User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Not necessarily.
Besides, the only thing to add is Catching. Kinda makes sense for Coverage LB, but on the other hand, 3 of the 4 Secondary archetypes don't even have Catching. P.S. I couldn't help but notice you didn't the same argument for WRs/DBs.


I support the same argument for any positional interactions CB/WR; TE/LB; DL/OL. There's no variance in my argument I didn't notice the CB/WR but that needs to be fixed too
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil

One thing I thought of (and to be honest might have already been suggested in 55 pages). Could you maybe make an archtype "Classic" For each position, and have it be basically the same as it currently is, with no bonus or penalty SAs etc?


bumping that

shamelessly of course
 
Rich0523
offline
Link
 
Probably not for some positions it will be overpowered compared to the new archetypes.
 
xsujx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
SUP SCATFB SUP

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 8
Speed: 147.38 (+46)
Agility: 86.39 (+3)
Jumping: 21.38
Stamina: 48 (+3)
Vision: 32.38
Confidence: 50.38

Football Skills
Blocking: 8
Catching: 80.38
Tackling: 10
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 51.38
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8

Special Abilities
Blocking Abilities
Hands: 0
Lead Block: 0
Spot Blitz: 0
Strong Arm: 0
Pancake: 0

Offensive Abilities
Cover Up: 2
Sticky Hands: 3
Power Through: 4
Quick Cut: 11
Dive for Yardage: 1

Additional Abilities
First Step: 12
Veteran Abilities
Quick: 15
Track Star: 15
Mr. Reliable: 15
Scat Back: 15


Lovely. Although the idea of archetypes is intriguing, there's plenty of room for disaster.

And what for? So some dissatisfied people can get more of the training combos they wanted doable and optimal capping order for the specific build they've always wanted? Hasn't there always been the ability to make a scatback FB, or a "power" WR, or toughguy CB? Is it wrong to think that making such specialized builds shouldn't entail some minor sacrifices?

It's like watching the unraveling of D&D when all the insecure little emo kids complained that super character classes should be made without any consequence. At least the panicky calls of "NERF! NERF!!" over the coming seasons will be mildly amusing.
Edited by xsujx on Feb 11, 2010 18:49:30
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xsujx
Lovely. Although the idea of archetypes is intriguing, there's plenty of room for disaster.

And what for? So some dissatisfied people can get more of the training combos they wanted doable and optimal capping order for the specific build they've always wanted? Hasn't there always been the ability to make a scatback FB, or a "power" WR, or toughguy CB? Is it wrong to think that making such specialized builds shouldn't entail some minor sacrifices?

It's like watching the unraveling of D&D when all the insecure little emo kids complained that super character classes should be made without any consequence. At least the panicky calls of "NERF! NERF!!" over the coming seasons will be mildly amusing.


That player he just linked will be completely fucking worthless vs anyone with 1/10 of a brain
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
i dont see the logic behind how speedster WR have vision and catching as majors... yeah those things will help for an ideal build, but isnt the point of arch types to be not ideal for all situations? speedster WRs in real life usually dont have the best hands in the world. troy williamson anyone?

inb4dotball/=rl
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Worker 3
i dont see the logic behind how speedster WR have vision and catching as majors... yeah those things will help for an ideal build, but isnt the point of arch types to be not ideal for all situations? speedster WRs in real life usually dont have the best hands in the world. troy williamson anyone?

inb4dotball/=rl


Williamson's problem has always been vision, but point taken
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo

3 of the 4 Secondary archetypes don't even have Catching.

i recommended a play making CB archetype that had catching... but since asking for new archetypes is ngth atm, the current ones should be fixed so that catching is included in the ALG, or tell us that catching does pretty much nothing for INTs. either or.
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 11, 2010 20:05:04
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Worker 3
i dont see the logic behind how speedster WR have vision and catching as majors... yeah those things will help for an ideal build, but isnt the point of arch types to be not ideal for all situations? speedster WRs in real life usually dont have the best hands in the world. troy williamson anyone?

inb4dotball/=rl


Because in this game vision and catching go into a WR's ability to catch the ball on the run. Lower vision and catching means a speedster has to slow down to catch the ball = the point of being a speedster--outrunning everyone--is gone.
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Because in this game vision and catching go into a WR's ability to catch the ball on the run. Lower vision and catching means a speedster has to slow down to catch the ball = the point of being a speedster--outrunning everyone--is gone.


well then there should be a penalty to catch% or something (i dont think thats really possible though.) otherwise every deep ball is going to be caught, which isnt the most realistic thing in the world... that is if we are going for realism. if not, carry on.
or maybe a bigger penalty to pass quality on deep balls, but then QBs will complain.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Worker 3

i recommended a play making CB archetype that had catching... but since asking for new archetypes is ngth atm, the current ones should be fixed so that catching is included in the ALG, or tell us that catching does pretty much nothing for INTs. either or.


A DB is just WR who can't catch.
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
A DB is just WR who can't catch.


I as a FS resent that remark... albeit its true, but catching should at least be a minor on more than 1 archetype if it indeed has a large role in the INT roll (which makes sense... then again this is GLB) DBs still have better hands than the d line.
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 11, 2010 20:21:23
 
xsujx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
That player he just linked will be completely fucking worthless vs anyone with 1/10 of a brain


While that may be the case, the potential for really kinky games happening still exist. And that was just one specific example. In any case, whether that particular player would be fail in no way has anything to do with the fact that all of these "archetypes" could already be made. It just requires putting together a good build plan and not caring what the self-proclaimed High Priests of Builds think. Now we're just handing a crutch to all of those who were too gutless to offend the Priests by doing their own work and putting out a more "unique" player that works.

And you know those same agents too afraid to think and figure things out for themselves will be back on the position forums with their usual "Tell me where to put my SPs!" and "Tell me what to train!" cries. The same zealots will be there to tell them just what to do. So much for the end of "cookie-cutter" builds.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Worker 3
it should at least be a minor. they at least have better hands than the d line.


True, but is anybody taking catching past 50 on a CB anyway? I agree they can use it, but do they need it high enough to benefit from ALGs?
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
True, but is anybody taking catching past 50 on a CB anyway? I agree they can use it, but do they need it high enough to benefit from ALGs?


there are some people who are thinking about trying going higher than 50 with the supposed bump in PD and INT chances.

i think there would be more people who would do it if there was more solid evidence or a more concrete answer as to how much impact catching has on the INT roll.

and the same can be said for stamina and confidence... how many CBs take that over 50? my lvl 63 had catching capped before confidence...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.