. My guy plays 2 plays in the 4th quarter. 2 plays!!! When we need him most, my backups come in and throw 8/19 in the 4th quarter and get 1 first down the last 20+ minutes of the game. This needs to be fixed.


Though we are lucky enough to have a very skilled backup QB, I also have an issue with how the QB sub is working.

Also, in 3 out of 4 games I've participated in, I've seen my backup QB come in at the last play of a drive and throw the TD, even though my starter did all the work. LITERALLY, the LAST PLAY, and gets the TD.

We need a setting that keeps starters in until the end of DRIVES, regardless of their current energy.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 13:19:21
 
Link
 
It is crazy how the most valued players went overnight from the skill positions to the Defensive line. Guess in the real NFL when your team drafts a non-glamour position over a QB or HB there might actually be a very big reason why they do.

Anyhow do not despair too much. We are ALL in this together, even most of the Pro league teams. If you have no backups then you ARE in BIG trouble. But if you have at least two on the d-line you can make it manageable. You just need to evaluate 4 areas and come up with a long term strategy.

1. What is the level of your next opponent? Do you need to play at hard or is normal or even relaxed an option? Could you possibly adjust your sub settings to have you subs come in even quicker?
2. What kind of offense will you run? Can a ball control offense keep your d off the field?
3. Daily Training = Relaxed except in RARE circumstances
4. Stamina probably became a Major instead Minor Skill attribute!!


I think that overall this is going to be very positive for the game. With the exception of the QB and Kicker you will get significant playing time whether you are a starter or sub. It will make it much easier to sign someone as a sub knowing this.

The biggest problem right now is just the shock of what happened. In addition the sub and play tactics are grossly to inferior to what is actually needed. These tactics are due to be introduced at anytime and I am sure with all the howling that is going on that Bort and the rest are working overtime to get them out. In the meantime those that can adapt and innovate will come out ahead. Part of what makes this game so much fun!!!
 
mykez
offline
Link
 
In my opinion, it is very bad for this game. Does Tom Brady take a break during the middle of a game? Does Peyton Manning take a break?

The simple answer is no.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mykez23
In my opinion, it is very bad for this game. Does Tom Brady take a break during the middle of a game? Does Peyton Manning take a break?

The simple answer is no.


Tom Brady and Payton Manning are pros who would have 80 stamina, not 10 or 20.
 
mykez
offline
Link
 
Does anyone in this game have 80 stamina? Or at least 50? My point is that this game was created a while back but not long enough to have 80 stamina.
 
Chaos Theory
offline
Link
 
"4. Stamina probably became a Major instead Minor Skill attribute!!"


I think it's beyond "major" right now. You can catch, throw, block, jump, cut, defend, etc in the 20's, but apparently you need to be 2 or 3 times that now to run around a couple plays without having an asthma attack.

OR... You need to have at least 2 backups for every starter. And those backups will cost you a gazillion dollars right now on the open market.

But what do you do? Adjust, I guess.
 
KilgoFoSho
offline
Link
 
So a high school player who plays a whole game is the same as a pro like Tom Brady? Because he plays a whole game? That doesn't hold water.

At least in baseball, when there's expansion, there was an expansion draft or something. Everyone thinned out.

This makes it actually LESS likely the good teams would trade depth. Not that we'd have anything to offer them, anyway. They want good human players, not cash.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Also some high schools have guys playing iron-man football, and some of those guys probably play 90% of the snaps in the game. They are also often some of the best players on the team, i.e. they are not just "high stamina guys".

I think this change can only be justified for gameplay reasons, it probably isn't going to translate 100% to "this is how college, pros, etc." work.




 
KilgoFoSho
offline
Link
 
Most sim fans are into realism. I know that I am.

I started with Dynamix Football Pro. Then Sierra ruined it.

I value realism. A team one of my RBs plays on just won 83-3, with the starter gaining 360+ yards with 5 TDs.

This energy "tweak" along with all the CPU teams has really watered this thing down.
 
Edonidd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by mykez23

In my opinion, it is very bad for this game. Does Tom Brady take a break during the middle of a game? Does Peyton Manning take a break?

The simple answer is no.


Tom Brady and Payton Manning are pros who would have 80 stamina, not 10 or 20.


The QB's right now have zero trouble playing the whole game with decent sub settings and will still be at 100 energy by next game. The huge problem is the ENORMOUS disparity between the O-Line and the D-Line right now.

You can have a level 10 DT who has spent all of his points in pure pash rushing skills, and he will be lucky to get a sack againt a level 1 CPU O-Line. Add to that the fact that even with 30+ stamina (which is 50% higher than any offensive linemen) and he will still be well below 70 energy at the end of a game.

If you are saying that we need 80 stamina to be where we expect to be, then that will be spnding every single point until season 3 or 4 including boosting every season and adding equipment. If They already aren't effective right now, how effective will they be with nothing except stamina? Now look at the Offensive linemen who can already play the whole game at 25ish stamina . Seriously what is the point of D-Linemen right now?

Nobody experienced wants to create one, because they don't add anything to the game and level slow. But they are the most needed position right now because they wear out so quickly that you need 6-8 of them on the roster. That can't be intended...can it?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.