User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
Originally posted by sjmay



A. if the Median for AAA is 30, more than likely the median for Pro will be, 36,37,38 that number

So B.

If your HB is 38, why wouldnt he find a spot in a "Pro" league, there are more than one of them around.



When there are more level 38 and above HB's than there are spots in the Pro League. Are you saying there will never be a time when there are more than 64 level 38 and above HB's?

2 spots per team, starting and the back-up they both will see a lot of playing time. The third string guy might not. What am I going to do with my level 40 HB and all the pro spots are filled? I hope I dont have to take a third string spot to avoid being punished by being to high to stay in the AAA leagues. Plus if I leave the AAA team it might hurt their chance of getting to the pros next season.


You think there is going to be 512 LVL 40 HB?

Granted, at one point there will be, but then your LVL 40, will be, what, 60?

 
saltman241
offline
Link
 
Reading comprehension for the win. If your not cheating you won't be effected. Everyones levels will continue to rise as will the median level. It's not a set number it will adjust as each leagues players grow. Honestly the only people that can see a problem with this are ones who it will effect negatively. Cheaters. Originally posted by Steelyeye
Originally posted by sjmay



A. if the Median for AAA is 30, more than likely the median for Pro will be, 36,37,38 that number

So B.

If your HB is 38, why wouldnt he find a spot in a "Pro" league, there are more than one of them around.



When there are more level 38 and above HB's than there are spots in the Pro League. Are you saying there will never be a time when there are more than 64 level 38 and above HB's?

2 spots per team, starting and the back-up they both will see a lot of playing time. The third string guy might not. What am I going to do with my level 40 HB and all the pro spots are filled? I hope I dont have to take a third string spot to avoid being punished by being to high to stay in the AAA leagues. Plus if I leave the AAA team it might hurt their chance of getting to the pros next season.


 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
Originally posted by PackMan97


Don't you mean 64 * 8 = 512 starting HB slots in the PRO leagues?

As for teams that get relegated. The longer you play for a team, the better your score. I imagine if a player has been with a team a few seasons, played 40 games with them, resigned three times, and boosted regularly (all pluses to sportsmanship), that player won't have a problem.


I am confused with this, forgive if I am an idjit.

This is what I have.... 32 Pro teams in the USA, 16 per conference.

2 spots for the No.1 and No.2, since those will see a lot of playing time.

32 teams X 2 spots = 64



You are forgetting,

South America, Oceania, Southeast Asia, Africa, Western Europe and Eastern Europe.

 
TheNastiest
offline
Link
 
I swear to god some of you guys are either illiterate or just ignorant.

Some of you complain and bitch about things that you can easily go re-read and see that the shit doesnt even effect you. Only a small perecentage of players will even have this effect their xp. And it should hurt them because they decided they wanted to pad their stats against weaker competition while still gaining their normal amount of xp which was only based on snaps played.

Peyton Manning shouldnt be allowed to go back to college and dominate and get the same experience as a Tim Tebow just cause he murders the competition being that hes already passed that Level of competitive play. He doesnt gain any game experience from doing something hes already done before.

So a Lvl 20 shouldnt gain much experience from beating up on Lvl 8-10's when he already played that level of comp a season or two ago. There should be nothing to gain from that.

How fair is it to some people that you have two level 20's and one is playing in a Pro League and one is in a BBB bottom league and both are progressing at the same rate even though one is clearly playing competitors on his own competitive playing field and the other is playing people 10+ levels below him.


Obviously the admins have thought this through and seen the positives and negatives of implementing this change.



 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
The best thing about this is that there is an option for admins to manually adjust the sportsmanship rating for any player engaged in cheating. It is sort of a miscellaneous clause.

I hope they use that option routinely and punitively. It will be nice to have a visible means of punishing the garbage that some people around here engage in.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Ehhhhhh not sure about that, WVU defintely doesn't see the forest for the trees, but he isn't a cheater.

Originally posted by saltman241
Reading comprehension for the win. If your not cheating you won't be effected. Everyones levels will continue to rise as will the median level. It's not a set number it will adjust as each leagues players grow. Honestly the only people that can see a problem with this are ones who it will effect negatively. Cheaters. Originally posted by Steelyeye

Originally posted by sjmay




A. if the Median for AAA is 30, more than likely the median for Pro will be, 36,37,38 that number

So B.

If your HB is 38, why wouldnt he find a spot in a "Pro" league, there are more than one of them around.



When there are more level 38 and above HB's than there are spots in the Pro League. Are you saying there will never be a time when there are more than 64 level 38 and above HB's?

2 spots per team, starting and the back-up they both will see a lot of playing time. The third string guy might not. What am I going to do with my level 40 HB and all the pro spots are filled? I hope I dont have to take a third string spot to avoid being punished by being to high to stay in the AAA leagues. Plus if I leave the AAA team it might hurt their chance of getting to the pros next season.




 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Yay! Maybe parity will happen sooner or later. Until it comes, the general population will bitch and moan.
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Steelyeye

Originally posted by PackMan97



Don't you mean 64 * 8 = 512 starting HB slots in the PRO leagues?

As for teams that get relegated. The longer you play for a team, the better your score. I imagine if a player has been with a team a few seasons, played 40 games with them, resigned three times, and boosted regularly (all pluses to sportsmanship), that player won't have a problem.


I am confused with this, forgive if I am an idjit.

