User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
So then if the QB is attempting the pass, then his max velocity IS high enough to reach the distance at some angle. What situation would cause him to not choose this angle? Is that max velocity number the number that is calculated before energy and chemistry are factored in or after?


I think he is choosing the correct angle, or else the ball wouldn't get to the spot. I think that for whatever reason the WR doesn't think the ball is at a catchable height or within his radius when he reaches that spot.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
So the QB is hitting his mark, but the WR isn't even attempting the catch?
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
So the QB is hitting his mark, but the WR isn't even attempting the catch?


Sounds like progress to me.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
So the QB is hitting his mark, but the WR isn't even attempting the catch?


Yeah I think basically the receiver is getting there just as the ball hits the ground, which means he has no chance to catch it.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Staz

So the QB is hitting his mark, but the WR isn't even attempting the catch?


Yeah I think basically the receiver is getting there just as the ball hits the ground, which means he has no chance to catch it.


Could that have to do then with the medium/lofty passing settings throwing the ball at a higher angle on the z axis? I would assume that your vector math includes different angles for these settings to the bullet setting, which when you came out with the passing style option you said was the closest to what it was in season 1 2 and 3. On medium and loft, the QB is probably selecting the angle to throw the ball to a particular spot, but since he is throwing the ball up at a higher angle than on bullet, and not as flat, the slope of the ball as it comes down may be steeper, causing him to select an angle that is putting the ball the right distance but in such a way that the z coordinate of the pass when it travels that distance is 0. In actuality if he is going to throw the ball at such an angle, the target point of the angle he selects should be behind the one it's currently landing at, shouldn't it? Basically he should be throwing the ball at a spot further downfield than the reciever such that if the ball could pass through the reciever, it would land a few feet past him.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
But if the QB is leading him correctly, and putting the right angle to hit him in stride at hand level, then this is all on the WR correct?

If that's true, then the QB is fine, but the WR is having issues when wide open, that they're not experiencing when covered?
 
aspenwolf
offline
Link
 
there was a post stated here a min ago, and i think it's right on the nose

it's either jumping catch SA or diving catch SA that's working here
the diving catch SA is after the jumping catch, so if you have that one you'd have both

but wr's without those skills aren't 'reaching' the pass
wr's with them are

if i'm wrong on this, someone with a wr with a bunch of those SA's that are having this problem feel free to post some links
 
hud
offline
Link
 
I don't know if it has anything to do with it, but on almost all of the plays, the WR passes the CB (down field) after the ball is thrown. Is there anything in the Receiver and the defender crossing paths that could affect it?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Could that have to do then with the medium/lofty passing settings throwing the ball at a higher angle on the z axis?


Could be, although on long passes your angle is going to be higher anyway because it's long, unless your arm is a laser.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Brett Favre?

I think hud may have touched on something, and aspen could have something. If it IS the SAs though that are causing this, I wouldn't be fond of that being the case lol
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Note: I possibly have a lead on what's going on based on some code perusal for logic errors, but I could be completely off base, being kinda tired at the moment.

Running a bunch o tests with a modification to see (should be done when I get up, hopefully).
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rj414

Could that have to do then with the medium/lofty passing settings throwing the ball at a higher angle on the z axis?


Could be, although on long passes your angle is going to be higher anyway because it's long, unless your arm is a laser.


Ok but if the math is set to be higher anyway, then couldn't the added loft be increasing the angle even further?

I don't know if I'm remebering my physics right, but the angle that would generate the maximum distance when a ball is thrown is 45 degrees, correct? So let's say the QB selects that 45 degree angle... and then the fact that his passing setting is medium or loft adds a few degrees more, to make it 50 maybe - that would make the ball land just short.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Note: I possibly have a lead on what's going on based on some code perusal for logic errors, but I could be completely off base, being kinda tired at the moment.

Running a bunch o tests with a modification to see (should be done when I get up, hopefully).


good to know
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by rj414


Could that have to do then with the medium/lofty passing settings throwing the ball at a higher angle on the z axis?


Could be, although on long passes your angle is going to be higher anyway because it's long, unless your arm is a laser.


Ok but if the math is set to be higher anyway, then couldn't the added loft be increasing the angle even further?

I don't know if I'm remebering my physics right, but the angle that would generate the maximum distance when a ball is thrown is 45 degrees, correct? So let's say the QB selects that 45 degree angle... and then the fact that his passing setting is medium or loft adds a few degrees more, to make it 50 maybe - that would make the ball land just short.


Doesn't work like that - there's a floor and a ceiling on the angles independent of the pass setting. The pass setting really only takes over when the angle needed to get to the spot is very low and doesn't matter to the play.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rj414

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by rj414



Could that have to do then with the medium/lofty passing settings throwing the ball at a higher angle on the z axis?


Could be, although on long passes your angle is going to be higher anyway because it's long, unless your arm is a laser.


Ok but if the math is set to be higher anyway, then couldn't the added loft be increasing the angle even further?

I don't know if I'm remebering my physics right, but the angle that would generate the maximum distance when a ball is thrown is 45 degrees, correct? So let's say the QB selects that 45 degree angle... and then the fact that his passing setting is medium or loft adds a few degrees more, to make it 50 maybe - that would make the ball land just short.


Doesn't work like that - there's a floor and a ceiling on the angles independent of the pass setting. The pass setting really only takes over when the angle needed to get to the spot is very low and doesn't matter to the play.


Ok - well I appreciate the effort you've shown in attempting to address this issue, and I look forward to and wish you luck during your field tests. The commitment you've shown here does make me feel better about continuing to invest in this game, and I hope you find a solution soon.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.