User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03


Anyways, this thread is so far off topic now. Going to bed. Nice chatting with you iceman, get some sleep


Bye. If you'd like to continue tomorrow and respond to my post, I'd love to hear what you have to say. Sweet dreams
 
cbtd10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
its too long to read all 800 posts and i'm sure its been brought up.

But if it takes 80 strength and 80 tackling to "stone" the RB.....then i think 50 & 50 should probably trip him up most of the time. I think players with low tackling and strength should get "run through" more often but still tackled. We see all the time in football the CB brings down the RB but he gets 3-4 yards after the hit stumbling and being dragged to the ground.

I think that is more realistic and gives you reason to get strength and tackling up....but doesn't force you to have 80 tackling on every defensive player.

I apologize if thats been brought up...or been shot down in the thread.

Exactly what I said a few pages ago imo.

Glad to see someone agrees.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 00:11:59
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bears Rule
i think bhall is speaking of my HB....pwned last year splitting time...but it was South America A league...so who knows maybe it was just the talent he was facing....


this....but ill concede the argument...im not about to battle HB talk with people...dont know enough about them.
 
Aanidar
offline
Link
 
Alright, I read the first 12 pages or so, and don't feel like reading the other 40+ so if I'm repeating already stated points I apologize.

I saw a lot of people saying that cornerbacks should need less strength and tackling than a linebacker does to take the power back down with the same consistency. I don't see this making any sense.

50 tackling is 50 tackling. If you have a corner with 50 tackling and a linebacker with 50 tackle, they are both equally adept at executing proper tackling technique. The difference is apparent when other attributes are factored into the equation. Such as strength helping determine whether you drive the HB back, stop him where you hit him, or get dragged for a yard or two. Agility is big, which is in a DBs favor.

Saying that defensive backs should get a boost to making these tackles and that 50 tackling on a DB should count more than 50 tackling on a linebacker is ridiculous. It's having to pick and choose which skills to be good at and which to sacrifice that make you fit different positions and schemes. The numbers next to the attribute are meaningless if you make them all of independent variable worth dependent on what position you're in.

I saw some people saying that tackling is a lot more than strength and tackling, I agree. Tackling includes a ton of different things and I don't feel strength should be a heavy factor in whether or not you successfully stop the back. As others said, strength should factor in on whether you get dragged for 5 yards. I feel the Tackling skill should factor in a lot of things such as the angle of attack you take, and whether you go high or low on the guy. It's your tackling technique, and without good technique you won't be able to take the proper approach and leave yourself vulnerable to getting trucked, or juked. Either way.

Agility should be a key attribute in conjunction with tackling in being able to get into the proper position and execute the technique.

Fighting to stop a guy with 100 strength, 70 carrying, 60 speed, 60 agility should take quite the tackle. If you're taking him one on one in the open field then I would think 60+ tackling and 50+ agility is required to have a 90% success rate. This of course is after you have the vision to see the play, the speed to get to it, and the confidence to put yourself in the way of this monster. And then let's make your strength check to see if you knock him unconscious, or wrap yourself around his waste and get dragged 5 yards down field.

If the guy is getting started and trying to split through a hole at the line, bouncing off a lineman who's getting shoved backwards in his face and as the DTs arm wrapped halfway around his waist, then it should take significantly less to finish him off. This of course goes to the "gang tackling" points I saw mentioned before.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 00:15:52
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by FairForever



Except this is why power backs sorta sucked last season.
You're not really making it more difficult to tackle the power back than it should be. The fact is, in real life, CBs don't tackle power backs one-on-one.

Defenses need to get the fumbling SAs/VAs. They can't whine about not getting fumbles when they haven't done anything to help their cause.


Power Backs sucked last season? Thats news to me...


Yeah, they did, because they were often tackled by LB's that had no business tackling them, who were just fast but not nearly as strong and had not nearly enough Tackling.

They didn't seem to totally suck, because people built their LB's like that; but they sucked because it should take a 60/70 build to bring them down and 40/40 builds were.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
its too long to read all 800 posts and i'm sure its been brought up.

But if it takes 80 strength and 80 tackling to "stone" the RB.....then i think 50 & 50 should probably trip him up most of the time. I think players with low tackling and strength should get "run through" more often but still tackled. We see all the time in football the CB brings down the RB but he gets 3-4 yards after the hit stumbling and being dragged to the ground.

