Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Gabrosin
I think the divisional system is a convenient and easy way to solve this problem with a bare minimum of changes required, AND it has the added benefit of being flexible and extensible for future seasons. But ultimately I'm fine with any scheme with the following properties:
1. Start off with the top four teams from each Pro league.
2. Promote each Pro league champion and maybe each Pro conference champion.
3. Demote either eight or sixteen teams, and ensure that each one goes back to its original league.
Any other details are unimportant.
Everyone agrees with that, this entire thread is basically "8 or 16", "divisions" and "where do they go" ... your solution says we need divisions to do step 3, the most common suggestion, it seems, is to force them down and use Pro-AAA traffic to even out the Pros. another one has been to try to force it and only screw over those teams that really did badly in Pros.
Oh believe me, not everyone agrees with that. But I think enough do. And I don't say we NEED divisions... once again that reading comprehension problem comes out.
The personal attacks don't help your argument, fwiw.
Even number of promotions from each league every season, 16 non-playoff demotions every season FTW.
If the 14th, 13th, or even 12th seed in a Pro Conference gets bumped down to make this work, so be it. It's the fairest system.
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
It's arbitrary grouping of teams followed by the retarded idea of having every division winner get in. All division ideas require a made-up subgrouping followed by forcing playoff spots based on that made-up, having-nothing-to-do-with-performance subgrouping.
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
First, that "different debate" is very important. Second, isnt your idea that the bottom 2 in each division gets demoted? Third, having arbitrary groupings in Pro is wrong because we've filtered tthrough hundreds of teams to get aa Pro champion and runner up. Fourth, arbitrary divisions also introduce a completely retarded and unnecessary scheduling bias, one well beyond the one that is, sadly, a necessary evil in the conference setup in GLB.
I didn't begin the attacks. And Syed has repeatedly demonstrated that s/he is just jumping to conclusions based on things I haven't said:
1. I never said every division winner should get an automatic playoff berth.
2. I never said the bottom two teams in each division should get demoted (just the bottom one).
3. I never said that divisions would require a change to the scheduling system, only that it's an option to be considered.
So yes, I think reading comprehension is an issue here. And it's coming out again:
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
I'm confused, because in your suggestion I seeOriginally posted by Gabrosin
Have four divisions in each conference. Name each one for a region. Keep each of the Pro teams that promoted initially together as part of that division.followed byOriginally posted by Gabrosin
At the end of the season, demote the lowest team in each division back to the Pro league from whence it came, and promote the league champion from that league.andOriginally posted by Gabrosin
I've promoted the idea of divisions a couple times before but never seen them gain much traction. You could use them to implement any number of cool things across ALL leagues:and finallyOriginally posted by Gabrosin
a little bit of UI rework to provide a page for each divisionso your suggestion doesn't need divisions? it seems to be the entire suggestion.
See, here's what I said just a couple posts ago:
Originally posted by Gabrosin
I think the divisional system is a convenient and easy way to solve this problem with a bare minimum of changes required, AND it has the added benefit of being flexible and extensible for future seasons. But ultimately I'm fine with any scheme with the following properties:
1. Start off with the top four teams from each Pro league.
2. Promote each Pro league champion and maybe each Pro conference champion.
3. Demote either eight or sixteen teams, and ensure that each one goes back to its original league.
Any other details are unimportant.
So YES, my suggestion is a divisional system, for the many reasons I've already listed, but so long as those three requirements I noted are met, I'd be fine with supporting whatever sensible system implements them. Honestly, I like ITS's regional "flags" idea. The two things I am firmly against:
1. Initial seeding biased towards USA and away from other regions.
2. Random regions upon demotion.
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
also, i would like for you to find a suggestion in this thread that doesn't involve
- rapid overturn (8 or 16 demoted),
- regional/random demotion (do we make them choose? do we force them? do we demote AAA), and
- should we change the structure from conferences or otherwise rework WPL
i've read every post in all 56 pages and i haven't found a single suggestion that isn't just some answer combination to those three questions
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knightman
OK, it's been a while since I posted my suggestion, and since Bort has said he doesn't like the divisions idea....
What about the idea of assigning a pot of money to WPL teams based on their original regions?
This would promote parity as if OPL has only 2 teams splitting a pot and USAPL has 6, each OPL team will get 3 times as much money as the USAPL teams. Since EQ upgrades at the levels we're talking about cost much more than a level boost, and players will only level 5 times a season, giving a team that extra cash may be enough to compensate for lower level players it may have. Even if it gets demoted, it has a wad of cash to dole out to recruits who want EQ upgrades for their players, thus giving them a recruiting advantage. Higher level players migrate to the teams that have the cash, and Voila!----parity!!!
This system can continue even after parity exists, since presumably each league will have the same number of teams in the WPL and get the same amount of money.
Now that the issue of parity gets addressed, there's no problem with allowing teams to go back to their original regions and resume their rivalries/friendships with familiar foes. After all, remember when GLB was touted as much as a social networking game as it was football? Why destroy the social networking aspect of it by randomizing demotion?
Interesting and out of the box at the very least. Kinda like taking the idea of media revenue and splitting it by representation in the league.
What about that one? Has nothing to do with number of demoting teams, where the teams get demoted to, or any structural rework. Perhaps you misread that one as well.