User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE


What Larry keeps missing is that more options for subbing the QB out would solve the problem and we wouldn't even be having a discussion about 10 picks. If anything is broken or missing here, its that (along with no ability to throw the ball away or eat a sack).

Confidence is working as intended by the programmer/creator, the problem lies in the fact that the user can't sub the player out when low confidence becomes a serious issue in a game.


I agree that more sub settings would be nice, especially a sub setting for in game morale for certain positions. I just shouldn't take 56 pages to arrive at that decision.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigdawg_56
Originally posted by SCACE

What Larry keeps missing is that more options for subbing the QB out would solve the problem and we wouldn't even be having a discussion about 10 picks. If anything is broken or missing here, its that (along with no ability to throw the ball away or eat a sack).

Confidence is working as intended by the programmer/creator, the problem lies in the fact that the user can't sub the player out when low confidence becomes a serious issue in a game.


I agree that more sub settings would be nice, especially a sub setting for in game morale for certain positions. I just shouldn't take 56 pages to arrive at that decision.


It didn't take that many pages. It was mentioned very early, it just got lost in the shuffle.
 
NilanJ92
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by Gator93



Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader




Originally posted by SCACE





larry...you're beating a dead horse. 12 INT's combined has happened in a Bowl game, since you are SO stuck to the playoff idea. Your game had 11 combined, just so happened they were weighted against one team.




There has never been a NFL playoff or college bowl game where ONE team was intercepted 10 times.

Has everyone here forgotten that "sim" stands for "simulation"? What "reasonable" simulation would include ONE team getting picked off 10 times in a single playoff game? Do you guys even watch football? I'm starting to think that I'm surrounded here by housewives and children who may have registered here by accident.


I believe there was a bowl game and there also has never been a middle schooler playing against nfl teams.



Players at the end of season 3 are somewhere between 50 and 75% of all they will ever be and only 7 years away from their demise. You can't play the "middle schooler" card at this point--its simply not accurate.


haha - you have no clue. They may be 50% at best, meaning they are probably at best freshmen in college or something along those lines at this point.


Do the math--because of the soft cap and 2:1 and 3:1 buy ratios, most players are already having to switch to tertiary attributes because the economics don't reward continued building of the primary one(s).



Even so...I'm pretty sure that stamina isn't even one of your top 3 most important attributes...there's strength, passing, vision, specials, and confidence that you should be improving. I'm pretty sure it still only costs 1 point for you to improve your strength, which I reccomend. I have a reccomendation too for your equipment. If you have bonuses on attributes that are still cheap to improve with sp from gaining levels, redesign your equipment to make sure it's on your most important/most costly attribute. Then, build off of your 2nd, 3rd, and other important abilities.
 
dciace
offline
Link
 
This thread is fantastic.

Let's say that the Favre 6 INT game was caused by superb defensive gameplanning and DBacks having a great day. Now - replace Brett, a hall of famer in his prime, with a mentally fragile Division I-AA Quarterback, and make him throw the ball downfield 45 times.

Or

PLAYOFFS TEN TEN TEN TEN PLAYOFFS UNREALISTIC REFUND TEN AMERICAN FOOTBALL PLAYOFFS TEN
 
helluin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dciace
This thread is fantastic.

Let's say that the Favre 6 INT game was caused by superb defensive gameplanning and DBacks having a great day. Now - replace Brett, a hall of famer in his prime, with a mentally fragile Division I-AA Quarterback, and make him throw the ball downfield 45 times.

Or

PLAYOFFS TEN TEN TEN TEN PLAYOFFS UNREALISTIC REFUND TEN AMERICAN FOOTBALL PLAYOFFS TEN


Pretty much this. Lol bad QB's.
 
byroan
offline
Link
 
His confidence is higher than mine and I didn't throw 10 int's. Wish my stamina was 50+ though.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Ken - if you're right that they will fall off steep after season 11 and won't grow in season 10, then I'll buy into them being college players now. That said, even the best college players can have awful games, and by no means is this QB a good college player build.

I do hope you're wrong and there is more than one plateau season.


I'm telling you that is the plan.

Now, Bort has said that how it'll work isn't set in stone, that the only thing absolutely set in stone is that there will be decline. And I agree with him that that should be set in stone.

But the currently-planned decline will have steep drop-offs beginning in the 12th season, and no exp (perhaps training, but training as the only way to gain) starting in the 10th.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by helluin
Originally posted by dciace

This thread is fantastic.

Let's say that the Favre 6 INT game was caused by superb defensive gameplanning and DBacks having a great day. Now - replace Brett, a hall of famer in his prime, with a mentally fragile Division I-AA Quarterback, and make him throw the ball downfield 45 times.

Or

PLAYOFFS TEN TEN TEN TEN PLAYOFFS UNREALISTIC REFUND TEN AMERICAN FOOTBALL PLAYOFFS TEN


Pretty much this. Lol bad QB's.



Uh, not the point. "Bad joke of a sim" is the point.

Lets use the "random" function on a car's 6-disc CD changer. Were the "random" function TRULY random, its possible in theory that it might play the very same Smashing Pumpkins song 10 times in a row. But the manufacturers were aware that such an outcome was not desirable. As a result, even though they label the button "random" (or "shuffle" or some other similar term), its not REALLY "random" because qualifiers were put in the coding to prevent such an extreme outcome.

