User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Demboyz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Hahaha now the RB owners whine after the LBs got strength/tackling. Awesome
The fumbling on kickoffs/punts is fucked up though. KR/PR are usually CBs or WRs with fuck all for carrying but they do fine in the NFL (some HBs too, but even then they are just the elusive ones).


lol
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Demboyz
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Demboyz


Originally posted by firehazard



Originally posted by Demboyz




bort made morale more relevant this season so ppl will invest into confidence and def knows most offensive players wont invest into confidence as much as they need to so they attacked that which leads to abilities decreasing cuz your morale is down so that 50+ carry at the beginning of the game may not be 50+ carry anymore. result= more FF opportunities


Where did you come up with that one?


look at the summary tab you will see the morale bar next to the energy bar. the ppl that are fumbling alot if you chek there energy and morale its probably below 30 at least for the morale part it could be higher if they get energy and moral bonuses from other players.

im guessing thats the case


Wrong.


so morale has no significance on the "substantial increased of FF" this season


That's not what I said.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Demboyz

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by Demboyz



Originally posted by firehazard




Originally posted by Demboyz





bort made morale more relevant this season so ppl will invest into confidence and def knows most offensive players wont invest into confidence as much as they need to so they attacked that which leads to abilities decreasing cuz your morale is down so that 50+ carry at the beginning of the game may not be 50+ carry anymore. result= more FF opportunities


Where did you come up with that one?


look at the summary tab you will see the morale bar next to the energy bar. the ppl that are fumbling alot if you chek there energy and morale its probably below 30 at least for the morale part it could be higher if they get energy and moral bonuses from other players.

im guessing thats the case


Wrong.


so morale has no significance on the "substantial increased of FF" this season


That's not what I said.


It's exactly what you said.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
My LVL 16 Elusive RB had 0 fumbles.
 
JSSynister
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
My LVL 16 Elusive RB had 0 fumbles.


playing in -
USA BBB #14
Lv 1-13, 10-17 Suggested

doesn't really prove much either way.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by UnderDogs
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Demboyz


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Originally posted by Demboyz




Originally posted by firehazard





Originally posted by Demboyz






bort made morale more relevant this season so ppl will invest into confidence and def knows most offensive players wont invest into confidence as much as they need to so they attacked that which leads to abilities decreasing cuz your morale is down so that 50+ carry at the beginning of the game may not be 50+ carry anymore. result= more FF opportunities


Where did you come up with that one?


look at the summary tab you will see the morale bar next to the energy bar. the ppl that are fumbling alot if you chek there energy and morale its probably below 30 at least for the morale part it could be higher if they get energy and moral bonuses from other players.

im guessing thats the case


Wrong.


so morale has no significance on the "substantial increased of FF" this season


That's not what I said.


It's exactly what you said.


Nope. I agree that morale plays a good-sized part in the equation. Just that FFs are happening a lot at much higher morale and energy than 30.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JSSynister
Originally posted by Darkus Black

My LVL 16 Elusive RB had 0 fumbles.


playing in -
USA BBB #14
Lv 1-13, 10-17 Suggested

doesn't really prove much either way.


Equally matched teams with newer builds.
 
JSSynister
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by JSSynister

Originally posted by Darkus Black


My LVL 16 Elusive RB had 0 fumbles.


playing in -
USA BBB #14
Lv 1-13, 10-17 Suggested

doesn't really prove much either way.


Equally matched teams with newer builds.


yes but at that lvl, majority of defensive players are still getting speed and agility and vision up, and have at best average tackling and strength.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by JSSynister

Originally posted by Darkus Black


My LVL 16 Elusive RB had 0 fumbles.


playing in -
USA BBB #14
Lv 1-13, 10-17 Suggested

doesn't really prove much either way.


Equally matched teams with newer builds.


The Power Tackler VA is definitely a force for lvl 17 players, so good job avoiding the fumbles. . .

Mod trolling. . .awesome.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
You do realize that people experiment in the preseason, particularly when there are drastic changes like there has been this season with new VAs, a reduction in broken tackles, new plays, a defensive play creator and boost resets.

Teams that generally force fumbles will continue to force fumbles unless teams adjust. Teams that generally lose fumbles will continue to lose a lot of fumbles unless they adjust. It really is that simple.

