User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

Again,

You are looking at the tree, NOT THE FOREST, you assume that because your player in AAA which is fine right now, let's say AAA median is 14, and you are 16, you are assuming that as your play grows into 17,18,19,20,21, that YOU are the only one growing. NOT TRUE. People will boost, grow, boost, grow, and that Median, goes from 14, to 21, to 28, to 35, etc.



I think there are a ton of people with the misconception that the league median is static and you will outgrow it causing undue punishment. The median by definition has to change as the league player makeup changes and grows (or devolves).

This seems like a great idea; I hope that the sportsmanship number will not be hidden and it will be used to hammer the scum in this game.
 
cbtd10
offline
Link
 
so my lvl 18 RB who plays in the 6th best league in GLB will be punished because he's not playing in Pro? right....makes sense.
 
Link
 
I know there are around 50 million pages so i'm probably just channeling someone else here but:

"The spirit of the game" is to win! Win win win. You have to beat your opponents. Not get them so tied up in the red tape that they are handucffed in their own league.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WVUFAN1971
Originally posted by sjmay

Ehhhhhh not sure about that, WVU defintely doesn't see the forest for the trees, but he isn't a cheater.

Thanks, man. I'm not a cheater, I'm just worried about the long term effects of this rule.

And, not, I'm not assuming that I'm going to be the only one boosting, that's silly. But to assume that EVERYONE else boosts is just as silly. My point is that you really can't assume the median is going to rise at the same level as someone who boosts and is active.

It's entirely possible I'm missing the big picture. It's entirely possible that I'm completely wrong. I just feel this sort of forced level cap is ultimately a really, really bad thing.


It's not a forced level cap, you can play in ZZZZZZ for all Bort cares, but when you do that, if your player is too good for the level, he will not grow at the same pace as the players that, that level is designed for. Take your LVL 14 DT, AA, AAA, good level probably, not gonna research its irrelevant, take him to the D league, because you are really really good friends with the CPU there. Basically under this system, instead of growing at 100 XP playing there, you would grow at 90XP growing there, or whatever, the numbers no one knows, but the point is, do you, or anyone really believe that your LVL 14 DT can/should play at the DLevel league?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbtd10
so my lvl 18 RB who plays in the 6th best league in GLB will be punished because he's not playing in Pro? right....makes sense.


Another one who didnt even bother to read it, but doesnt like it.
 
ravensfan
offline
Link
 
i'm against any rule changes that don't give teams/ players time to account for it.
i'm sure alot of people added 1 or 2 high level players this year to improve their team. why should they get punished for something that was never an issue before.
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbtd10
so my lvl 18 RB who plays in the 6th best league in GLB will be punished because he's not playing in Pro? right....makes sense.


Uh...no...if its the 6th best league in GLB then thats probably where we should be. He'd be punished if you moved him to BBB. And even then its just an experience hit..not a performance one.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Twilightbeckoned
I know there are around 50 million pages so i'm probably just channeling someone else here but:

"The spirit of the game" is to win! Win win win. You have to beat your opponents. Not get them so tied up in the red tape that they are handucffed in their own league.


If we're talking about real football here, then no player in the pros would move down (with a huge pay cutno less, not that its relevant to the game ) to play in some backwoods league with about 10 initials in the title just to win, either.

This helps the lower levels have their place to play, and encourages the pro players to move up closer to where they belong, thats it.
 
saltman241
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbtd10
so my lvl 18 RB who plays in the 6th best league in GLB will be punished because he's not playing in Pro? right....makes sense.


Wow. The median level in your league is easily 15. Did you even read the post?
 
Link
 
ALthough over all I will be hurting where I'm playing this season, I love this idea.

I give Kudos to Bort for putting this in and to all the crybabies out their,

((STRAW))

SUCK IT THE FOK UP
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

Again,

You are looking at the tree, NOT THE FOREST, you assume that because your player in AAA which is fine right now, let's say AAA median is 14, and you are 16, you are assuming that as your play grows into 17,18,19,20,21, that YOU are the only one growing. NOT TRUE. People will boost, grow, boost, grow, and that Median, goes from 14, to 21, to 28, to 35, etc.


So you can guarantee that my player will always have a spot in the Pro's if he out levels the AAA leagues? What about the teams in a very competitve AAA league that cant move up to the Pro with players that will be above the median if they boost?

There is not going to be enough spots for those players to move up, does not matter how the other team grow in the league. You can choose to stay in the AAA league and stunt your growth if you cant find a spot in the pros, or you can take the 3rd or 4th string spot in the pros and lose xp's because your sitting on the bench.

I can see the forest, and it looks very tiny.

Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:45:17
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ravensfan
i'm against any rule changes that don't give teams/ players time to account for it.
i'm sure alot of people added 1 or 2 high level players this year to improve their team. why should they get punished for something that was never an issue before.


GLB ain't a democracy RatBird. Nor should it be... Inmates can't run the assylum.

Players were upset that people were stacked lower level teams with pro calibre talent. Bort has interceded and made a solution. Case closed.
 
saltman241
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ravensfan
i'm against any rule changes that don't give teams/ players time to account for it.
i'm sure alot of people added 1 or 2 high level players this year to improve their team. why should they get punished for something that was never an issue before.


And it won't be an issue now. As long as those players are not radically higher levels than the median it will have absolutely 0 effect on them. When adjusted with the sportsmanship rating, you won't even see a difference. Since those 1-2 players were recruited fairly.
 
Jim Force
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny Wad
Discuss.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=355508


There should be no rules for AAA and Pro Leagues.
 
ravensfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sean Bishop
Originally posted by ravensfan

i'm against any rule changes that don't give teams/ players time to account for it.
i'm sure alot of people added 1 or 2 high level players this year to improve their team. why should they get punished for something that was never an issue before.


GLB ain't a democracy RatBird. Nor should it be... Inmates can't run the assylum.

Players were upset that people were stacked lower level teams with pro calibre talent. Bort has interceded and made a solution. Case closed.


i did'nt ask for your rude comments either jackass. this has nothing to do with who's running the asylum but i can tell from your comment your to stupid to realize that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.