The sim we were handed yesterday to end our season was an awful joke. It was the equivalent of "1979" played 10 times in a row on the "shuffle" function. You guys are paying for this crap. All of my teammates did. Its bad enough that we're winding down season #3 and still can't pick which side of a defense we'd like to run against, still can't choose which DBs to pick on, still can't bring in goal-line packages and all of the other things that take place in a legitimate football game. And the problems with the offensive side of the sim when two "roughly similar" teams face off in the higher leagues are well documented--even Bort has acknowledged them. But its just plain stupid to be handed what we were handed yesterday and have various folks pretend that its a reasonable outcome. Some of you know better and are arguing just to read your own words.

In the end, you all will get the sim that they believe you're willing to accept. I'm on record as stating that what they are currently offering is unacceptable.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 15:08:46
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
you're on record larry as a sore loser right now. I had more respect for you in these forums, a lot more, before this whine session. If the game isn't fun for you anymore, maybe it really is time to leave.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by SCACE

Ken - if you're right that they will fall off steep after season 11 and won't grow in season 10, then I'll buy into them being college players now. That said, even the best college players can have awful games, and by no means is this QB a good college player build.

I do hope you're wrong and there is more than one plateau season.


I'm telling you that is the plan.

Now, Bort has said that how it'll work isn't set in stone, that the only thing absolutely set in stone is that there will be decline. And I agree with him that that should be set in stone.

But the currently-planned decline will have steep drop-offs beginning in the 12th season, and no exp (perhaps training, but training as the only way to gain) starting in the 10th.


I do hope he considers a longer plateau...longer plateau = more players at the top of their game = more seasons of supreme competition. Just my two cents. I do 100% agree that a decline should be (and is) set in stone.

Now to your other point, if training is the only way to gain starting in the 10th, do you still have to boost? Trying to figure out how that would work.
 
WolfbattXIX
offline
Link
 
Shuffle and Random are not the same thing.

Random would mean that if could play the same song over and over (all though odds are against it)

Shuffle would be to take all the songs mix them up and then play them one after another. Like a deck of cards.

To "shuffle" on this sim wouldn't be realistic either.

If you go to a craps table in Las Vegas, there is a chance that snake eyes could be rolled 10 times in a row. It is a very small chance, but a chance.

I can see how you could get upset, but it is just a sim game.

I don't see why you should think you deserve a refund. You are paying for the entertainment value of building up a player and watching them play a sim game. Which is basically a bunch of circle bouncing around. Don't take it so hard. It is a work in progress.

If you are truly this unhappy, my advice would be, don't dump any more money into flex points. But I am pretty sure the agreement you signed said you wouldn't get a refund or never promised an extreamly believable sim.
 
dciace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by helluin

Originally posted by dciace


This thread is fantastic.

Let's say that the Favre 6 INT game was caused by superb defensive gameplanning and DBacks having a great day. Now - replace Brett, a hall of famer in his prime, with a mentally fragile Division I-AA Quarterback, and make him throw the ball downfield 45 times.

Or

PLAYOFFS TEN TEN TEN TEN PLAYOFFS UNREALISTIC REFUND TEN AMERICAN FOOTBALL PLAYOFFS TEN


Pretty much this. Lol bad QB's.



Uh, not the point. "Bad joke of a sim" is the point.


The result, while pretty spectacular, wasn't random. Your quarterback was kept in too long and has no confidence in himself, so after a couple early picks, he was just done. You can't compare it to NFL, or even high-end NCAA because top-end athletes tend to be extremely confident.

You're using ridiculous strawman arguments to try to be right here.

Here:

FACT: Miami Perf's defense, particularly DBs, is excellent.
FACT: Your QB has a very weak build. (Do not go "LOL 15 picks ALL YEAR OMG" - most good teams hadn't boosted, and bad teams aren't much of a threat, so who cares?)
FACT: Aside from the all-around weak build, QB has VERY VERY low confidence. This alone renders NFL comparisons worthless.
 
Ultra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by byroan
His confidence is higher than mine and I didn't throw 10 int's. Wish my stamina was 50+ though.


hahahahahaha
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by SCACE


Ken - if you're right that they will fall off steep after season 11 and won't grow in season 10, then I'll buy into them being college players now. That said, even the best college players can have awful games, and by no means is this QB a good college player build.

I do hope you're wrong and there is more than one plateau season.


I'm telling you that is the plan.

Now, Bort has said that how it'll work isn't set in stone, that the only thing absolutely set in stone is that there will be decline. And I agree with him that that should be set in stone.

But the currently-planned decline will have steep drop-offs beginning in the 12th season, and no exp (perhaps training, but training as the only way to gain) starting in the 10th.


I do hope he considers a longer plateau...longer plateau = more players at the top of their game = more seasons of supreme competition. Just my two cents. I do 100% agree that a decline should be (and is) set in stone.

Now to your other point, if training is the only way to gain starting in the 10th, do you still have to boost? Trying to figure out how that would work.


Good question. I think there may still be boosting planned for the 10th season, but I'm not sure either way on that. After the 10th season, there would definitely be no more boosting.

I'm with you on a longer plateau. Let the 11th season be no increase but no decline, the 12th season be a decline about equal to what would have been gained in the 9th season without boosting, and then start wiping two seasons' worth (including boosts) in the 13th season (so that we still get retirement around the 16th even by hangers-on).

That would allow seasons 9-12 to all be played more or less at the top of a player's game.
 
dciace
offline
Link
 
I don't understand why everyone's arguing about the definition of random. You have a badly built QB that got into a death spiral as a direct result of having no confidence playing against a top defense.

Once the QB got sacked/picked a couple times, and still threw the ball downfield 40+ times while sobbing uncontrollably, this IS the correct result. If he only threw 4 INTs, that would be more broken than it is now.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.