User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed



It's not about whether everyone get's hit by it. It's that some get hit more than others.


No, they don't. Not over the long run. Everyone gets hit the same over the long run. Higher level players will feel it more than lower level guys, (stats move slower), but they'll get it the same as other high level guys.


Riddle me this.

Who gets hurt over the long or short run by decimals being left IN the game?
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed



It's not about whether everyone get's hit by it. It's that some get hit more than others.


No, they don't. Not over the long run. Everyone gets hit the same over the long run. Higher level players will feel it more than lower level guys, (stats move slower), but they'll get it the same as other high level guys.


It's not the same if you have to wait for it to even out. Your player being affected the same in the future doesn't win that game you lost in the past. And, it won't even out if you don't train on those attributes w/ the high fractions. It's all such a small factor that it probably won't affect much, but it does at some level.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716


Who gets hurt over the long or short run by decimals being left IN the game?


No one. Like I said, it makes no difference to me either way, and I don't think it makes any difference to anyone's performance.


I think we need ONE decimal, whether its training percentage, or stat percentage. THe current system is an ugly hack and makes no sense.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
And, it won't even out if you don't train on those attributes w/ the high fractions. .


YES IT WILL. You get fractional points at level on some stats.


If you chose not to train a high percentage skill, right now, you're being penalized. This would be the same.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:17:42
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Synovia

Originally posted by OSU_Ed




It's not about whether everyone get's hit by it. It's that some get hit more than others.


No, they don't. Not over the long run. Everyone gets hit the same over the long run. Higher level players will feel it more than lower level guys, (stats move slower), but they'll get it the same as other high level guys.


Riddle me this.

Who gets hurt over the long or short run by decimals being left IN the game?


The Game. You will have bugs if you write code poorly.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

And, it won't even out if you don't train on those attributes w/ the high fractions. .


YES IT WILL. You get fractional points at level on some stats.


If you chose not to train a high percentage skill, thats your choice, and its a dumb one.


Do you know what 'some stats' means. It doesn't mean 'all stats'.

Of course it's your choice. A choice because of the change. A negative choice. A choice that involves not training something else to make up for an unbalanced change.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:20:55
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed


Of course it's your choice. A choice because of the change. A negative choice. A choice that involves not training something else to make up for an unbalanced change.


Players already get penalized for partially trained stats. If you leave the training bar on a stat at 80%, it does nothing for you. This would be EXACTLY the same as that. Why do you feel this is some huge change?


I'm just talking about merging the fractions.

Having a player have 62.7 speed and be 85% of the way to 63.7 is just stupid. The system is just totally arbitrary.

I'd rather have him be at 63.55 speed, or be at 63 speed and 55% percent developed. I don't really care which. They're the same as far as I'm concerned. They're just both a whole lot less unwieldy than 62.7 and 85%
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:25:38
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
You just don't understand
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
You just don't understand


No, I fully understand. I just don't think you understand the simple math. Nobody is getting screwed here.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
I'm also talking about merging the fractions. But you're trying to tell the opposing side it doesn't matter if you stop counting fractions in the sim. This is plain and simply wrong.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
I'm also talking about merging the fractions. But you're trying to tell the opposing side it doesn't matter if you stop counting fractions in the sim. This is plain and simply wrong.


No, I'm not saying it doesn't matter. I'm saying it doesn't hurt anyone. Everyone has fractions. You're not getting any more taken away than anyone else.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Everything you say is inconsistent. We were taling about pre-training change fractions and you switched to post-training change %'s.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

I'm also talking about merging the fractions. But you're trying to tell the opposing side it doesn't matter if you stop counting fractions in the sim. This is plain and simply wrong.


No, I'm not saying it doesn't matter. I'm saying it doesn't hurt anyone. Everyone has fractions. You're not getting any more taken away than anyone else.


Wrong
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
I tell you what.

If you can come up with one good reason that decimals should get moved, you may convince me.

So far, all I am hearing is:

A. People want to look at integers.
B. Its inconsistent with the new training system, where progress is not a decimal.

~~~~
A. Ignored. I care about what my players do in the box score and the sim. Having more of an attribute is better than having less. Why would I willingly surrender points to satisfy other players sense of aesthetics.

B. This is a true statement. HOWEVER, the old system was completely consistent for all players. The new system is completely consistent for all players. If the old was equal and the new is equal, a combination of the two should also be equal.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Everything you say is inconsistent. We were taling about pre-training change fractions and you switched to post-training change %'s.


They should be the same thing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.