User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > 4 out of 29 Completion ratio to open WR…incomplete. Plays showing all of them.
Page:
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim
Originally posted by jdupuy3

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Sigmaforce



QB on the team I own is having a better season than last season for sure, more yards, more tds, better completion percentage -- go figure. In the whole SEA A #1 over half the QBs have 70% completion rate or more, and nearly all have over 60.

I'm not sure why people don't believe Bort anywho, why would he lie? If he says it hasn't been touched it really hasn't been touched as far as I'm concerned. I haven't noticed 'widespread' outbreaks of these types of plays in the games I've watched.


Our QB is hitting 69% of his passes. Our backup is doing about the same.


Are we complaining about the completion percentage?! NO!
We're not complaining about stats in the slightest.
We're complaining about the unrealistic nature of the sim.
Yes, we know the dots aren't precise, but there's a problem with the way they are now.


You fail. Just because the ball hits your dot does not mean it hits him in the hands. it could hit him in the back, the head, the leg the shoulder.

It would not be a dropped pass just because it hits him.

If you and i were out side and you had your back to me and I threw a ball and hit you in the back of the head. Would i then be able to tell everyone that you cant catch and that you dropped the ball. No. it would just not be caught simple. its not a catch but its also not a drop. The best i know there are not deflected passes by the offense. some of you seem to think that just because the player looks to touch the ball that it either has to be a drop or a catch but in real life this is not the case anymore then it should be the case in GLB. simple math = pass throw + pass not caught can = dropped pass, incomplete pass, pass deflected.

The sim could say QB Obama's momma throws to WR aint wortha nickel, pass hits aint worth a nickel in the back of the head pass incomplete. or it could just say QB Obama's momma throws to WR aint wortha nickel pass incomplete and we go to the next play.


BigDaddyTim (god what a pitiful name):

If you're playing the realism card, by your logic I suppose it's not peculiar for this to happen to a QB 6+ times in a single game? That's right, Peyton Manning is gonna hit Marvin Harrison on the back of his head twice, his left and right ass cheek, big toe, and left testicle once each in the same game. Gee, you'd think that Marvin would start to turn around or - here's a good one - PEYTON MIGHT LEAD HIM A BIT MORE.

This is why arguments that compare the sim to real life are idiotic. As you say, GLB is simple math. IF bort reviews his math and determines that these passes really should all be incomplete, then more power to him - modify the graphic to display it better so that the people building QBs can make an adjustment and determine if its an under or overthrow. As it is, I think the easiest fix would be for Bort to find a way to make the QBs lead the recievers more, I don't know if leading enters into the calculation at all but if it does then he may need a formula adjustment there.

But the bottom line is, your argument makes you look childish and stupid. I love people who just come out and blindly defend a sim that Bort tweaks every day because he knows it's not perfect. Go watch some film before you come up with these ridiculous rationalizations. Bort himself is even starting to concede that this should be looked into, and we don't require the input of Bug forum trolls any longer.

Thank you and have a nice day.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 19:30:17
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
How many times in the game does the "bug" show up as opposed to the WR catching the ball in a similar situation?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tfuerte
I'm thinking that there is something wrong with the WR seeing the ball right after he passes the CB. The passes are thrown right about when the WR and CB dot overlap. When you are watching the replays pause it right when the QB throws the pass, on most of the weird incompletes the CB and WR dots are right on each other, or the WR is making a cut. Anyone else seeing this, or is it just me trying to find a reason too hard?


No, that makes no difference whatsoever as to whether he makes a catch or not.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim

Originally posted by jdupuy3


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by Sigmaforce




QB on the team I own is having a better season than last season for sure, more yards, more tds, better completion percentage -- go figure. In the whole SEA A #1 over half the QBs have 70% completion rate or more, and nearly all have over 60.

I'm not sure why people don't believe Bort anywho, why would he lie? If he says it hasn't been touched it really hasn't been touched as far as I'm concerned. I haven't noticed 'widespread' outbreaks of these types of plays in the games I've watched.


Our QB is hitting 69% of his passes. Our backup is doing about the same.


