User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Cryptotich



Granted. So where do we go from here? First of all we need to fix the disparities between paying customers. That means that no paying customers can have access to the Test Server.


That's really not a bad idea... I am sure there are quite a few users with the required knowledge of the game who would forgo the 'rat race' to be a tester in advanced SIM.


You are correct. There are probably even people here who would do the work for free. That is not the whole picture. We need to eliminate the possibility of gain by the testers of the test server. People who are able to access the test server should not be able to play at all on the main GLB site.

Of course that does not eliminate the possibilities of leaks. But it does give a reasonable protection against it.
 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai
The people who test should not be able to play alongside the regular community, unfortunately it is an unfair advantage for them to know the exact numbers to make the best players.

let them play around with testing stuff from here on out, let them have their fun on the forums, but keep them segregated from the rest of us in regular play.

half the fun of this game is getting good builders and people who know how to build some elite players, but allowing everybody to see this testing stuff would just result in cookie cutter players left and right that all look exactly the same and all are 'the best they can be' and all it will come down to is who is the highest leveled.

The problem with this is that the testers will be in a very boring game indeed, a few of them hanging out in their exclusive league it will get boring to have insane builds vs insane builds all the time for the same reason, no variety, no surpprise... the team with the highest leveled players would always win.

I think this will lead to the testers making alts, changing IP adresses, using proxies... whatever it takes to be able to sign up as a regular player and know how to undermine the system.

The reality of it all is Bort opened up too much information to too many people... and basically there is no reconciling it, only stopping it from ever happening again.

We can just try and contain those who know too much and try and keep the community the same as much as possible. It's impossible to have them 'un-learn' the perfect builds and all the time they got learning what plays work best for what types of players over countless tests. they got free experince that it has taken others a long time to develop just a bit of what they know due to this.

It's just too much, it's absurd that Bort wouldn't consider this, especially after how long he has kept the number secret for a reason. This has the potential to kill GLB as we know it, it needs to be treated as such.


Well though out concise points made. Logical, intelligent...
Too bad that means it will be unnoticed
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snaza
Originally posted by Atatakakunai


It's just too much, it's absurd that Bort wouldn't consider this, especially after how long he has kept the number secret for a reason. This has the potential to kill GLB as we know it, it needs to be treated as such.


Well though out concise points made. Logical, intelligent...
Too bad that means it will be unnoticed


Yet the question remains, how can it be fixed?
Last edited Feb 14, 2009 16:41:13
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
6 announcements Bort needs to make to the community:
1) The GLB Code- we have a right to know about Bort's bloodline and if there are any living sons or daughters of GLB Jesus.
2) The identity of Deep Ball, the agent who leaked news of the test server.
3) Admit that the test server is far to advanced to be a human made server and that it was stolen from a Roswell, NM alien spaceship crash in 1947. How much longer can you reasonably deny this?
4) Admit you hired organized crime to assassinate Flames' team.
5)Admit that the Royal Family is trying to destroy the game because they are embarrassed that Prince Charles plays it.
6) You knew about the test server and purposefully covered it up to draw support for a war between SEA Asia and the USA leagues.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Deep Ball, hilarious
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
6 announcements Bort needs to make to the community:
1) The GLB Code- we have a right to know about Bort's bloodline and if there are any living sons or daughters of GLB Jesus.
2) The identity of Deep Ball, the agent who leaked news of the test server.
3) Admit that the test server is far to advanced to be a human made server and that it was stolen from a Roswell, NM alien spaceship crash in 1947. How much longer can you reasonably deny this?
4) Admit you hired organized crime to assassinate Flames' team.
5)Admit that the Royal Family is trying to destroy the game because they are embarrassed that Prince Charles plays it.
6) You knew about the test server and purposefully covered it up to draw support for a war between SEA Asia and the USA leagues.


ROFL
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snaza
Originally posted by Atatakakunai

The people who test should not be able to play alongside the regular community, unfortunately it is an unfair advantage for them to know the exact numbers to make the best players.

let them play around with testing stuff from here on out, let them have their fun on the forums, but keep them segregated from the rest of us in regular play.

half the fun of this game is getting good builders and people who know how to build some elite players, but allowing everybody to see this testing stuff would just result in cookie cutter players left and right that all look exactly the same and all are 'the best they can be' and all it will come down to is who is the highest leveled.

The problem with this is that the testers will be in a very boring game indeed, a few of them hanging out in their exclusive league it will get boring to have insane builds vs insane builds all the time for the same reason, no variety, no surpprise... the team with the highest leveled players would always win.

I think this will lead to the testers making alts, changing IP adresses, using proxies... whatever it takes to be able to sign up as a regular player and know how to undermine the system.

The reality of it all is Bort opened up too much information to too many people... and basically there is no reconciling it, only stopping it from ever happening again.

We can just try and contain those who know too much and try and keep the community the same as much as possible. It's impossible to have them 'un-learn' the perfect builds and all the time they got learning what plays work best for what types of players over countless tests. they got free experince that it has taken others a long time to develop just a bit of what they know due to this.

