User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdawg95
I'm beyond frustrated at the moment. You know what our offense did last season Hydro. . . and then we go for 1.9yds/carry tonight?

I love how guys who were solid performers for an entire season (and don't have stupid builds to one extreme) all of a sudden forget how to play football.

It's really getting to the point that I don't look forward to new seasons because all it has become is "starting over from scratch" every season.


Just because the LB is 4 yds downfield from the hole doesn't mean the HB can't go there does it?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187293&pbp_id=723573


I feel ya man. I've been watching these two preseason games very closely because I just knew something was going to be fucked up and I wanted to catch it sooner this time. Now we have to change our offensive philosophy to compensate for it if it's not corrected and I have no idea how that's going to work out so it could put that title run in jeapordy. I think I need to take a hard look at how much money I've sank into this game and reevaluate things.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Starting to fell the same law....I have invested money but even more than that time and I mean alots of time only to find a proper build cannot even find a gaping hole.As always we start out the season learning the game from the season before thinking we have a handle on the game only to have the rug yanked out from under our feet.This needs to be looked into cause there is no reason for a 5 season productive back to go to hell in a hand basket.
 
Mac Attack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
I think I need to take a hard look at how much money I've sank into this game and reevaluate things.


I know for a fact that my developmental players I've been working on aren't getting boosted.

And they very well may get retired to boost my current ones. I really hate to be one of "those guys" but it's all about the fun factor for me, and season upon season of having to change gears after building for one thing is really getting old.

I know, I know, it's "Beta". But it's pretty brutal to work your ass off to build players and a team and then have to completely switch it up.

Our guys and our team don't chase the magic "pot of gold" every season by capitalizing on things. We build very well rounded players who are not built just for one attribute. And when you come out in season 5 not even remotely looking like the same team you were in Season 4 it's pretty damn frustrating.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Having watched over 30 games now, and specifically looking at RB pathing on any Off Tackle input...

The entire pathing on the 'Off Tackle' play is completely broken now.

Firstly the way they line up is wrong, the RT and TE should be much tighter to the RG than it is now.

The intent is that the TE should be inside the LDE if possible, or to force the LDE to step inside a few feet.

How the LDE reacts is the key for the Offense on how the Off Tackle play will unfold as it is in effect a simple pre snap option read play.

If the LDE stays in his normal position, then the TE will block up on the LDE taking him out to the sideline, while the rest of the line block down to create the seam for the HB to run through, by sliding 'Off the Tackle's back'.

The FB leads the way, but has no blocking assignment, he makes a read on either the LDE if the TE needs help or the first LB he sees.

The 'Gap' is between the RT and TE.

At the moment this cannot happen as the TE is outside the LDE to begin the play.

In this situation the RT should block up on the LDE, while the RG blocks the NT.
The TE should now take the nearest LB.
The Off Tackle gap becomes between the RG and the RT.

At no point in a Off Tackle play should the TE block down.

At all times the FBs sole intent is to get through the gap and take down anyone standing there.

This is a power run and its intent is for the HB to be running at full speed at a LB that is either flat footed, back peddling or already blocked.

Right now we have a hodge podge Zone read play by the RB, but not the blocking to match it.

Bort, you need to review the Off Tackle in light of the above, as far as the starting alignment in GLB is concerned, the Off Tackle play should be running between the RG and RT and not the RT and TE.

The idea of the Off Tackle is from the HB sliding 'Off the Tackle's back'. Thats means different things depending on if he is blocking up or blocking down.

If he turn to the left the play is to his right.
If he turns to the Right the play is to his left.

As GLB is static, and the TE is always going to be lining up outside the LDE, the RT will ALWAYS be turning to his Right.

So the HBs first read should ALWAYS be for the Gap between RG and RT.

He should only EVER bounce outside if the LDE is pancaked, or to avoid a Blitz into that Gap.


+1 Off tackle wasn't perfect last season. But the new version is much much worse.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
I really hope this gets fixed. The pitch play is already broken, now with off tackle broken too all we have left is inside running and goal line running for the running game. If anything, revert it back to last season's codes, it's not perfect but it's better than what we have right now.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mac Attack
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

I think I need to take a hard look at how much money I've sank into this game and reevaluate things.


I know for a fact that my developmental players I've been working on aren't getting boosted.