Are we complaining about the completion percentage?! NO!
We're not complaining about stats in the slightest.
We're complaining about the unrealistic nature of the sim.
Yes, we know the dots aren't precise, but there's a problem with the way they are now.


You fail. Just because the ball hits your dot does not mean it hits him in the hands. it could hit him in the back, the head, the leg the shoulder.

It would not be a dropped pass just because it hits him.

If you and i were out side and you had your back to me and I threw a ball and hit you in the back of the head. Would i then be able to tell everyone that you cant catch and that you dropped the ball. No. it would just not be caught simple. its not a catch but its also not a drop. The best i know there are not deflected passes by the offense. some of you seem to think that just because the player looks to touch the ball that it either has to be a drop or a catch but in real life this is not the case anymore then it should be the case in GLB. simple math = pass throw + pass not caught can = dropped pass, incomplete pass, pass deflected.

The sim could say QB Obama's momma throws to WR aint wortha nickel, pass hits aint worth a nickel in the back of the head pass incomplete. or it could just say QB Obama's momma throws to WR aint wortha nickel pass incomplete and we go to the next play.


BigDaddyTim (god what a pitiful name):

If you're playing the realism card, by your logic I suppose it's not peculiar for this to happen to a QB 6+ times in a single game? That's right, Peyton Manning is gonna hit Marvin Harrison on the back of his head twice, his left and right ass cheek, big toe, and left testicle once each in the same game. Gee, you'd think that Marvin would start to turn around or - here's a good one - PEYTON MIGHT LEAD HIM A BIT MORE.

This is why arguments that compare the sim to real life are idiotic. As you say, GLB is simple math. IF bort reviews his math and determines that these passes really should all be incomplete, then more power to him - modify the graphic to display it better so that the people building QBs can make an adjustment and determine if its an under or overthrow. As it is, I think the easiest fix would be for Bort to find a way to make the QBs lead the recievers more, I don't know if leading enters into the calculation at all but if it does then he may need a formula adjustment there.

But the bottom line is, your argument makes you look childish and stupid. I love people who just come out and blindly defend a sim that Bort tweaks every day because he knows it's not perfect. Go watch some film before you come up with these ridiculous rationalizations. Bort himself is even starting to concede that this should be looked into, and we don't require the input of Bug forum trolls any longer.

Thank you and have a nice day.


I did look at a game. I played a game just to look at the passing. The passing works however not every pass that looks like a pass is a catch. This i agree on. what i argue is that not every pass that looks like a catch should be a catch either. it does not have to be a dropped pass or a defended pass it could just be incomplete.

I have 3 QB's and i have at least 3 WR my self so this does affect me. and figuring out what is going on is important to me. But looking at thins and always blaming the sim is just stupid. sometimes its just not going to go your way it does not mean its a bug. If you post in the bug forum then expect people to come to your post and try to show you why it is not a bug. When people show only the plays that result in an incomplete then yes it looks like a bug but the same play runs and its a catch it just shows that sometimes its a catch and sometimes its not and makes it look less like a bug.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
BigDaddyTim, you are a dumb ass with no clue. Yeah, the play works great against LVL 16 CBs with LVL 26 WR.....holly shit you have fixed everything. We should all be 10 LVLs above the team we are playing and everything will work great. I need to move back to BBB and play gutted team.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=91


the point is you are saying it happens on wide open players how better to get a test of wide open players then to play a team with cb's that can not cover the players they can not get any more wide open then that. if you were complaining that covered players never caught passes i would play against a us pro team and try the same thing.

You should look at the plays and the same plays you say dont work. some times they worked and some times it happens just like your plays the ball lands right on my dot and its incomplete. but the point is if it was a bug the result would be the same every time the play happened not just once in a while. what it does show is that it has nothing to do with the receiver because in my game it happened to my speed guys and my possession guys. its not the builds it just seems to be part of the game. the good part is it happens less then it happens about 3 out of 5 are catches. maybe 4 out 5 if you have better players then i do.
 
Kayoh
offline
Link
 
My QB has 70+ completion PCT in almost 40 attempts so far this season. He's the starter for an 0-3 team, so it's not like he has an amazing surrounding cast.
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
How many times in the game does the "bug" show up as opposed to the WR catching the ball in a similar situation?


