User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato
We ought to start calling the East The Mike Vanderjagt's of Canada AA2. They are really good, but cant seem to win the big one.

Oh ya thats right, because you guys dont try. The championship game means nothing huh. Please!!! That is the lamest excuse ever. Truth is West does have more gutted teams, but history has shown that the West's best team is better than your best team. 3 seasons in a row.


The only ones who have said the East "doesn't try" is Wolf and Unspoken... obviously the East tries to win the big one. The West has been FORTUNATE to win all 3 championships. The same way Denver was FORTUNATE that Ed Hochuli blew Jay Cutler's fumble dead a few weeks back. That doesn't mean that the Chargers are better, or that Denver is better. One game never proves anything about two teams, unless it is completely one-sided. That's why they play series' in all sports that can physically handle a series. And even in series play, games often come down to a last second, game 7 hit-or-miss shot.

Again...

Season 2: Kensington (West) defeats Slack Jawed Yokels (East) 13-10
Season 3: Montreal (West) defeats Springfield (East) 19-16
Season 4: Crotch Lake (West) defeats Jetnation (East) 16-10

3 championships have been decided by a total of 12 points. 12. points. Did the West win the games? Sure. But does this prove that one conference is better than the other? Certainly not. We all how know easy it is for games to go one way or the other, even by 10+ points...3 and 6 point spreads mean nothing in this game.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 11:54:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai


Again...

Season 2: Kensington (West) defeats Slack Jawed Yokels (East) 13-10
Season 3: Montreal (West) defeats Springfield (East) 19-16
Season 4: Crotch Lake (West) defeats Jetnation (East) 16-10




The west won. The best team in the West IS Better than the best team in the East. Each year it has been proven. Regardless how many points it was by. All of the sudden the Sim Engine is Biased against the Canada AA2 East? Please!

 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato
Originally posted by SpearSrai



Again...

Season 2: Kensington (West) defeats Slack Jawed Yokels (East) 13-10
Season 3: Montreal (West) defeats Springfield (East) 19-16
Season 4: Crotch Lake (West) defeats Jetnation (East) 16-10




The west won. The best team in the West IS Better than the best team in the East. Each year it has been proven. Regardless how many points it was by. All of the sudden the Sim Engine is Biased against the Canada AA2 East? Please!



...clearly you do not understand logic. It has nothing to do with sim bias. It has to do with sim-randomness, and game-randomness in general.

And just for the record...We've played the GSP's twice, and beat them by over 42-27, and 42-24. Even a margin that wide barely proves that one team is better than another. A 1-6 point win means almost nothing.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 12:08:35
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato

Originally posted by SpearSrai




Again...

Season 2: Kensington (West) defeats Slack Jawed Yokels (East) 13-10
Season 3: Montreal (West) defeats Springfield (East) 19-16
Season 4: Crotch Lake (West) defeats Jetnation (East) 16-10




The west won. The best team in the West IS Better than the best team in the East. Each year it has been proven. Regardless how many points it was by. All of the sudden the Sim Engine is Biased against the Canada AA2 East? Please!



...clearly you do not understand logic.


The logic I understand is The West has won every year since the begining of AA2. The East has been playing this sharade for 2 seasons now, each time getting beat in the Big Game.

You claim that the West got lucky, "Ed Hoculli" call. So your saying that the West gets lucky every single season. Where as the other two claim that you guys werent trying. Which I declare B/S. You guys have been out to Prove that you are better for a while now. I knot JNDT tried to beat Crotch Lake last season, and couldn't, but thats right the Sim hates you guys.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai


We've played the GSP's twice, and beat them by over 20 points both times.


But yet you cant make it to the finals to play. Gsp if Im not mistaken beat the team that beat you. They showed up when it counts, not in some pointless scrimage.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato
Originally posted by SpearSrai

Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato


Originally posted by SpearSrai





Again...

Season 2: Kensington (West) defeats Slack Jawed Yokels (East) 13-10
Season 3: Montreal (West) defeats Springfield (East) 19-16
Season 4: Crotch Lake (West) defeats Jetnation (East) 16-10




The west won. The best team in the West IS Better than the best team in the East. Each year it has been proven. Regardless how many points it was by. All of the sudden the Sim Engine is Biased against the Canada AA2 East? Please!



...clearly you do not understand logic.


The logic I understand is The West has won every year since the begining of AA2. The East has been playing this sharade for 2 seasons now, each time getting beat in the Big Game.

You claim that the West got lucky, "Ed Hoculli" call. So your saying that the West gets lucky every single season. Where as the other two claim that you guys werent trying. Which I declare B/S. You guys have been out to Prove that you are better for a while now. I knot JNDT tried to beat Crotch Lake last season, and couldn't, but thats right the Sim hates you guys.