And they very well may get retired to boost my current ones. I really hate to be one of "those guys" but it's all about the fun factor for me, and season upon season of having to change gears after building for one thing is really getting old.

I know, I know, it's "Beta". But it's pretty brutal to work your ass off to build players and a team and then have to completely switch it up.

Our guys and our team don't chase the magic "pot of gold" every season by capitalizing on things. We build very well rounded players who are not built just for one attribute. And when you come out in season 5 not even remotely looking like the same team you were in Season 4 it's pretty damn frustrating.


I agree 100%. The "beta" excuse just doesn't fly with me any more, not with as much of my real money that has been invested. Like you, we're not talking about builds that once were able to exploit flaws in the sim by loading up on one skill or the other and are now being exposed. These are all well rounded, high-level, championship players with excellent builds that have performed since day 1. It's not that we won't be able to adjust and overcome this setback if we have to, the question now is do we want to?
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
I really hope this gets fixed. The pitch play is already broken, now with off tackle broken too all we have left is inside running and goal line running for the running game. If anything, revert it back to last season's codes, it's not perfect but it's better than what we have right now.


Agreed. Without the option of effective off tackle running, or more productive pitch plays (which probably should've been the primary focus to be fixed this offseason) then all teams have to do is stack the middle against the run and effectively make you one-dimensional. That's great news for the passing teams because the secondary nerfs haven't been dealt with entirely either so now they have the instant advantage.
Last edited Sep 19, 2008 23:40:11
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Definitely noticing this a lot on more than one team I"m on in terms of defensive players just taking retarded vectors and running to the wrong place.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mac Attack
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

I think I need to take a hard look at how much money I've sank into this game and reevaluate things.


I know for a fact that my developmental players I've been working on aren't getting boosted.

And they very well may get retired to boost my current ones. I really hate to be one of "those guys" but it's all about the fun factor for me, and season upon season of having to change gears after building for one thing is really getting old.

I know, I know, it's "Beta". But it's pretty brutal to work your ass off to build players and a team and then have to completely switch it up.

Our guys and our team don't chase the magic "pot of gold" every season by capitalizing on things. We build very well rounded players who are not built just for one attribute. And when you come out in season 5 not even remotely looking like the same team you were in Season 4 it's pretty damn frustrating.

I purchased another team since I liked the game so much but with the constant wrong tweaks I am rethinking my future investments.I at least expected the running game to be similar to the end of last season not a totally new game.The fun is staring to disappear with each passing season and constant revamping at my expense.

The HB problem needs to be fixed asap or I feel others will start to feel the same.Especially when you have built solid builds from day one and then find out they are a total waste.Of course we will be told we are not calling the right plays our or offensive line is not capable of holding there blocks.

In short get rid of the delay and work on pathing issues.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Some are still correctly pathed:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189197&pbp_id=383680

I'm not saying it's all fine now. I am saying, it's not as consistently bad as some people seem to think it is. A big key is just letting more go through the G/T hole, as others have mentioned.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Some are correct but some very obvious ones are not.What worked last season is not working this season and that is the frustration.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Some are still correctly pathed:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189197&pbp_id=383680

I'm not saying it's all fine now. I am saying, it's not as consistently bad as some people seem to think it is. A big key is just letting more go through the G/T hole, as others have mentioned.


I agree I have seen some plays that are running correctly but there are enough bad ones right now that its disrupting the flow of the game and killing drives at very inopportune times. By doing so it takes us back to square one when we had no advanced tactics and had to rely on a lucky roll by the sim to pick up those yards.

With the addition of the advanced AI (an excellent addition to this game IMO) we were able to take chance out of the equation by scripting certain plays that we know have a high % success rate given the right builds. Now we are simply going back to relying on the sim to be nice to us if this doesn't get corrected immediately. To compensate we have to change our offensive philosophy and replace those plays with something else that may or may not work well with the overall game plan. It takes a once proven formula and scrambles it all to hell. We'll have to go back to the drawing board to find the right formula again and it could mean the difference in home field advantage or even a championship considering some of us were very very close last season and have/had everything set and ready to go to possibly get to the top. And as high levels as some of our players are the window of opportunity gets smaller and smaller each passing season.

