Originally posted by Kayoh
obviously it's possible to miss from anywhere but attempting longer FGs this early makes it significantly more likely you'll miss.
ASU doesn't attempt a ton of field goals, but that's by design. This early in a kicker's career, your accuracy tapers off more dramatically when attempting longer field goals. We've only attempted 2 40-49 FGs this season and 0 from 50+, but looking at your K on HAHA, who's pretty damn solid inside 30 yards (11/13), it looks like we're almost better off having punted in 40+ yard FG attempt situations. Our K is 12/17 inside 40. Yours is 17/26. That's all it is, really. Build up your accuracy & consistency early, and when you have those maxed out, pump power to increase your accurate range. nbd
Seems like it doesn't really help till you get your accuracy/consistency high enough, otherwise RNG is still too big of a factor. For that you need more SP to get there, so around the JMan level.
I don't see the purpose of punting to save a few yards of field position just so the kicker can have a nicer looking FG% in earlier tiers. That is unless you can control how often Punters go for coffin corner stuff, or possibly some kind of bounce backwards thing. As far as I know going for a coffin corner is random. So I'd rather just have a chance at 3 points, even if that chance is 40%. I'm fine sacrificing 4 or 5 extra yards.
obviously it's possible to miss from anywhere but attempting longer FGs this early makes it significantly more likely you'll miss.
ASU doesn't attempt a ton of field goals, but that's by design. This early in a kicker's career, your accuracy tapers off more dramatically when attempting longer field goals. We've only attempted 2 40-49 FGs this season and 0 from 50+, but looking at your K on HAHA, who's pretty damn solid inside 30 yards (11/13), it looks like we're almost better off having punted in 40+ yard FG attempt situations. Our K is 12/17 inside 40. Yours is 17/26. That's all it is, really. Build up your accuracy & consistency early, and when you have those maxed out, pump power to increase your accurate range. nbd
Seems like it doesn't really help till you get your accuracy/consistency high enough, otherwise RNG is still too big of a factor. For that you need more SP to get there, so around the JMan level.
I don't see the purpose of punting to save a few yards of field position just so the kicker can have a nicer looking FG% in earlier tiers. That is unless you can control how often Punters go for coffin corner stuff, or possibly some kind of bounce backwards thing. As far as I know going for a coffin corner is random. So I'd rather just have a chance at 3 points, even if that chance is 40%. I'm fine sacrificing 4 or 5 extra yards.






