This is what I have.... 32 Pro teams in the USA, 16 per conference.

2 spots for the No.1 and No.2, since those will see a lot of playing time.

32 teams X 2 spots = 64



You are forgetting,

South America, Oceania, Southeast Asia, Africa, Western Europe and Eastern Europe.



Yeah I just realized that now.

But it doesnt change much, I am willing to bet there will be a time when there is more than 512 player of one position that are to high to play in the AAA Leagues. Considering the thousands that play this game.

But I still do not like the fact that I might be forced to leave my AAA team (or any team in any league) because I am to high to play there. Sucks if I have to give up a boost to stay. Now I am hurting my player;s development for the "selfish" reason of wanting to play on a team I really like?

Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:32:05
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheNastiest
I swear to god some of you guys are either illiterate or just ignorant.

Some of you complain and bitch about things that you can easily go re-read and see that the shit doesnt even effect you. Only a small perecentage of players will even have this effect their xp. And it should hurt them because they decided they wanted to pad their stats against weaker competition while still gaining their normal amount of xp which was only based on snaps played.

Peyton Manning shouldnt be allowed to go back to college and dominate and get the same experience as a Tim Tebow just cause he murders the competition being that hes already passed that Level of competitive play. He doesnt gain any game experience from doing something hes already done before.

So a Lvl 20 shouldnt gain much experience from beating up on Lvl 8-10's when he already played that level of comp a season or two ago. There should be nothing to gain from that.

How fair is it to some people that you have two level 20's and one is playing in a Pro League and one is in a BBB bottom league and both are progressing at the same rate even though one is clearly playing competitors on his own competitive playing field and the other is playing people 10+ levels below him.


Obviously the admins have thought this through and seen the positives and negatives of implementing this change.





Good comparison... only it's more like Peyton going back to high school
 
Link
 
Love the new rule Bort. Should stop some of these pathetic owners from moving lvl 20s into BBB leagues....IMO thats very lame. Good call.
 
Legionnaire11
offline
Link
 
on the surface I don't like it. If a lower leeague team stacks up with ridiculous players, they have a great chance at getting promoted, and that solves that. Let the relegation system work it's course.

on the other hand, we have no idea what the parameters are. This change may only affect a guy playing 15-20 levels above his league average which would be extremely rare. I'm hoping this is the case and it only affects the .001% of players that would consider jumping from a Pro league down to a B league.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Steelyeye


Originally posted by PackMan97




Don't you mean 64 * 8 = 512 starting HB slots in the PRO leagues?

As for teams that get relegated. The longer you play for a team, the better your score. I imagine if a player has been with a team a few seasons, played 40 games with them, resigned three times, and boosted regularly (all pluses to sportsmanship), that player won't have a problem.


I am confused with this, forgive if I am an idjit.

This is what I have.... 32 Pro teams in the USA, 16 per conference.

2 spots for the No.1 and No.2, since those will see a lot of playing time.

32 teams X 2 spots = 64



You are forgetting,

South America, Oceania, Southeast Asia, Africa, Western Europe and Eastern Europe.



Yeah I just realized that now.

But it doesnt change much, I am willing to bet there will be a time when there is more than 512 player of one position that are to high to play in the AAA Leagues.

But I still do not like the fact that I might be forced to leave my AAA team (or any team in any league) because I am to high to play there. Sucks if I have to give up a boost to stay. Now I am hurting my player;s development for the "selfish" reason of wanting to play on a team I really like?



Again,

You are looking at the tree, NOT THE FOREST, you assume that because your player in AAA which is fine right now, let's say AAA median is 14, and you are 16, you are assuming that as your play grows into 17,18,19,20,21, that YOU are the only one growing. NOT TRUE. People will boost, grow, boost, grow, and that Median, goes from 14, to 21, to 28, to 35, etc.
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
edit: duplicate post.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:37:36
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
OK, I've only got through 5 pages of this thread but there seems to be one key point that people are missing...

IF your player is too high for that league, it affect their XP earned. I haven;t seen anything written that it affects your PERFORMANCE. THis means that people who have stacked their BBB teams with Pro level talent can still dominate their leagues BUT these players will not advance as quickly lvl wise as they won;t earn as much xp as they could.

THis will drive higher lvled players to the higher leagues...which, frankly, is where they should be.

If players want to stick with the team, then it requires dedication by mnay players to the team to stick with it and try to win the championship so they can all move up together. If playing with your friends or a team you're dedicated to is that important, then this shouldn;t be a big deal.

I think this is a great move once you realize it is JUST a adjustment to XP that can be earned. People who continue to bitch and moan about that are upset because they've stacked a team in BBB.

The hierarchy in GLB was collapsing and there was no incentive for people to try to move up. Now there is.... well done GLB.

For those of you who continue to cry into your beers about it, I encourage you to sell your team. I'm 311 on the waiting list.
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Ehhhhhh not sure about that, WVU defintely doesn't see the forest for the trees, but he isn't a cheater.


Thanks, man. I'm not a cheater, I'm just worried about the long term effects of this rule.

And, not, I'm not assuming that I'm going to be the only one boosting, that's silly. But to assume that EVERYONE else boosts is just as silly. My point is that you really can't assume the median is going to rise at the same level as someone who boosts and is active.

It's entirely possible I'm missing the big picture. It's entirely possible that I'm completely wrong. I just feel this sort of forced level cap is ultimately a really, really bad thing.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:37:03
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.