It's just very frustrating that this happens every season.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 00:17:02
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
Originally posted by Ken1

Some are still correctly pathed:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189197&pbp_id=383680

I'm not saying it's all fine now. I am saying, it's not as consistently bad as some people seem to think it is. A big key is just letting more go through the G/T hole, as others have mentioned.


I agree I have seen some plays that are running correctly but there are enough bad ones right now that its disrupting the flow of the game and killing drives at very inopportune times. By doing so it takes us back to square one when we had no advanced tactics and had to rely on a lucky roll by the sim to pick up those yards.

With the addition of the advanced AI (an excellent addition to this game IMO) we were able to take chance out of the equation by scripting certain plays that we know have a high % success rate given the right builds. Now we are simply going back to relying on the sim to be nice to us if this doesn't get corrected immediately. To compensate we have to change our offensive philosophy and replace those plays with something else that may or may not work well with the overall game plan. It takes a once proven formula and scrambles it all to hell. We'll have to go back to the drawing board to find the right formula again and it could mean the difference in home field advantage or even a championship considering some of us were very very close last season and have/had everything set and ready to go to possibly get us to the top.

It's just very frustrating that this happens at the beginning of every season.


I see the pitch play as screwed up to the point I'm reluctant to use it.

At this point I'm not seeing the off tackle play screwed up to the same extent. Again, I'm not saying that it's all the way it should be; I just feel as if the anger is disproportionate to the degree of the problem.

Anytime anything changes even a little, it's "The sky is falling!" Again, the off tackle play worked better last season, but I think Bort gets the message to let it go through the G/T hole, and I think it'll be all right pretty soon. And it's already not so awful to make me afraid to use it, personally.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

Originally posted by Ken1


Some are still correctly pathed:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189197&pbp_id=383680

I'm not saying it's all fine now. I am saying, it's not as consistently bad as some people seem to think it is. A big key is just letting more go through the G/T hole, as others have mentioned.


I agree I have seen some plays that are running correctly but there are enough bad ones right now that its disrupting the flow of the game and killing drives at very inopportune times. By doing so it takes us back to square one when we had no advanced tactics and had to rely on a lucky roll by the sim to pick up those yards.

With the addition of the advanced AI (an excellent addition to this game IMO) we were able to take chance out of the equation by scripting certain plays that we know have a high % success rate given the right builds. Now we are simply going back to relying on the sim to be nice to us if this doesn't get corrected immediately. To compensate we have to change our offensive philosophy and replace those plays with something else that may or may not work well with the overall game plan. It takes a once proven formula and scrambles it all to hell. We'll have to go back to the drawing board to find the right formula again and it could mean the difference in home field advantage or even a championship considering some of us were very very close last season and have/had everything set and ready to go to possibly get us to the top.

It's just very frustrating that this happens at the beginning of every season.


I see the pitch play as screwed up to the point I'm reluctant to use it.

At this point I'm not seeing the off tackle play screwed up to the same extent. Again, I'm not saying that it's all the way it should be; I just feel as if the anger is disproportionate to the degree of the problem.

Anytime anything changes even a little, it's "The sky is falling!" Again, the off tackle play worked better last season, but I think Bort gets the message to let it go through the G/T hole, and I think it'll be all right pretty soon. And it's already not so awful to make me afraid to use it, personally.


I can understand your point of view but it depends on the % of that certain play you are using in your tactics. If it's a "bread and butter" play then it becomes a bigger problem. The ineffectiveness of the pitch play compounds the problem now because you are limited to mostly inside runs that haven't been nerfed. That's easy to defend against so a smart DC will stack the line against that and force a team to throw. You might say that a team should be able to pass the ball well enough to compensate for it but then you're also saying that an OC should have to change his entire approach to game planning to do so. Not every team wants to be one dimensional. A good offensive team will use both phases of the game to its advantage. There's a lot of time and effort that goes into developing an extensive AI package that would have to be corrected just for this one simple flaw.

I hope you are right that Bort gets the message because that's what this discussion is for. We want to stress the importance of making it work correctly BEFORE the season starts so that we don't have to scramble to make these changes and miss our window of opportunity again. Like I said, the frustration comes from having to deal with this exact type of thing every season and its just getting old.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
btw....IMO the pitch play has been a known problem from the start and that should have been the focus to correct this offseason, not a play that was working well for the most part. Let's fix the OBVIOUS problems first and then worry about minor tweaks later, please.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.