Now you're just being silly. As you can see above, I did not say the west got lucky. I said they were fortunate to win all 3 games. The Hochuli analogy is meant to illustrate not how one team got lucky, but that victory is not always an indicator of what team is better.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai




Now you're just being silly. As you can see above, I did not say the west got lucky. I said they were fortunate to win all 3 games. The Hochuli analogy is meant to illustrate not how one team got lucky, but that victory is not always an indicator of what team is better.



Yet the "better" team has lost for 3 straight seasons? Common now, that is being silly.

 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato
Originally posted by SpearSrai





Now you're just being silly. As you can see above, I did not say the west got lucky. I said they were fortunate to win all 3 games. The Hochuli analogy is meant to illustrate not how one team got lucky, but that victory is not always an indicator of what team is better.



Yet the "better" team has lost for 3 straight seasons? Common now, that is being silly.



:-/ I did NOT say that the East had the better team all 3 seasons. Those 6 teams are all very evenly matched. My point is NOT to prove that the East has had the better team in all 3 championships. It is that you can't use the championship game alone to prove which conference is better. But that is the only argument that anyone in the west has to offer, so I understand why you keep bringing it up.

But just for the record, my opinion is:

Kensington was the best team in the league season 2.
Montreal and Springfield were about even.
Jetnation and Crotch Lake were about even. (Though it is also my opinion that neither of those teams were their conference's best team that year either)
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai



:-/ I did NOT say that the East had the better team all 3 seasons. Those 6 teams are all very evenly matched. My point is NOT to prove that the East has had the better team in all 3 championships. It is that you can't use the championship game alone to prove which conference is better. But that is the only argument that anyone in the west has to offer, so I understand why you keep bringing it up.

But just for the record, my opinion is:

Kensington was the best team in the league season 2.
Montreal and Springfield were about even.
Jetnation and Crotch Lake were about even. (Though it is also my opinion that neither of those teams were their conference's best team that year either)


Ok just as you said for the most part the teams are evenly matched. Granted the West does have More gutted jobs, but as I have said forever and a day, that the teams in the West that go to the playoffs are just up to par or IMO better than the ones in the East.

Yet the West hears the criticism from you guys, because of some gut jobs. A few gut jobs and now West cant even compete with the East. That is what this is all about. Unspoken is the worse with it. No matter how many times you guys get beat no respect will ever get shown.

 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato
Originally posted by SpearSrai




:-/ I did NOT say that the East had the better team all 3 seasons. Those 6 teams are all very evenly matched. My point is NOT to prove that the East has had the better team in all 3 championships. It is that you can't use the championship game alone to prove which conference is better. But that is the only argument that anyone in the west has to offer, so I understand why you keep bringing it up.

But just for the record, my opinion is:

Kensington was the best team in the league season 2.
Montreal and Springfield were about even.
Jetnation and Crotch Lake were about even. (Though it is also my opinion that neither of those teams were their conference's best team that year either)


Ok just as you said for the most part the teams are evenly matched. Granted the West does have More gutted jobs, but as I have said forever and a day, that the teams in the West that go to the playoffs are just up to par or IMO better than the ones in the East.

Yet the West hears the criticism from you guys, because of some gut jobs. A few gut jobs and now West cant even compete with the East. That is what this is all about. Unspoken is the worse with it. No matter how many times you guys get beat no respect will ever get shown.



It's not about the gutted teams...that only made it worse. It's about how many top teams each conference has. The west has consistently had 3-4 strong teams every season, but the east has more like 5-8 strong teams every season. The teams that end up with the 5-8 seeds in the West would have a tough time beating the 9th team in the East, who misses the playoffs. That's always been the argument. The gutted teams just make it worse.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato

Originally posted by SpearSrai





:-/ I did NOT say that the East had the better team all 3 seasons. Those 6 teams are all very evenly matched. My point is NOT to prove that the East has had the better team in all 3 championships. It is that you can't use the championship game alone to prove which conference is better. But that is the only argument that anyone in the west has to offer, so I understand why you keep bringing it up.

But just for the record, my opinion is:

Kensington was the best team in the league season 2.
Montreal and Springfield were about even.
Jetnation and Crotch Lake were about even. (Though it is also my opinion that neither of those teams were their conference's best team that year either)


Ok just as you said for the most part the teams are evenly matched. Granted the West does have More gutted jobs, but as I have said forever and a day, that the teams in the West that go to the playoffs are just up to par or IMO better than the ones in the East.

Yet the West hears the criticism from you guys, because of some gut jobs. A few gut jobs and now West cant even compete with the East. That is what this is all about. Unspoken is the worse with it. No matter how many times you guys get beat no respect will ever get shown.