I think that is more realistic and gives you reason to get strength and tackling up....but doesn't force you to have 80 tackling on every defensive player.

I apologize if thats been brought up...or been shot down in the thread.


If 50/50 were enough we'd just see the pure Speed builds continue. You can get to 50/50 with 90 Speed easily enough around Level 40. You should have trouble with power backs if Strength and Tackling aren't your highest stats. You might be a decent LB with 50/50 and lots of Speed, made to catch Speed HB's and stop the pass, but power backs are going to get past you quite a bit.
 
Baustin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by britdevine316


If a player pushes tackling to anything above 60 in this game, they are going to get burnt so bad by everyone with 100+ speed it's not even funny.



Why shouldn't there be a way to get burnt by 100 STR as opposed to speed, then? Or 100 AGI or 100 Jumping, etc. Metagame, right?


How does the D "burn" the O then?


There's no way for the D to burn the O with 100 STR. It doesn't do jack for you on the D-line, why should it work for RB's?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


If 50/50 were enough we'd just see the pure Speed builds continue. You can get to 50/50 with 90 Speed easily enough around Level 40. You should have trouble with power backs if Strength and Tackling aren't your highest stats. You might be a decent LB with 50/50 and lots of Speed, made to catch Speed HB's and stop the pass, but power backs are going to get past you quite a bit.


If the RB is bowling you over for 3 yards on every run you aren't going to stop the offense. At best you will slow that guy down to 4-5 yards a carry....at worst he's killing your team.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Ken1



If 50/50 were enough we'd just see the pure Speed builds continue. You can get to 50/50 with 90 Speed easily enough around Level 40. You should have trouble with power backs if Strength and Tackling aren't your highest stats. You might be a decent LB with 50/50 and lots of Speed, made to catch Speed HB's and stop the pass, but power backs are going to get past you quite a bit.


If the RB is bowling you over for 3 yards on every run you aren't going to stop the offense. At best you will slow that guy down to 4-5 yards a carry....at worst he's killing your team.


I don't think that would be enough to make it enough of a weakness...just get enough fast guys on your team and they'll swarm and get a clean tackle.

There's probably a reasonable argument that breaking tackles should slow down the guy breaking the tackle to a greater extent than it does, if the would-be tackler is halfway decent (as in even 50/50 as opposed to 30/30 or something). But for power backs not to be a bane to your player, you should need something like 60/70.

Then you need a mix like real football teams have, of the big, strong tacklers who bring down the strong rushers and the smaller, faster guys who cover passes and faster guys.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too



Folks need to be very careful how they answer this because it applies across the board. If 60 tackle is enough to take down a back with 100 str and say 60ish carry, then 60 speed/agility should be enough to easily maintain contact with a DE who has 100 speed/60 agility.

My answer is dependent on the tactics setting. If the player is using wrap up it should give a percentage bonus to his tackle ability say 30%. That would mean that for consistent tackling you would need around x+30% = 160 or around 125ish combination strength and tackle, otherwise, you should miss significant numbers of tackles on that back. If you use the average, then you need around 160, and if you use the jackhammer tackle, you need in the order of 200 to be successful.

Those are all combined strength and tackle numbers. If you have softcapped strength and softcapped tackle, you should be eaten alive by a 100 strength 60 carry back.

PinTBC
 
MrNomad
offline
Link
 
I think there is a missing ability in this equations as well. Vision.

Vision I kind of equate to not only seeing the play develop but also seeing how to tackle someone sort of putting technique into vision in my mindset.

An example:Take Zack Thomas who was always an undersized MLB in the NFL. But he consistently was in the top 5 in tackles just about his entire career. Now he's not super strong or fast. But he has great field vision and tremendous tackling technique.

Now I know you are thinking that tackling covers the tackling technique but that's not true. You can have great tackling and pretty solid strenght but without good vision elusive backs are going to just juke you out of your jock strap. So vision has to equate into the tackling equation because if you aren't in the proper position to tackle you aren't going to make the tackle.



 
Tigam
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Deathblade


Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


Honestly, each position should have different caps.

Ok... I made it this far and that's all the farther I'm going before making this post and going to bed.

I disagree... Each position should not have different caps. However, I do agree their should be caps.

Much of this thread has been, and Bort seems to really want to address how much is enough tackling... And more or less using a Bruising HB to figure that out. Seems fair to me...

