User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Team Loans, Chemistry
Page:
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Bort/DD - Can you confirm that chemistry began today so any moves made today WILL affect chemistry?

Thanks.
 
PapaHalas
offline
Link
 
I'm having a hard time fishing through all these pages for the answer i seek.
Curious if i can make moves on lower level players without it hurting chemistry... i heard mention of that, though can't find anything official on it..

Thanks
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wsdp
Bort/DD - Can you confirm that chemistry began today so any moves made today WILL affect chemistry?

Thanks.


Yeppers.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
if we drop or trade a CPU player away its -1 point to appropriate bars, shouldn't it be -1 for adding a CPU player to the team, instead of -2 as if were human?
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Maybe its just me, but shouldn't chemistry be less affected by dropping and adding backups. In reality, if you keep a good core of your starters together, then the Chemistry of a team is not really affected. Also, I think that taking 3-5 points off per addition/subtraction is kinda steep for new teams. Just thought i'd add my two cents.
 
tyante
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoVikings16
Maybe its just me, but shouldn't chemistry be less affected by dropping and adding backups. In reality, if you keep a good core of your starters together, then the Chemistry of a team is not really affected. Also, I think that taking 3-5 points off per addition/subtraction is kinda steep for new teams. Just thought i'd add my two cents.


It would take some extra work to keep track of who backups are. There are also cases where backups produce more during the games than starters. Really it should be more based on how much they play for the team. Someone who only played 2 games for the team and was cut should give less of a penalty than a player who was a backup the entire season, but played in 40% of the snaps.
 
Waltang
offline
Link
 
In weeks 1 and 2, were the ingame calculations based on everyone having a 100 chemistry, or based on everyone having a 70 Chemistry?

In otherwords, when Chemistry went live, were all teams treated as having 30% less chemistry than they had the week prior?

 
trauty
offline
Link
 
I hate this chemistry thing. The thing I like about this game better than anything is tinkering with the team trying to upgrade it through trades, signings, etc. I just wish there was a trading/signing deadline about midway (maybe even 2/3) through the regular season. Chemistry on a 50-man football team is highly overrated anyway, like the whole team is gonna play worse because the 3rd string tackle gets traded or cut.
-- Andy
 
OtisDriftwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trauty
I hate this chemistry thing. The thing I like about this game better than anything is tinkering with the team trying to upgrade it through trades, signings, etc. I just wish there was a trading/signing deadline about midway (maybe even 2/3) through the regular season. Chemistry on a 50-man football team is highly overrated anyway, like the whole team is gonna play worse because the 3rd string tackle gets traded or cut.
-- Andy


i have to agree.


My senario is I got a cpu team that was placed into a South AMerican AAA league with established teams galore. I did what I could before the trade deadline but where everyone on those teams were L 9+ it was hard to find that many players in 3 days. Now I've made moves after the deadline to sure up my team and my chemistry will be somewhere around 40 tomorrow. And its gonna take all season to get remotely close to the 70 it started at. There's no way it should go back more then it goes up. I would think you should lose like .5 point for adding a player , 1.0 for trades and + 1 daily for doing nothing.


Also team chemistry can be in a positive manner if a player that is released or traded was a cancer.

I suggest the mods look this over more and adjust it some.



Also here's an idea to keep more people active.

Email alerts - due to trades. send these unhappy people who got put on inactive teams an email when their player is traded or a team is taken over by another owner. That would entice people to come back and play if they knew they went to another team. Maybe this would answer some of the inactive questions..





 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trauty
I hate this chemistry thing. The thing I like about this game better than anything is tinkering with the team trying to upgrade it through trades, signings, etc. I just wish there was a trading/signing deadline about midway (maybe even 2/3) through the regular season. Chemistry on a 50-man football team is highly overrated anyway, like the whole team is gonna play worse because the 3rd string tackle gets traded or cut.
-- Andy


Yes, but when there are problems with collusion in certain leagues, team chemistry provides a great way to defend against it. I personally really like the team chemistry idea, it makes me WAY more cautious about how I deal with the player's on my team. Team chemistry gives the aura of a better, more team focused "team". I guess that's the way I look at it. If you trade away talent, your team chemistry suffers from it in some form or another. I like it.

EDIT: Sure, you'll also get talent in return for trading away talent, but it only takes approximately 3 days for your new player to gain back the lost team chemistry points. In retrospect, it's only a short-term penalty. That is, unless you are constantly trading player's back and forth with another team or two.
Last edited May 3, 2008 16:33:23
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCondor
That is, unless you are constantly trading player's back and forth with another team or two.


Or if you are an owner of one of the 1000+ new teams trying to get competitive by making a lot of trades or sign and trades..

I understand the chemistry thing and what it's meant to protect, I just think they need to be careful on how much of an effect it has.
 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by TheCondor

That is, unless you are constantly trading player's back and forth with another team or two.


Or if you are an owner of one of the 1000+ new teams trying to get competitive by making a lot of trades or sign and trades..

I understand the chemistry thing and what it's meant to protect, I just think they need to be careful on how much of an effect it has.


It probably depends on how you're looking at it. Maybe this would work better -- the more experienced your league is, or the closer you get to a Pro League, the more Team Chemistry changes affect in-game performance?

Seems to me that would solve your problem.

EDIT: actually, while it may temporarily solve the more new team owners issues, it still benefits collusion too. I can't say that's a better trade-off, nor a benefit to the new teams trying to remain competitive. Especially if the new teams face against a two-team-in one collusion-assisted team.
Last edited May 3, 2008 17:39:00
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
I agree the Chemistry thing could work, but like its been said, it is kinda shitty for the 1000+ new teams. Its hard to start from scratch with only CPU players and build a team in like the 7 days before the Chemistry meter was turned on. I realize where you are going, but you should seriously consider turning the meter off for the new teams... or at least until 3/4 through the season when teams have had more time to finish completing building a team.

Just a suggestion. Thanks for such a great game Bort.
 
YardRat
offline
Link
 
It should be shitty for new teams. You can't throw together 50 guys and expect them to have anywhere near the team chemistry that an established team has...that's part of building a team from scratch.
 
Adol
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by YardRat
It should be shitty for new teams. You can't throw together 50 guys and expect them to have anywhere near the team chemistry that an established team has...that's part of building a team from scratch.



I agree, learning should be half the fun.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.