It's not about the gutted teams...that only made it worse. It's about how many top teams each conference has. The west has consistently had 3-4 strong teams every season, but the east has more like 5-8 strong teams every season. The teams that end up with the 5-8 seeds in the West would have a tough time beating the 9th team in the East, who misses the playoffs. That's always been the argument. The gutted teams just make it worse.


I beg to differ. Helifax came in it #5 last season, and wouldnt have a problem defeating your 5-8. I think your allowing the illusion of the gutted teams to cloud your judgement. 2 seasons ago Langley came in at #8. They where good enough to beat the team that all of Canada AA2 thought was the team to beat.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato
Originally posted by SpearSrai

Originally posted by TheCrazyTomato


Originally posted by SpearSrai






:-/ I did NOT say that the East had the better team all 3 seasons. Those 6 teams are all very evenly matched. My point is NOT to prove that the East has had the better team in all 3 championships. It is that you can't use the championship game alone to prove which conference is better. But that is the only argument that anyone in the west has to offer, so I understand why you keep bringing it up.

But just for the record, my opinion is:

Kensington was the best team in the league season 2.
Montreal and Springfield were about even.
Jetnation and Crotch Lake were about even. (Though it is also my opinion that neither of those teams were their conference's best team that year either)


Ok just as you said for the most part the teams are evenly matched. Granted the West does have More gutted jobs, but as I have said forever and a day, that the teams in the West that go to the playoffs are just up to par or IMO better than the ones in the East.

Yet the West hears the criticism from you guys, because of some gut jobs. A few gut jobs and now West cant even compete with the East. That is what this is all about. Unspoken is the worse with it. No matter how many times you guys get beat no respect will ever get shown.



It's not about the gutted teams...that only made it worse. It's about how many top teams each conference has. The west has consistently had 3-4 strong teams every season, but the east has more like 5-8 strong teams every season. The teams that end up with the 5-8 seeds in the West would have a tough time beating the 9th team in the East, who misses the playoffs. That's always been the argument. The gutted teams just make it worse.


I beg to differ. Helifax came in it #5 last season, and wouldnt have a problem defeating your 5-8. I think your allowing the illusion of the gutted teams to cloud your judgement. 2 seasons ago Langley came in at #8. They where good enough to beat the team that all of Canada AA2 thought was the team to beat.


Two seasons ago, London finished #8 also. And Thunder Bay #7. I guess I should have said 5-8th best teams, not 5-8th seeds. Halifax was one of the teams I was referring to in the top 3-4. Halifax, North Delta, Nanaimo, and Crotch Lake last year.
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
The problem with the west in the future is that they might win 4-5 in a row but the west has a very limited pool. The east can win 9-10 in a row starting this year. After your top 4 teams move up then what. The east has 9 teams that can move up and have success up in AAA.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
One of the lamest and worse responses to which conference is better is the hype of the "Championship game". Idiots who come in and brag that a team in their division won the championship thus means his division is better despite the fact that east has dominated the crossover games and scrimmages. Tkae a look at every game played between the 2 conferences for the past 3 seasons and it is very very clear which conference is deeper and better. If the East had won a game or 2 I would then consider everyone in the West utter shit but that's not the case as I have always said the top teams are good and competitive.

Once again it is not that the top teams in the West that suck, but the huge huge drop off after the 5th spot. This makes only 4 games of concern for the top teams where as in the East you have the top 9 or 10 that you have to have concern for and as Toronto showed last year and again this year even a 11th or 13th place team can bite a top team in the ass. That is not true in the west and has nothing to do with the top teams being dominate but how shitty the mid pack to bottom teams are.

Also look at how teams like Windsor and Saskatchewan have improved in the east, I remember 1 team in the west to go from bottom dweller to contender with recruiting and use of tactics.

And for the record I never said the East doesn't try for the championship game, I merely said "why try"? To me its a nothing game and doesn't warrant the time spent scouting as any east game we play does/should. I prefer to use those days to recruit, look over the new stuff for the up coming season, check out the teams moving up and down, reading about builds and tactics and PMing Unspoken and telling him he has a smallish dick....erson jersy.


Also want to point out that when Slack Jaw went to the championship game they were the 7th seed and just lost to the top West team.



Last edited Oct 9, 2008 15:07:16
 
djknick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Unspoken
Originally posted by Animalmother

Originally posted by SpearSrai



What the west needs isn't more trash talkers...what it needs is half-way decent teams. You can't tell me that you're having fun blowing out cupcake teams every week.


Yea the East is where its at... it's WAAAY more fun getting your ass handed to you by teams that belong in AAA+hehe


The East has been like this from the start. Some of us want to be in AAA but its been so hard to even make the playoffs never mind win the playoffs.


WAAAAAAA It's too hard! Us Peckers...we like it hard. Whiner!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.