User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GmanV2

So no, just b/c the vocal minority, including you, is posting here, the large majority are out there, completely unaware that their plans are being altered by those in this thread.


Yeah there are probably about 30-40 people in this thread, and hundreds (thousands?) that are already planning changes off the official announcement on the main page. The final decision must surely keep the main components of the original announcement with a few tweaks. The tweaks I have seen that are pretty logical are those proposed by DD/Bort and dpride's idea is worth considering.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
What point? The only reason you want it to stay at day 480 is for Cobra Kai's dots...that's completely selfish. Don't throw stones in a glass house. I think cutting off at D440 solves all the problems we have:
1. No workaround to even things up
2. No one is at an UNFAIR advantage
3. No unnecessary coding when Bort could be focused on fixing other things


Yes they are....it just shifts it back one season. The day 400 dots will be at a disadvantage w/ teh day 440 dots.

Just do dpride's suggestion and BALANCE it out amongst all levels.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
I can't believe this is the major point of contention, and not the fact that it will take 2 years before the next generation of dots is able to play the end game.

There will be no one left.

It's gunna be like Highlander up in here. THERE CAN ONLY BE ONE!
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
You forgot

3) EVERY Uncapped league in GLB.....Day 480 cutoff instead of 440 is a LOT of extra dots making more available to the uncapped leagues=improved competition.


Why should it be that the top teams now have to go out and recruit S5 dots in particular because of a loophole in the rules making them the only dots worth recruiting? Having it at 480 might be a short term solution for the uncapped leagues, but it wouldn't make any difference in the long-run.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
The negative is you lose tons of dots, league won't be nearly as competitive as they would


I was kinda thinking we'd basically increase the top level playing field for next season by doing the 440-480 day group as well. If we cut it off at 440 only, we're essentially delaying that increase by a season, which isn't necessarily good or bad, but it would definitely be nice to have that now instead of later.

My VP page idea would probably take like 20 minutes to add, so time isn't really a concern there. And it's easy to freeze decline pcts wherever they are for a group of players if need be.

I do not like the idea of giving more TP's and such through day 480, as that just shortens the plateau to 2 seasons. P much a no on that one.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
hmmmmm

fuck the extra training I want the cutoff to be 440


Why?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GmanV2
Damn, with my sorry grammar intact, man you guys post quick.

I'm serious though, many avoid the main forums for a variety of well documented reasons and are happy, tomorrow they'll see the amended announcement and while they won't rage, some will be upset, but a TON will be more upset I'd wager if the day 480 thing was gone completely.


yup, not to mention GLB loses out because there is less competition, and Bort loses money because season 5 flex is returned and less need to buy flex.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr. Me2
I'd like that...but where do you draw the cutoff at on the given VA's? Give them extra VA's forever? Because if you ever stop giving the extra VA's, those players without them are at a disadvantage compared to the ones that got them and then we are no further along. Basically, taking VA's away from the smaller player pool sounds like a better idea than giving them to the larger player pool, just to deal with competing with the smaller player pool over the course of 2 or 3 seasons. Unless you plan to give the extras permanently.


No they are not...you are giving the 8 to Balance it out.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by jrry32

What point? The only reason you want it to stay at day 480 is for Cobra Kai's dots...that's completely selfish. Don't throw stones in a glass house. I think cutting off at D440 solves all the problems we have:
1. No workaround to even things up
2. No one is at an UNFAIR advantage
3. No unnecessary coding when Bort could be focused on fixing other things


the S6 dots would be at an advantage to start next season and things wouldn't work themselves out for another 2 full seasons. You would also have a smaller player base.

Just balance it out and let the dots play ball and everyone wins.


I still don't get how this is true.

Originally posted by Dpride59
Originally posted by jrry32

What point? The only reason you want it to stay at day 480 is for Cobra Kai's dots...that's completely selfish. Don't throw stones in a glass house. I think cutting off at D440 solves all the problems we have:
1. No workaround to even things up
2. No one is at an UNFAIR advantage
3. No unnecessary coding when Bort could be focused on fixing other things


Cutting it at d440 fucks every dot made man. Every agent I work with will be done with the game and use recycled flex. all of these builds have been mapped out with VPB for over a year to rely on training from d479. You have to give those training pts to those players no matter how you do it.


I really fail to see how that is different then what is currently going on, cutting it off at D480 does not allow them to train until D480.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Quit with the frivolous reports people.


lol, kai are reporting me like crazy?

i guess they don't understand how the "reported" meme works.

Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Probably the biggest issue I have with an announcement being made and not following through.


