User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

You would have to be really naive to assume any of the testers will not notice the difference in say, 0 Swat Ball and 15 Swat Ball, or 0 Field Gen and 15 Field Gen.


That's why I feel from this moment on that testers should be known and their players builds should be open to all, (the price of being a tester)...

I am afraid one testers builds are not enough as they could very easily mislead the whole community
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Cryptotich

I was pointing out that it was an either/or prospect. You either believe that they got no knowledge from testing or you have to believe that they all COULD have gained maximum knowledge.


Everyone knows they gained maximum knowledge, anyone who denies that is lying to themselves.


I want maximun knowledge too! im a active paying customer just like the testers. Gimme NOW!
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
The simple fact that people "could have" gained gained insider knowledge about GLB is the issue. If anyone who was on the test server, then everyone who was on the test server is "tainted"

It is not that I am accusing any of the testers of cheating. The simple fact that cheating was available to them, is what is making people upset.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by CinTex

lol... you made up that number...


No I didn't...there is nothing wrong with that sentence. There is no made up numbers. We, in fact, do NOT need 345746736 threads about it. Nowhere did I say that we had that many threads about it, I simply said we do not need that many about it, which I think is pretty much an inarguable point.


touche' I just thought it was a nice attempt at levity... I guess I was wrong
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
touche' I just thought it was a nice attempt at levity... I guess I was wrong


It's OK, I found it pretty funny, and enjoyed responding to it
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by CinTex

touche' I just thought it was a nice attempt at levity... I guess I was wrong


It's OK, I found it pretty funny, and enjoyed responding to it



 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
The simple fact that people "could have" gained gained insider knowledge about GLB is the issue. If anyone who was on the test server, then everyone who was on the test server is "tainted"

It is not that I am accusing any of the testers of cheating. The simple fact that cheating was available to them, is what is making people upset.


We need to make a distinction between cheating and having an unfair advantage. If you cheat, it means you circumvent the rules to gain an advantage. If you're given an unfair advantage within the rules (like power backs at the beginning of last season, or testers for this season) the game's administrators are to blame rather than the users who receive the advantage.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Deathblade


You would have to be really naive to assume any of the testers will not notice the difference in say, 0 Swat Ball and 15 Swat Ball, or 0 Field Gen and 15 Field Gen.


That's why I feel from this moment on that testers should be known and their players builds should be open to all, (the price of being a tester)...

I am afraid one testers builds are not enough as they could very easily mislead the whole community


My personal view is that the former testers should not be known. It wouldn't help anyone, and would only spark controversy about their involvement in any team they were on.

I do believe that in the future testing should be handled in a different way. If I were in charge of testing, then all the testers I picked would not be able to play in the general GLB game.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
The simple fact that people "could have" gained gained insider knowledge about GLB is the issue. If anyone who was on the test server, then everyone who was on the test server is "tainted"

It is not that I am accusing any of the testers of cheating. The simple fact that cheating was available to them, is what is making people upset.


The game, GLB, is tainted because its now clear that not all paying "testers" are created equal.
 
Arawn
offline
Link
 
Whats all this about testing that everyone is bitching about (to lazy to read the thread)
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
Originally posted by Cryptotich

The simple fact that people "could have" gained gained insider knowledge about GLB is the issue. If anyone who was on the test server, then everyone who was on the test server is "tainted"

It is not that I am accusing any of the testers of cheating. The simple fact that cheating was available to them, is what is making people upset.


The game, GLB, is tainted because its now clear that not all paying "testers" are created equal.


Granted. So where do we go from here? First of all we need to fix the disparities between paying customers. That means that no paying customers can have access to the Test Server.

Edit... Sorry, I meant that no players who have access to the Test Servers, can play in the general GLB game.
Last edited Feb 14, 2009 16:23:40
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by odg62

Originally posted by Cryptotich


The simple fact that people "could have" gained gained insider knowledge about GLB is the issue. If anyone who was on the test server, then everyone who was on the test server is "tainted"

It is not that I am accusing any of the testers of cheating. The simple fact that cheating was available to them, is what is making people upset.


The game, GLB, is tainted because its now clear that not all paying "testers" are created equal.


Granted. So where do we go from here? First of all we need to fix the disparities between paying customers. That means that no paying customers can have access to the Test Server.


its too late for that, already happened
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich


Granted. So where do we go from here? First of all we need to fix the disparities between paying customers. That means that no paying customers can have access to the Test Server.


That's really not a bad idea... I am sure there are quite a few users with the required knowledge of the game who would forgo the 'rat race' to be a tester in advanced SIM.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
Originally posted by Cryptotich

Originally posted by odg62


Originally posted by Cryptotich



The simple fact that people "could have" gained gained insider knowledge about GLB is the issue. If anyone who was on the test server, then everyone who was on the test server is "tainted"

It is not that I am accusing any of the testers of cheating. The simple fact that cheating was available to them, is what is making people upset.


The game, GLB, is tainted because its now clear that not all paying "testers" are created equal.


Granted. So where do we go from here? First of all we need to fix the disparities between paying customers. That means that no paying customers can have access to the Test Server.


its too late for that, already happened


Sorry had to edit.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
The people who test should not be able to play alongside the regular community, unfortunately it is an unfair advantage for them to know the exact numbers to make the best players.

let them play around with testing stuff from here on out, let them have their fun on the forums, but keep them segregated from the rest of us in regular play.

half the fun of this game is getting good builders and people who know how to build some elite players, but allowing everybody to see this testing stuff would just result in cookie cutter players left and right that all look exactly the same and all are 'the best they can be' and all it will come down to is who is the highest leveled.

The problem with this is that the testers will be in a very boring game indeed, a few of them hanging out in their exclusive league it will get boring to have insane builds vs insane builds all the time for the same reason, no variety, no surpprise... the team with the highest leveled players would always win.

I think this will lead to the testers making alts, changing IP adresses, using proxies... whatever it takes to be able to sign up as a regular player and know how to undermine the system.

The reality of it all is Bort opened up too much information to too many people... and basically there is no reconciling it, only stopping it from ever happening again.

We can just try and contain those who know too much and try and keep the community the same as much as possible. It's impossible to have them 'un-learn' the perfect builds and all the time they got learning what plays work best for what types of players over countless tests. they got free experince that it has taken others a long time to develop just a bit of what they know due to this.

It's just too much, it's absurd that Bort wouldn't consider this, especially after how long he has kept the number secret for a reason. This has the potential to kill GLB as we know it, it needs to be treated as such.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.