Do I think that elusive backs should need 68 carrying and 60 strength to not fumble more than a half dozen times a season? No, I think it is beyond stupid but it is what it is and you can whine or fix the builds because nerfing something after the last vet reset is dumb unless we get yet another vet reset. I suggested toning fumbles back in the preseason before the final vet resets happened and got flamed. So instead of crying I reset VAs, added carrying and now force the fumbles instead of fumble. My backs will continue to struggle until later this season but once adjusted they will do quite well as always.

There are a ton of factors involved but none of it is random. How many motivational speakers do you have? How often are you running the same play? Is there more than 1 player on the DC at each position and what are the sub settings, how high is the confidence of the entire team, what are the builds like of the team that you are playing, etc.


I agree that it's not random, and that the reason this is happening to some teams and not others is a combination of offensive and defensive builds. I am certain that many teams that had no FF problem in game 1 will experience it at some point in the season when they face a team set up to force fumbles, unless they were smart enough to hold their boosts and can rapidly increase the strength and carrying on their non-powerback ball carriers.

 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard
But if they make the first tackle roll and the FF roll fails, sure tackler doesn't help to make the FF at all. Sure tackler would only help create a few FFs on the 2nd roll attempt, but it couldn't be many.

I attribute it to people using less AVAs and using more power tackler and helmet crash. None of the FF machines I've seen are using sure tackler.


firehazard,

The main argument that the change in Sure Tackler has aided the increase in fumbling (which Bort agreed with earlier in this thread) is that the fixed Sure Tackler VA takes some of the risk out of using the Power Tackler VA (as would David vs. Goliath, as Deathblade pointed out in this thread somewhere). It also means that the second roll creates a second chance to force a fumble, but I agree with you that the odds of that happening are probably not that high.

 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gyuri1

In fairness, though, Bort, fixing Sure Tackler has, in my opinion, made Power Tackler a much more powerful VA this season than it was previously.


I agree that you are likely right in that respect. It has been discussed that sure tackler should net a penalty to FF's, or use the original roll in calculations etc, if requiring a second roll. It's supposed to help you make tackles, not make you a fumble machine.


Haven't read through the whole thread to see how this was addressed, but I'm assuming the folks who make money from this venture put that kind of effort in. My thoughts on preventing Sure Tackler from making Power Tackler overpowered: only have Sure Tackler work when wrap-up tackling is being used. Problem solved.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by JSSynister


Originally posted by Darkus Black



My LVL 16 Elusive RB had 0 fumbles.


playing in -
USA BBB #14
Lv 1-13, 10-17 Suggested

doesn't really prove much either way.


Equally matched teams with newer builds.


The Power Tackler VA is definitely a force for lvl 17 players, so good job avoiding the fumbles. . .

Mod trolling. . .awesome.


Trolling? Do you even understand what you are saying?

I was adding to the discussion, just showing that lower levels are not experiencing problems. It helps to bring focus towards where the issues lie. Now just calm yourself down before you do yourself some mischief.
 
Link
 
va reset, here we come.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by UnderDogs
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Demboyz


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Originally posted by Demboyz




Originally posted by firehazard





Originally posted by Demboyz






bort made morale more relevant this season so ppl will invest into confidence and def knows most offensive players wont invest into confidence as much as they need to so they attacked that which leads to abilities decreasing cuz your morale is down so that 50+ carry at the beginning of the game may not be 50+ carry anymore. result= more FF opportunities


Where did you come up with that one?


look at the summary tab you will see the morale bar next to the energy bar. the ppl that are fumbling alot if you chek there energy and morale its probably below 30 at least for the morale part it could be higher if they get energy and moral bonuses from other players.

im guessing thats the case


Wrong.


so morale has no significance on the "substantial increased of FF" this season


That's not what I said.


It's exactly what you said.

it's kind of weird, and sort of depressing, how many people think that since bort allows people to see end morale after games now, that he changed the role of morale in this game. it's exactly how it was last season. alot of people wanted to see end game morale if only to prove the importance of confidence, and while it's had that effect, it's arrived there at a somewhat different path then intended.
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 05:31:02
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.