Again, that's how it's been every single time that they've made an announcement. I know you're not that dumb. Please stop trolling.



I'd like it if bort and DD were a bit more vocal here. Ultimately it's their decision and it would be nice to hear that way they're leaning, and why.
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by 5STAR

hmmmmm

fuck the extra training I want the cutoff to be 440


Why?


because my entire team is under day 440

Same reason Kai is arguing for day 480 tbh
Edited by 5STAR on Jun 24, 2010 16:44:33
 
brock86
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah, I like the idea, though I am not entirely sold on the everybody past the 480 days old part.

Basically just make a "reset my VP's" page that removes a season's worth of VP's and resets your skills when hit the button. And if you don't opt in, you just follow old rules.


Great minds think alike.. I was thinking of an option/page where the deduction to opt in could be accepted or refused as well.

I'm not sure what's not to like/accept about dots over d480 though. They've gotten more training (minor effect at this point in their careers) and BTs for AEQ (this is a more considerable advantage, but still not too big). Giving them a flat penalty to attribs based on age, like you suggested, would counter this somewhat - for example, -2% per season, so current d440-480 get -2, d480-520 get -4, etc,. Not perfect, but servicable, and could be easily stated and added to the acceptance/VA refund page. Make it work like an early decline penalty if possible so they don't get doubly screwed when their decline restarts, post-extended plateau.


PS cut my finger cutting a day old bagel so am typing much much slower now
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

The negative is you lose tons of dots, league won't be nearly as competitive as they would


I was kinda thinking we'd basically increase the top level playing field for next season by doing the 440-480 day group as well. If we cut it off at 440 only, we're essentially delaying that increase by a season, which isn't necessarily good or bad, but it would definitely be nice to have that now instead of later.

My VP page idea would probably take like 20 minutes to add, so time isn't really a concern there. And it's easy to freeze decline pcts wherever they are for a group of players if need be.

I do not like the idea of giving more TP's and such through day 480, as that just shortens the plateau to 2 seasons. P much a no on that one.


Freezing the decline? EDIT: So you mean they still lost those 2 points on their attribute even if you cut it off at D480?
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 24, 2010 16:45:29
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 24, 2010 16:45:11
 
seahawk10
Last name Wilson
offline
Link
 
Behind the scenes at an undisclosed conference room in the Pacific Northwest:

Bort: Hey everyone, I brought doughnuts!

DigitalDaggers: Sit down fatty, and will you drop that god forsaken balloon? We need to talk about something...

Bort: Are you an angry man, Henry?

DD: That's my fookin' line, try mixing in a salad balloon boy.

Bort: Ok, so what's crawled up your ass and died then bro?

Catch22: Ya, what's the problemo my main doods?

<Bort and DD glare angrily at Catch....>

Catch: <gulp>, let me get your coffee ready sirs.

DD: Without a doubt this has been the best WL season yet with the Kai and Gunny tearing shit up. We need to keep that going, the forums have never been better.

Catch: How about we extend plateau to keep the Kai at the top?

<Bort and DD glare angrily at Catch....>

Bort: Hey! I got it, how about we extend plateau to keep the Kai at the top!

DD: Now you're talkin' fatty. Did your P90x ever show up?

Bort: Umm... Ahhh... I'm not sure yet, I need to check with the butler, ever since I moved into my palatial estate on Lake Osflexego I don't even know where the mailbox is exactly.

Catch: So should I writeup the announcement then?

DD: Not yet, my shoes need the shine brought back, grab your box and let's get that taken care of then you can announce the change to the proletariat. Now run along and play, and don't come back.

Catch: Wait, you just told my to comeback and now you don't want me to?

DD: Don't be thick in front of me, Al.

Catch: Al? That's not my real name.

DD: Say it like you mean it.

Catch: What?

DD: Say it like it's your sermon.

Catch: This is foolish.

<Bort and DD glare angrily at Catch....>

<Catch quickly leaves the room>
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I was kinda thinking we'd basically increase the top level playing field for next season by doing the 440-480 day group as well. If we cut it off at 440 only, we're essentially delaying that increase by a season, which isn't necessarily good or bad, but it would definitely be nice to have that now instead of later.

My VP page idea would probably take like 20 minutes to add, so time isn't really a concern there. And it's easy to freeze decline pcts wherever they are for a group of players if need be.

I do not like the idea of giving more TP's and such through day 480, as that just shortens the plateau to 2 seasons. P much a no on that one.


I think competition is the main issue GLB has. Keep those dots around, find a solution to the VA thing, and I think you are good to go. Then the league fill up with proper talent over the next 3 seasons and Pros & AAA are much better and much more competitive.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.