So... How much tackling is enough? I don't know... It really depends on what *player* we are talking about... Lets redefine like others have done to keep the same logic going...

Strength: Should be a factor in tackling... Not as much as tackling sure... And Bort has said that it doesn't.
Tackling: The skill of tackling. Easy enough.
Weight: Why isn't anyone talking about weight?

Someone said before me that Reggie Bush isn't a power back... And he's damn strong... They're right. Filix Jones... Willie Parker... Same thing... Of course they are right at 200 lbs too.

Now... There are exceptions to every rule... But go look at your favorite bruising Half Back... Chances are they are over 240 lbs. Now these guys usually fall forward for more yardage and break tackles not because they are stronger than the guy that is trying to tackle them... Not because the guy trying to tackle him is bad at tackling... But because when you are 240 lbs it's just flat out easier to stop a 200 lbs man than one that weighs 240 once you have him in your grasp.

Those 200 lbs half backs aren't putting their heads down to try to hit you, they are putting their heads down to try to take as little damage as possible while going to the ground because that 240 lbs linebacker is likely to take his velocity to a complete stop in 0.0 seconds...

With that said a 300 lbs lineman will never be as fast as a speed WR... Or as agile. That speed reciever will never be as strong as that 300 lbs lineman. That's the way the world works... that's your cap.

Of course this is a game.. And not set up that way... But that's how I personally would address "dragging the players" and what not. I believe a 300 lbs man with a 100 Strength shouldn't need more than a 30 tackling to take down a Power Half Back of the same level of attributes at 240 lbs. While a 180 lbs man with a 30 STR would need a 100 tackling to have the same effectiveness of the 300 pounder on the same target. ( Generally speaking, just trying to promote the thought process than give 'true' numbers )












Last edited Dec 30, 2008 01:39:17
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


I read the frist few pages then said oh well

my $.02
The NFL dont keep track of broken tackles..yes I will use the NFL..seems like everyone else does
But if you ever watch a game when Earl Campbell was in his prime do you honestly think he only broke 2-3 tackles a game...lol It happens more then you would think. There was a game when Emmitt was in his prime the Cowboys was playing the Falcons and he broke 5 tackles at the LOS bounced out of the pile and went a long ways for the TD
Walter Payton...Was not the strongest HB but knew how to stiff arm and run someone over...do you think he could not break 5 tackles in game.
A miss tackle can be counted a a plyer trying to make a bad arm tackle and the back breaks it Or the back makes a stiff arm just to get that step or 2 and that is a broken tackle. If the NFL did keep track of a HB's broken tackles I am sure it would be a high number
Back are carrying the ball 300+ times in a NFL season Heck if they just broke one tackle for every other carry that is a 150 broken tackles a season.
As far as the statement made CB's tackling backs..that was said on the first or second page...
If a power back gets his shoulders square with the field(heading "north and south"..look out
If a cb can get a back running "east and west" then yea a CB should make the tackle...W/O the back having his shoulder squared with the field he dont have the leverage and power...if he has them squared then he has his ceter gravity and leverage to use..there for he has his power he could use to "bowl" a player over
That is why player like Coska,Campbel, Riggins,Jim Brown, ..to name a few did not run wide..they was given the ball head straight for the LOS
Heck look how many time Barry Sanders made a guy miss or broke a tackle..he was not a true power back
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Speed to gain momentum = 70 +

Agility to stay with his cut backs = 65+

Vision to avoid blocks and potential spin = 65+

Strength to grab and hold = 65+

Tackle to bring him down QUICKLY and Consistently = 70+

Confidence to go all out with his instincts = 50+

Stamina = consistency = 50ish

IMO
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I would say

-80 Strength - my guess would be this determines a baseline for who gets pushed back, the old irresistable force vs immovable object

-70 Tackling - my guess here is how far away you can attempt a tackle plus how likely your are to get a successful tackle roll

-60 Agility - what can I say? You can't tackle without agility

-50 Confidence - not sure why this is important but I know from experience that more confidence lowers missed tackles. Maybe it is a stamina like issue where low morale seriously diminishes performance, or maybe it is a consistency factor

-Some Brick Wall and Wrap Up/Sure Tackler type abilities would help and if you had some intimidation ones pretty high I think you could make do with lower physical attributes. Maybe at first he would plow through you but eventually he would slow down as his morale decreased each time you tackled him.

I am usually wrong about this stuff though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.