User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > IS STRONGBASE BROKEN? (by WiSeIVIaN, the guy who posts threads that never really go anywhere)
Page:
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er


You obviously are stat-blind.

No one runs against us. The DEs on my team are in the backfield on every play, making it kind of difficult to register stats on passing plays.

Most DTs struggle mightily to get any kind of pressure at the higher levels. The OP wanted a DT that had good vision/confidence and was still able to get in the backfield, and I provided him one.


You provided him with a DT who has 1 sack and 3 hurries in 5 games, I think your GM was short changed.

This DT has good numbers in SA AAA#1
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=181753

USA Pro league
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26196

 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
Originally posted by j10er



You obviously are stat-blind.

No one runs against us. The DEs on my team are in the backfield on every play, making it kind of difficult to register stats on passing plays.

Most DTs struggle mightily to get any kind of pressure at the higher levels. The OP wanted a DT that had good vision/confidence and was still able to get in the backfield, and I provided him one.


You provided him with a DT who has 1 sack and 3 hurries in 5 games, I think your GM was short changed.

This DT has good numbers in SA AAA#1
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=181753

USA Pro league
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26196



Bwahahaha - you are completely blinded by stats.

You provided a DT from AAA who has 7 sacks on the season, all from one 255-0 game.

Then you pick one of the best, most well-known DTs who has 6 sacks this season, 5 from a 255-0 game.

If the OP wants to run through same game film and see penetration on pass and run plays even though the DEs I play with are excellent and make it difficult to get stats, then he can. And I'm always open to a discussion if he wants to take it to PMs.

But, obviously, I have no idea how to build players, a team, game plan or analyze builds/strategy, and my attempt to help the OP was just plain silly. I'm glad you picked up on that and put me in my place.

I'm finished with this little discussion, but it was fun - thanks!
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er

Bwahahaha - you are completely blinded by stats.

You provided a DT from AAA who has 7 sacks on the season, all from one 255-0 game.

Then you pick one of the best, most well-known DTs who has 6 sacks this season, 5 from a 255-0 game.

If the OP wants to run through same game film and see penetration on pass and run plays even though the DEs I play with are excellent and make it difficult to get stats, then he can. And I'm always open to a discussion if he wants to take it to PMs.

But, obviously, I have no idea how to build players, a team, game plan or analyze builds/strategy, and my attempt to help the OP was just plain silly. I'm glad you picked up on that and put me in my place.

I'm finished with this little discussion, but it was fun - thanks!


I am the DC of two successful teams, one of which is fairly close in talent to your team despite being in AA, so I do know about how to build a team.

Enjoy your season. I am sure you will get to 20 tackles and maybe another sack by season's end.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 19:55:47
 
kipperkalle
offline
Link
 
From what I can tell strength does 2 things for DT's:

- probably part of formula that decides if he gets pancaked or not.
- helps to not miss any tackles.

DT with str over 90 is useless against G with str of 50-60.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kipperkalle
From what I can tell strength does 2 things for DT's:

- probably part of formula that decides if he gets pancaked or not.
- helps to not miss any tackles.

DT with str over 90 is useless against G with str of 50-60.


But if there's an SA that says its based on strength, shouldn't strength perhaps do something pass rushy when grouped with that SA?
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by kipperkalle

From what I can tell strength does 2 things for DT's:

- probably part of formula that decides if he gets pancaked or not.
- helps to not miss any tackles.

DT with str over 90 is useless against G with str of 50-60.


But if there's an SA that says its based on strength, shouldn't strength perhaps do something pass rushy when grouped with that SA?


You would think, but unfortunately it doesnt work at all.
 
Link
 
I'm surprised the combo is so ineffective. Tell me wise, does your guy actually seem to get push on pass plays? I'm not talking about stats, but rather, early in the game (before confidence should be a factor) does Rhino "collapse the pocket" or push the guard back in the direction of the QB?

Another thing that would be interesting would be to increase speed but leave agility and see whether that increases the speed with which you push linemen back. ie speed affects your open field speed if you're running but it could also affect your ability to move players while keeping them engaged in a block etc.
 
StrinG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by kipperkalle

From what I can tell strength does 2 things for DT's:

- probably part of formula that decides if he gets pancaked or not.
- helps to not miss any tackles.

DT with str over 90 is useless against G with str of 50-60.


But if there's an SA that says its based on strength, shouldn't strength perhaps do something pass rushy when grouped with that SA?


It absolutely should, but the SA is apparently not working or has such a small effect that it doesn't help. We have tried lots of different set ups on str/agi/spd with strong base and none have worked.

