User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > The worse QB sim ever and I started in season 1.........INCOMPLETE
Page:
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Not if the WR's were built with more catch. They are after all WR's you would think catching would be pretty important if you wanted them to catch the ball.


No one's build stays the same you had to have added sp's to something maybe you messed them up some how. My center went from 10-15 pancakes a game to 2-4 a game after season 3. I did not blame the sim i blamed myself for messing up his build i have been here a long time and i have a ton of players some are good and some not so much. even with all my players i cant say i know the best way to build anyone but i do know that when i add points and the player gets worse its my fault and i have to fix him myself i dont just blam the sim everytime i get bad results i figure out what the problem is and i work to fix them.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
thats right what ever you do dont try bullet. dont try it in a sim either it never works and i only tell you this because i want your QB to be great.
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
Shrug went 13 of 15 with a short passing game. Just like a west coast offense.

Medium and long passing arent suppose to be sure things. When I tried the med an long we had incompletes also . Shrug I think its a good thing an more realistic. If everybody catches every pass then the scores of 80 plus will be regular. Listening to some that seems to be what they want.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
This game has become total bullshit. These are the worse sims I have ever seen with the QB play. This is total shit. I have a QB that passed for 13 TDs in our league playoffs and a backup that passed for 7 (so pissed I am not going to get the exact number) TDs. Now this......INCOMPLETE!!!!!!!!! What the hell. It's not my throwing and it sure the hell is not my strength. I know it is not my WR becasue they had mad numbers too, and great builds. This is just dumb, over and over incompete. Here are a few examples of the Bullshit:



I watched each of those plays, and let me comment if i may (and y ou dont need to point out that I dont have a QB or WR character, it's not necessary).

First, on several of those plays, the WRs were pretty well covered and just because the "dot" looked wide open, you have to remember that these are supposed to be representing real players. Defenders with hands in their face, running full speed at times, QB throwing a little sooner than expected, whatever. The point is, i looked up this QB's stats, and they arent as unrealistic as you try to make them out to be. DO you really expect your QB to have a 100 rating every game? Then you can bet the D guys will be in here bitching and whining, because THATS not realistic.

Hell, even Manning and Brady have shit games sometimes. Are you looking at the competition every time too? Your QB had some great games last season (against teams that you beat by 100), but had some pretty terrible games as well. A 65 QB rating against a team loaded with players 20 levels below yours, and a team taht you beat by 146 points? Another game with a 67 QB rating? A couple of 47s, a 24, a 65, and yeah, he had some great games mixed in. Isnt this how it should be, or do you expect every game to be played in the 90s and 100s? Last season's game logs seem pretty consistent with this season's IMO. About 3 good games for every bad 1. So far, your QB has 1 game with a 98 rating against a solid team, and a 50 against a really GOOD team. Sorry, but if you had thrown for 280 on 70% passing against that team, THEY would be the ones who'd be complaining because they have a really good D.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
By the way, I only have the numbers from 2006, but Tom Brady and Carson Palmer, both of whom had nice seasons, were sub 45% on passes thrown over 20 yards. Brett Favre was even worse, coming in at 33%. Long passes arent supposed to be high percentage passes, even if your QB does have 80 passing and 75 vision. It's just not realistic.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
By the way, I only have the numbers from 2006, but Tom Brady and Carson Palmer, both of whom had nice seasons, were sub 45% on passes thrown over 20 yards. Brett Favre was even worse, coming in at 33%. Long passes arent supposed to be high percentage passes, even if your QB does have 80 passing and 75 vision. It's just not realistic.


