Originally posted by lolMurp Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Pro World Tournament = -Invites by a DIVERSE committee which is open to all users who really do their research and base rankings on league records, tournaments, league strength, etc to come up with a relatively unbiased list of top teams. -Allows more teams to compete. Pretty much everyone who deserves to be there is, and everyone has a chance. -Isn't single elimination so if you get set up against one of the favorites you aren't screwed. -Is only 3 more games -Already has an official trophy and widely recognized -Run very well for 3 seasons now WITHOUT official scheduling and gone off without a hitch -Allows teams to stay in their leagues where they've built up rivalries and friendships -Doesn't bring up the whole demotion mess Bort seems so concerned about
So what's the problem with just slapping the an official sticker on it, putting the bracket in on the league page, and scheduling the games under a tournament section instead of a scrimmage section?
sounds like the BCS
Maybe a little like the BCS how the teams are selected, but it's an OPEN committee. Also most people hate the BCS because there is no playoffs. The PWT has a bracket.
Originally posted by CS481 I don't have the time to read 52 pages on this, but i'll give my opinion.
by giving the highest level players in the game a free boost, it seems to be just another "screw you" to the guys like myself that joined end of season 2/ start of season 3.
With the new retirement/decline rules taking effect as well as now a free boost for each guy on the team, i have to ask how in the heck will an agent like myself (thats boosts EVERY YEAR) make it to the pros before my guys start to decline?
They don't get an extra boost. They just don't have to pay for one of their normal 3.
Why would anyone want a 3rd scrimmage tourney that's official? WL is something cool new, further progression and it's going to be awesome. Just like a actual GLB sanctioned draft, there's a huge need for a draft. I'll send you the scripts or rewrite them in perl if you like. http://www.glbwiki.com/draft/
I have a feeling at least 80% of the teams would want the WPL, just for the fact that they'd be in it.
I have worked my ass off for over a year, literally spent hundreds and hundreds of hours working on this game to prepare Santiago for the advent of a world league.
Now it's erased because Bort cant make up his mind, listens to whiners and cant figure out demotion.
Make a committee of the handful of top owners/GMs who actually care deeply about this sim and I am sure we could figure out an equitable demotion system within a few days if Bort doesnt want to do it himself.
The tournament idea was fine but it was only ever a stop gap until the world league was ready.
The best teams want to play the best competition. I dont want yet another season of playing a ton of walkover and blowouts, which still take time to prepare for, and then be forced to do game planning for the real tournament on my off days.
What an awful, awful idea. Make the world league. If someone doesnt want to leave their precious USA/CAN/SA Pro/Whatever, just give them option of avoiding the World League altogether.
Let those of us who want to see who is really the best play in the World League. If Santiago gets demoted, they can send my team to whatever damn region they please.
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Pro World Tournament = -Invites by a DIVERSE committee which is open to all users who really do their research and base rankings on league records, tournaments, league strength, etc to come up with a relatively unbiased list of top teams. -Allows more teams to compete. Pretty much everyone who deserves to be there is, and everyone has a chance. -Isn't single elimination so if you get set up against one of the favorites you aren't screwed. -Is only 3 more games -Already has an official trophy and widely recognized -Run very well for 3 seasons now WITHOUT official scheduling and gone off without a hitch -Allows teams to stay in their leagues where they've built up rivalries and friendships -Doesn't bring up the whole demotion mess Bort seems so concerned about
So what's the problem with just slapping the an official sticker on it, putting the bracket in on the league page, and scheduling the games under a tournament section instead of a scrimmage section?
because it's actually a worse tournament than the unofficial one?
No, you misunderstood me. I'm not saying that's what this new World Tournament would be like. I'm saying we should just use the PWT INSTEAD of this tournament, since nobody seems to like it.