User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blankspace
^

Some people believe it like that, yes. But in different cases, like "If there was a god, he would help me with this" or "He would give me this". It's very common. Thanks for proving me right.


That god doesnt exist?

great point
 
jeramyhansen
offline
Link
 
Last time I will post this here: There is no, no will there ever be, any proof that God exists. To say that God has one day to give you 100 million dollars or else he doesn't exist is somewhat comical, but completely untrue. I am sure you meant it in a funny way, but I have heard people say they need proof or evidence in order to believe God exists.

The answer is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viPWb3ieH6o
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeramyhansen
I am sure you meant it in a funny way, but I have heard people say they need proof or evidence in order to believe God exists.


I need proof to know anything exists. Why should God be any different?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blankspace
^

Some people believe it like that, yes. But in different cases, like "If there was a god, he would help me with this" or "He would give me this". It's very common. Thanks for proving me right.


Which is the exact inverse of your argument against evolution. If you wanting a third arm and not receiving it disproves evolution, then god not poofing me money disproves god.
 
SkierLegend
offline
Link
 
http://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/list.html

That is a good list of many counters to creationist arguments. I don't have time to read how the discussion has panned out so far, hopefully I will be able to go over it when I get back and contribute something of my own.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeramyhansen
Last time I will post this here: There is no, no will there ever be, any proof that God exists. To say that God has one day to give you 100 million dollars or else he doesn't exist is somewhat comical, but completely untrue. I am sure you meant it in a funny way, but I have heard people say they need proof or evidence in order to believe God exists.

The answer is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viPWb3ieH6o


Yes, I need proof in order to believe it.

Otherwise the Three Little Pigs really did happen, and it proves that we should all make brick houses so that big bad wolves can't blow it down.

Anyone seen the Easter Bunny recently?

Santa Clause really exists too.

Can't forget the Tooth Fairy, she definitely exists, there is even proof, because when I put a tooth under my pillow, there was money when I woke up.
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 14:04:53
 
jeramyhansen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by jeramyhansen

I am sure you meant it in a funny way, but I have heard people say they need proof or evidence in order to believe God exists.


I need proof to know anything exists. Why should God be any different?


I don't put my belief in God in the same category as my belief in whether or not your cousin had a baby or not. That's me though. I don't need proof to know that God exists.

I am not trying to put you, or anybody else down. Just giving my opinion.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Quite simply.. yes. Anyone that believes otherwise is naive.. and ill informed.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeramyhansen
Last time I will post this here: There is no, no will there ever be, any proof that God exists. To say that God has one day to give you 100 million dollars or else he doesn't exist is somewhat comical, but completely untrue. I am sure you meant it in a funny way, but I have heard people say they need proof or evidence in order to believe God exists.

The answer is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viPWb3ieH6o


yet asking evolution (not even a tangible thing) to do something for you is perfectly rational?
 
jeramyhansen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rams78110
Originally posted by jeramyhansen

Last time I will post this here: There is no, no will there ever be, any proof that God exists. To say that God has one day to give you 100 million dollars or else he doesn't exist is somewhat comical, but completely untrue. I am sure you meant it in a funny way, but I have heard people say they need proof or evidence in order to believe God exists.

The answer is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viPWb3ieH6o


yet asking evolution (not even a tangible thing) to do something for you is perfectly rational?


No. I see what he was saying there. It was comical and it did make as much sense as wishing for a 3rd arm. Absolutely.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by blankspace

^

Some people believe it like that, yes. But in different cases, like "If there was a god, he would help me with this" or "He would give me this". It's very common. Thanks for proving me right.


Which is the exact inverse of your argument against evolution. If you wanting a third arm and not receiving it disproves evolution, then god not poofing me money disproves god.


Leaving the one and only true crator, FSM.
 
NiteMaestro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by jeramyhansen

I am sure you meant it in a funny way, but I have heard people say they need proof or evidence in order to believe God exists.


I need proof to know anything exists. Why should God be any different?


How do you know you exist? Not you as a biological being, but 'you'. Your self-awareness.
Can you prove it?

There are lots of things that science has yet to prove, that still are. Quantum Mechanics is a good example. No real 'proof' of it, but the theories do play out pretty well. Evolution, is another example, no 'proof', but it does play out quite nicely.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
For anyone who thinks evolution has a will, put a stop to it now. It's not a "competitor" to God. It doesn't control the features or the survival of animals actively. Evolution is passive and indifferent like the nuclear strong force or nearly any other well-founded natural phenomenon.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiteMaestro
Originally posted by cbarge

I need proof to know anything exists. Why should God be any different?


How do you know you exist? Not you as a biological being, but 'you'. Your self-awareness.
Can you prove it?

There are lots of things that science has yet to prove, that still are. Quantum Mechanics is a good example. No real 'proof' of it, but the theories do play out pretty well. Evolution, is another example, no 'proof', but it does play out quite nicely.


Cogito ergo sum anyone? And we're talking different levels of proof here. You're talking about abstract philosophical proof and I am talking about pragmatic proof. Of course we, as human beings, can never truly "prove" anything in the way you're talking about, but let's leave that discussion to the philosophy professors and academics, because it gets us nowhere.
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 14:09:08
 
ranks0213
offline
Link
 
I believe in god.....His name is BORT
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.