+1
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
I did not play my qb much last year and we ran all season till the playoffs. Look at the playoffs and you will see what I could have done all year if I just wanted to. We won the league an it was not even close. So before you start pointing out games you need to look at eveything.
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
Most of those passes are about 20 yards its not like I am throwing the ball 80 yards. Most of the plays are double moves and I can not help the cb can not run with the WR, so why should we be fucked over. If they completed 3 out of 10 that would be fine. Why have the pattern if it does not work.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
ok your right your QB is god's second coming and he should be at 100% comp every game the sim is jacked up and we should all stop playing because you got cheated. The rest of us can never hope to ever build a QB as great as yours and our builds suck that is why our qb's work with this jacked up sim. Oh please oh please mister winchester forgive me for ever doubting your wonderfull QB god.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
I did not play my qb much last year and we ran all season till the playoffs. Look at the playoffs and you will see what I could have done all year if I just wanted to. We won the league an it was not even close. So before you start pointing out games you need to look at eveything

Which is what i was trying to say. Heck, i dont even have an interest in your league or player, but i took the time to look into this to see if it's a legitimate gripe.
Youve got a great looking QB, but youve also played some really good teams. The game isnt, nor should it be, static. You shouldnt expect 70% completion percentages and EVERY single "open" pass to be completed. It doesnt happen in the NFL, and it shouldnt happen here IMO.

Originally posted by winchester
Most of those passes are about 20 yards its not like I am throwing the ball 80 yards. Most of the plays are double moves and I can not help the cb can not run with the WR, so why should we be fucked over. If they completed 3 out of 10 that would be fine. Why have the pattern if it does not work.


As I pointed out, 20 yard passes are NOT high completion passes. I wish i had last season's numbers, but i only have 2006, but as i stated previously, the top completion rates that season were in the 42-45% range for guys like Manning, Brady and Palmer. If you expect more than that, well, youre just expecting WAY too much out of your dot
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
This is about the incomplete passes that are hitting WRs not how has the best qb. Mine is not bad but there are a ton better. I never said I had the best qb in glb or even close to it. I have been saying there is something wrong with all the incomplete passes that are hitting wrs.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99


As I pointed out, 20 yard passes are NOT high completion passes. I wish i had last season's numbers, but i only have 2006, but as i stated previously, the top completion rates that season were in the 42-45% range for guys like Manning, Brady and Palmer. If you expect more than that, well, youre just expecting WAY too much out of your dot


His dot is QB god Dot to you mister and he is expected to be at 100% on all throws deep, med and short. He can even throw a 76 yard pass and run down the field and catch it for the TD with out even getting winded he dont do it because he dont want us to feel to bad about our lowly little dots but you better bet your bottom he can do it.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
This is about the incomplete passes that are hitting WRs not how has the best qb. Mine is not bad but there are a ton better. I never said I had the best qb in glb or even close to it. I have been saying there is something wrong with all the incomplete passes that are hitting wrs.


You THINK theyre hitting the WR, but dont you think that there are some passes floating over his head, or just out of reach? That never happens in real football? This is not 3 dimensional, so you have no idea WHERE those passes are in relation to the receiver, sorry
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
I did not play my qb much last year and we ran all season till the playoffs. Look at the playoffs and you will see what I could have done all year if I just wanted to. We won the league an it was not even close. So before you start pointing out games you need to look at eveything.


Forgot to comment on this, but dont you think a QB rating of 125+ in 4 playoff games is a TAD more unrealistic than your QB missing a wide open WR 20 yards downfield? Or do you really believe that just because you have a well built QB, he should be destroying competition (which is probably well built in their own right) every game? Im confused by this
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by winchester
This is about the incomplete passes that are hitting WRs not how has the best qb. Mine is not bad but there are a ton better. I never said I had the best qb in glb or even close to it. I have been saying there is something wrong with all the incomplete passes that are hitting wrs.


and bort told you that just because the ball looks to stop on your wr does not mean that is really where the ball stops.


look at all these bugs there is no way all these punters can keep getting the ball to stop just inside the endzone like that if they are that good howcome they cant get it to stop on the one every time. I can not talk for all of them but the 2 that are mine are damn good punters. they get them all to stop on the one in practice this is bs.....

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=164210&pbp_id=1860217

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=164210&pbp_id=1860662

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=164210&pbp_id=1862123

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=167258&pbp_id=1519549

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=167258&pbp_id=1521144

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=167258&pbp_id=1522513


or could it be that the replay stops once the play is over and once the ball passes the last reciever that could catch the ball the sim stops no reason to show you the ball going 30 yards over past the WR.

I know you think it should but i also think the sim should really show how far my punts go past the goal line so i can work on that more but it dont so it should not show your passes either.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 14:40:05
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.