User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by fletch03



Your right. A power back has no need for confidence, vision, catching. None whatsoever.


do you really think they do?


Our Powerback is successful catching out of the backfield, confidence helps, vision is nice. Show me a successful powerback with less than 20 in all of three of those.


less than 20 is what we are speaking of? i didnt mean they werent totally needed...i mean training those stats helps...but Power backs get along without reaching 40 in any of those stats tho...
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by fletch03




So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.



Power RB's dont really need vision at all....Confidence doesnt really pay off as much as people think at HB....and why would you put catching on your Power Back much at all? Thats the elusive's job more or less..


And you know that from all the HB's you have created? Confidence is very underrated for RB's .... Important at the Pro level.


I dont have a HB....but I have friends that do...
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by fletch03



So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.



Power RB's dont really need vision at all....Confidence doesnt really pay off as much as people think at HB....and why would you put catching on your Power Back much at all? Thats the elusive's job more or less..


I agree confidence doesn't pay off much, but it needs to be around 30, vision needs to be at least your players level IMO, and our powerback catches out of the backfield all the time, puts him up against CB's/safteys instead of D-line.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever


That's why weight is a factor as well. But if the LB weighs 50 pounds more but can't bench-press 150, then why would it matter?

Originally posted by Roctronic

CORNERS CAN TACKLE POWER BACKS.


Corners push them out of bounds, gang tackle, whatever. It's rare for a corner to take down a power back immediately.


Its funny but the primary people that are complaining don't understand that and are in low level leagues.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
im not saying im completely right on the whole HB deal...but I know of Power RB's that were pretty successful without putting much into many of those skills...
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
The fact that your HB catches out of the backfield does not mean it's a necessary skill, and I'm sure his YPC would be better if you focused SP elsewhere.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by bhall43


Originally posted by fletch03





So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.



Power RB's dont really need vision at all....Confidence doesnt really pay off as much as people think at HB....and why would you put catching on your Power Back much at all? Thats the elusive's job more or less..


And you know that from all the HB's you have created? Confidence is very underrated for RB's .... Important at the Pro level.


I dont have a HB....but I have friends that do...


So do I ..... and Tea Baggins (ever heard of him?) has tons of confidence
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
The fact that your HB catches out of the backfield does not mean it's a necessary skill, and I'm sure his YPC would be better if you focused SP elsewhere.


you mean the one that had 9.3 in todays game that you tried to throw in my face earlier? like i said go to sleep.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by fletch03



So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.


Here's something you may not have realized. GLB is not real life football. DUCY you're wrong yet?


haha, I think you have spun your argument around now. I'll take that as a victory for the good guys. Everyone realizes it isn't real life football, I could have the same argument with you supporting gang tackling. You really have no clue what you are saying at this point. Go to bed, get some sleep, you might think a little clearer in the morning.


LOL @ your moral victory. Leaving on a high note? Fact is power back need 6 TOPS skills to be effective. LBs need 8. Again, DUCY you're wrong yet? Amazingly stubborn.


 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
So do I ..... and Tea Baggins (ever heard of him?) has tons of confidence


This. Exactly the reason I never said confidence wasn't important.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by bhall43



Originally posted by fletch03






So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.



Power RB's dont really need vision at all....Confidence doesnt really pay off as much as people think at HB....and why would you put catching on your Power Back much at all? Thats the elusive's job more or less..


And you know that from all the HB's you have created? Confidence is very underrated for RB's .... Important at the Pro level.


I dont have a HB....but I have friends that do...


So do I ..... and Tea Baggins (ever heard of him?) has tons of confidence


Good HBs also often have high confidence...present example excluded
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
its too long to read all 800 posts and i'm sure its been brought up.

But if it takes 80 strength and 80 tackling to "stone" the RB.....then i think 50 & 50 should probably trip him up most of the time. I think players with low tackling and strength should get "run through" more often but still tackled. We see all the time in football the CB brings down the RB but he gets 3-4 yards after the hit stumbling and being dragged to the ground.

I think that is more realistic and gives you reason to get strength and tackling up....but doesn't force you to have 80 tackling on every defensive player.

I apologize if thats been brought up...or been shot down in the thread.
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 


Anyways, this thread is so far off topic now. Going to bed. Nice chatting with you iceman, get some sleep
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
its too long to read all 800 posts and i'm sure its been brought up.

But if it takes 80 strength and 80 tackling to "stone" the RB.....then i think 50 & 50 should probably trip him up most of the time. I think players with low tackling and strength should get "run through" more often but still tackled. We see all the time in football the CB brings down the RB but he gets 3-4 yards after the hit stumbling and being dragged to the ground.

I think that is more realistic and gives you reason to get strength and tackling up....but doesn't force you to have 80 tackling on every defensive player.

I apologize if thats been brought up...or been shot down in the thread.


Nope. In agreement bigtis. Some things I'd expand on but there's been enough controversial stuff ITT for me to start any more up.
 
Bears Rule
offline
Link
 
i think bhall is speaking of my HB....pwned last year splitting time...but it was South America A league...so who knows maybe it was just the talent he was facing....
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.