All of the plays on the first post. The 4 at the bottom are the only times it worked in all of these games. I may have missed one or 2. So out our the 33 plays it only worked 4 times. A lot are just 10-15 yard passes, its not like I am throwing a 60 yard bomb.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
Originally posted by Bort

How many times in the game does the "bug" show up as opposed to the WR catching the ball in a similar situation?


All of the plays on the first post. The 4 at the bottom are the only times it worked in all of these games. I may have missed one or 2. So out our the 33 plays it only worked 4 times. A lot are just 10-15 yard passes, its not like I am throwing a 60 yard bomb.


It could be something to do with the defenders going for the INT when they dont have help over top. Some of these plays looks like the defenders are set on that. This could be causing a problem with a code for the Receivers or something making them not catch the ball.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
that isn't shit should have seen our games, tonight was even worse for incomplete's
dunno what's going on but it's bad for everyone it seems

we had 49 incomplete's in our game tonight, guess the lv 27-32 wr's decided to go on strike tonight
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 20:07:33
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
Originally posted by Bort

How many times in the game does the "bug" show up as opposed to the WR catching the ball in a similar situation?


All of the plays on the first post. The 4 at the bottom are the only times it worked in all of these games. I may have missed one or 2. So out our the 33 plays it only worked 4 times. A lot are just 10-15 yard passes, its not like I am throwing a 60 yard bomb.


Only showing up in scrimmages? Or is it showing up just as frequently in regular games as well?
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by winchester

Originally posted by Bort


How many times in the game does the "bug" show up as opposed to the WR catching the ball in a similar situation?


All of the plays on the first post. The 4 at the bottom are the only times it worked in all of these games. I may have missed one or 2. So out our the 33 plays it only worked 4 times. A lot are just 10-15 yard passes, its not like I am throwing a 60 yard bomb.


Only showing up in scrimmages? Or is it showing up just as frequently in regular games as well?


It is showing up repeatedly in regular season games as well - I am posting a case study from a scrimmage from this season - I'm going to go in now and have a look at my team's match from today and do something similar for you. I will post the case study in its own thread and I will add the second case study to the same one
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by winchester

Originally posted by Bort


How many times in the game does the "bug" show up as opposed to the WR catching the ball in a similar situation?


All of the plays on the first post. The 4 at the bottom are the only times it worked in all of these games. I may have missed one or 2. So out our the 33 plays it only worked 4 times. A lot are just 10-15 yard passes, its not like I am throwing a 60 yard bomb.


Only showing up in scrimmages? Or is it showing up just as frequently in regular games as well?



Both, we now have a seaon 1 passing game....short, short, and hell give them another short one.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 20:27:45
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I'm not going to post plays, but I've seen the same thing in a few SIMs. I was actually optimistic that we'd get away with an update this offseason that didn't have a major affect on game mechanics.

Major in-season tweaks always seem to over-compensate and end up costing my team a game. Last season my team lost our 3rd game because of the passing update changes as we watched a team we should have beat throw the ball all over us as their WR's caught the ball in triple coverage all game. I'm getting a very bad feeling about this. The problem needs to be found, it's definitely there. I just pray we don't end up with a another stretch of games like last season where the passing game is on steroids.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 20:46:09
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
How many times in the game does the "bug" show up as opposed to the WR catching the ball in a similar situation?


I've compiled data to address this question on this thread here, taken from 3 games - 1 scrimmage and 2 regular season games:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1114096
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
What's odd is that it happened to me 2 times in consecutive plays, but never before or after to my guy (http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=60044) from what I can see.

I noticed it happened Season 4 - Week 13 - in CPL vs. the Arctic Bay Yetis.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84607&pbp_id=6775380
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84607&pbp_id=6775429

I think our QB may have been set to favor scrambling that game (I don't have a QB so I don't know what the setting is called), based on his action in the pocket.

This year my guy seemed to catch the deep ball fine in these situations in the one normal game we've had.

However, I have had other teammates on other teams complain about this this year.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.