It's just too much, it's absurd that Bort wouldn't consider this, especially after how long he has kept the number secret for a reason. This has the potential to kill GLB as we know it, it needs to be treated as such.


Well though out concise points made. Logical, intelligent...
Too bad that means it will be unnoticed


pretty much the way things go.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
People want to know if people who had access to the "Test Server" cheated by passing on inside knowledge. Since there is no way to measure the amount of knowledge any individual testers passed on, the general populous lumps them all into the same category.

Guilty or not, everyone who had access to the "test server" is now tainted.

I accept this as the past. But there needs to be a clear plan forward, that assures people that they are playing on a level field. I think that going forward the people who have access to the "test server" should not be able to play with the general GLB population.

At this point I see no point in publishing a list of people who were on the test server in the past.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Snaza

Originally posted by Atatakakunai



It's just too much, it's absurd that Bort wouldn't consider this, especially after how long he has kept the number secret for a reason. This has the potential to kill GLB as we know it, it needs to be treated as such.


Well though out concise points made. Logical, intelligent...
Too bad that means it will be unnoticed


Yet the question remains, how can it be fixed?


The only way to fix it is to basically quarantine the testing community... but this is nearly impossible.

The only other way to fix it is a total re-write of the code and attributes/abilities... which will never happen.

The fact of the matter is testers who are given that much depth have no right to be in a competitive arena with the rest of us. And releasing the information to everyone would be the downfall of the game.

So 2 solutions are there, and one will never happen... the only way to keep this from ruining the game is to quarantine the testers... This is completely unfair to them; but it would be more unfair, to the entire community, to allow them to continue.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
I would be fine with this if they let me use the test server for a few weeks....
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai

So 2 solutions are there, and one will never happen... the only way to keep this from ruining the game is to quarantine the testers... This is completely unfair to them; but it would be more unfair, to the entire community, to allow them to continue.


This is a game for entertainment, not the holocaust.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai
Originally posted by Cryptotich

Originally posted by Snaza


Originally posted by Atatakakunai


It's just too much, it's absurd that Bort wouldn't consider this, especially after how long he has kept the number secret for a reason. This has the potential to kill GLB as we know it, it needs to be treated as such.


Well though out concise points made. Logical, intelligent...
Too bad that means it will be unnoticed


Yet the question remains, how can it be fixed?


The only way to fix it is to basically quarantine the testing community... but this is nearly impossible.

The only other way to fix it is a total re-write of the code and attributes/abilities... which will never happen.

The fact of the matter is testers who are given that much depth have no right to be in a competitive arena with the rest of us. And releasing the information to everyone would be the downfall of the game.

So 2 solutions are there, and one will never happen... the only way to keep this from ruining the game is to quarantine the testers... This is completely unfair to them; but it would be more unfair, to the entire community, to allow them to continue.


I disagree. The testing community should be held to a higher standard. While we can not fix the past, we can go forward with a better plan.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
I would be fine with this if they let me use the test server for a few weeks....


Right, you want the same possible advantage as anyone who had access to the test server had.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Atatakakunai

Originally posted by Cryptotich


Originally posted by Snaza



Originally posted by Atatakakunai



It's just too much, it's absurd that Bort wouldn't consider this, especially after how long he has kept the number secret for a reason. This has the potential to kill GLB as we know it, it needs to be treated as such.


Well though out concise points made. Logical, intelligent...
Too bad that means it will be unnoticed


Yet the question remains, how can it be fixed?


The only way to fix it is to basically quarantine the testing community... but this is nearly impossible.

The only other way to fix it is a total re-write of the code and attributes/abilities... which will never happen.

The fact of the matter is testers who are given that much depth have no right to be in a competitive arena with the rest of us. And releasing the information to everyone would be the downfall of the game.

So 2 solutions are there, and one will never happen... the only way to keep this from ruining the game is to quarantine the testers... This is completely unfair to them; but it would be more unfair, to the entire community, to allow them to continue.


I disagree. The testing community should be held to a higher standard. While we can not fix the past, we can go forward with a better plan.


is it fair to have people out there that know the perfect builds?

like I said, there is no fair and reasonable answer to all of this now, Bort F'd up big time.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
Originally posted by Atatakakunai


So 2 solutions are there, and one will never happen... the only way to keep this from ruining the game is to quarantine the testers... This is completely unfair to them; but it would be more unfair, to the entire community, to allow them to continue.


This is a game for entertainment, not the holocaust.


Bort has to make a choice, I will not accept the fact that the perfect builds are now out there and that everyone will start making the perfect cookie cutter builds now. If it comes down to the testers still being able to do as they please or the testing tools released to everyone I will take my meager amount of money and leave this site with a bad taste in my mouth.

Personally I will not stand for this, Bort has spent so long telling us that he will not release information on builds because it should all be a mystery, and damned right it should be! we should build how we think will best perform, not by a set guideline that is 'do this or you will be inferior!' Him releasing this kind of information to even a small amount of regular players is Bullshit beyond belief.

I don't want to play in a game like that, I don't want there to be no real variety. Variety is the spice that makes this game interesting; without it, this game is not worth playing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.