Sadly right now they are pretty much wasted points, hopefully it will get fixed some day.

 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darren McFadden
I'm surprised the combo is so ineffective. Tell me wise, does your guy actually seem to get push on pass plays? I'm not talking about stats, but rather, early in the game (before confidence should be a factor) does Rhino "collapse the pocket" or push the guard back in the direction of the QB?

Another thing that would be interesting would be to increase speed but leave agility and see whether that increases the speed with which you push linemen back. ie speed affects your open field speed if you're running but it could also affect your ability to move players while keeping them engaged in a block etc.


Nope, no real penetration. He kinda just stands there and makes some coffee like most DTs do on pass plays a tiny bit of push, but a fairly negligible amount. I have him set on evasive for our next game, but I doubt it'll change much as DT pathing isn't a huge deal. I also gave him 3 points in agility with my last level up, as well as a temp +5 agility boost, though I'm less than hopeful.

My plan is to 2nd softcap agility, then 2nd softcap speed, fwiw.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StrinG
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN

Originally posted by kipperkalle


From what I can tell strength does 2 things for DT's:

- probably part of formula that decides if he gets pancaked or not.
- helps to not miss any tackles.

DT with str over 90 is useless against G with str of 50-60.


But if there's an SA that says its based on strength, shouldn't strength perhaps do something pass rushy when grouped with that SA?


It absolutely should, but the SA is apparently not working or has such a small effect that it doesn't help. We have tried lots of different set ups on str/agi/spd with strong base and none have worked.

Sadly right now they are pretty much wasted points, hopefully it will get fixed some day.



At least we are in agreement that strongbase is broken then.

Perhaps this means my thead isn't an epic failure? lol.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Strong Base is a waste!!!!

Strength: 88.69 Blocking: 24.01
Speed: 47.93 Tackling: 48.69
Agility: 61.69 Throwing: 8
Jumping: 10 Catching: 7
Stamina: 38.37 Carrying: 8
Vision: 31.41 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 29.83 Punting: 10
Pass Rusher Abilities
46471

2 sacks in 4 seasons

If you want to build a pass rushing DT you must go with high agility and speed and then shed block. Strong Base is worthless right now IMO.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 14:49:27
 
mgse
offline
Link
 
Might as well add my DT to the mix - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=290211

Strength: 84.88 Blocking: 21.17
Speed: 48.96 Tackling: 37.88
Agility: 64.88 Throwing: 8
Jumping: 14.92 Catching: 8
Stamina: 31.35 Carrying: 7
Vision: 40.08 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 25.97 Punting: 8

Pass Rusher Abilities
5 7 5 7 1

2 sacks this season, 6 last (3 or 4 before the nerf). This is with 40 vision...might help slightly, but my guy isn't destroying the competition, thats for sure. Its likely all his sacks are due to the shed block SA anyway, not strong base.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 15:03:14
 
kipperkalle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN

But if there's an SA that says its based on strength, shouldn't strength perhaps do something pass rushy when grouped with that SA?


Not arguing that it should do more, but unfortunately does what I said. I'm not too happy about it either.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak


DTs were nerfed after game 3 of last season, the change in league was not the chief difference. For an example of how the DT nerf affected some people, look at Edonidd's DT http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=64017&playoffs=0 who has a solid Strong Base DT but the nerf killed those builds.


This!!!

22 sacks in season 2. 23 sacks in season 3. 10 sacks in first 3 games in season 4. 1 sack in regular season and 1 sack in playoffs since then.

Strong Base was nerfed out of existence. I'm retiring my DT I posted stats above on after his contract runs out at end of season. I'm not even asking for money for lvl 32 upgrades. I think my level 21 DT could produce better stats against the same competition.

Last edited Oct 3, 2008 15:20:17
 
Drax
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
I love how, any time someone posts that something may not be working, people always find one low stat and instantly blame said low stat.

It could be possible that strong base actually isn't working. If it was confidence, you'd think that the player would have seen results at some point early in games, even with low vision.

If every stat is so important to softcap at every position, though, players will never touch SAs. I highly doubt you need 50+ in each stat for SAs to fire off or anything.

My DE has 36 vision and 26 confidence. Yet he's playing well this year. His build is working just fine despite 26 confidence:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=184345

Honestly, I think the big issue is simply that O Line loads up on strength, therefore strength based stuff is not nearly as effective. As people focus more and more on non-strength based stuff, it'll become more effective.


My build is really similar to mooses, just some SA differences and I have the same amount of sacks. I have 27 vision and 20 confidence.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.