User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by fletch03



Originally posted by Crawly




Originally posted by fletch03





Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Carrying

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



well in that case, lets get rid of confidence, jumping, strength and tackling for a LB. Because there are plenty of those builds as well.


You really fail at arguing your point, considering he took out things you ACTUALLY don't need.


Your right. A power back has no need for confidence, vision, catching. None whatsoever.


Needs confidence. No need for vision and catching whatsoever.


So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.
 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
all that i ask is whatever you come up with for tackling, please put it in an official faq so you dont have 100s of people wondering if you made attribute X a factor in tackling
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roctronic
CARRYING IS THE ABILITY TO NOT LOSE THE BALL WHILE RUNNING WITH IT.


Not in this game.

Originally posted by Roctronic
STRENGTH IS HOW POWERFUL YOU ARE.

Can you really tell me that you can stiff arm a 6"4 LB that weighs almost 50 pounds more.


That's why weight is a factor as well. But if the LB weighs 50 pounds more but can't bench-press 150, then why would it matter?

Originally posted by Roctronic
CORNERS CAN TACKLE POWER BACKS.


Corners push them out of bounds, gang tackle, whatever. It's rare for a corner to take down a power back immediately.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by Crawly


Originally posted by fletch03



Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Carrying


LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



fixed even better for a great powerback build


Dude...seriously...that HB sucks ass. Not elite in any way. I have consistently stopped guys like that for less that 2 ypc.


give me a build of a guy you stopped that had relatively high in the second 2 stats and great strength...adding in power back SA's....
 
cbtd10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roctronic
CARRYING IS THE ABILITY TO NOT LOSE THE BALL WHILE RUNNING WITH IT.

Nothing to do with a tackle.

STRENGTH IS HOW POWERFUL YOU ARE.



Fail.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.


Here's something you may not have realized. GLB is not real life football. DUCY you're wrong yet?
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by bhall43


Originally posted by FairForever





Except this is why power backs sorta sucked last season.
You're not really making it more difficult to tackle the power back than it should be. The fact is, in real life, CBs don't tackle power backs one-on-one.

Defenses need to get the fumbling SAs/VAs. They can't whine about not getting fumbles when they haven't done anything to help their cause.


Power Backs sucked last season? Thats news to me...


Compared to elusives?


I wouldnt say they sucked compared to elusives...id say they both had their place...i definitely faced off against some solid Power and Elusive backs last season...


Dunno where you came from. Elusives were much stronger last season than power backs.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Roctronic

CARRYING IS THE ABILITY TO NOT LOSE THE BALL WHILE RUNNING WITH IT.


Not in this game.


AH. There's my support.
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by fletch03


Your right. A power back has no need for confidence, vision, catching. None whatsoever.


do you really think they do?


Our Powerback is successful catching out of the backfield, confidence helps, vision is nice. Show me a successful powerback with less than 20 in all of three of those.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by bhall43


Originally posted by Crawly



Originally posted by fletch03




Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Carrying


LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



fixed even better for a great powerback build


Dude...seriously...that HB sucks ass. Not elite in any way. I have consistently stopped guys like that for less that 2 ypc.


give me a build of a guy you stopped that had relatively high in the second 2 stats and great strength...adding in power back SA's....


The team you are on stopped Csonka last season.
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.


Here's something you may not have realized. GLB is not real life football. DUCY you're wrong yet?


haha, I think you have spun your argument around now. I'll take that as a victory for the good guys. Everyone realizes it isn't real life football, I could have the same argument with you supporting gang tackling. You really have no clue what you are saying at this point. Go to bed, get some sleep, you might think a little clearer in the morning.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03


So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.



Power RB's dont really need vision at all....Confidence doesnt really pay off as much as people think at HB....and why would you put catching on your Power Back much at all? Thats the elusive's job more or less..
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by bhall43


Originally posted by Crawly



Originally posted by fletch03




Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Carrying


LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



fixed even better for a great powerback build


Dude...seriously...that HB sucks ass. Not elite in any way. I have consistently stopped guys like that for less that 2 ypc.


give me a build of a guy you stopped that had relatively high in the second 2 stats and great strength...adding in power back SA's....


60+ speed, 80+ Strength, 50+ carrying

50+ speed 90+ Strength 50+ carrying

both with significant SAs

Stopped them both dead cold, with an under-leveled team.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 00:01:19
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by fletch03


So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.


Here's something you may not have realized. GLB is not real life football. DUCY you're wrong yet?


haha, I think you have spun your argument around now. I'll take that as a victory for the good guys. Everyone realizes it isn't real life football, I could have the same argument with you supporting gang tackling. You really have no clue what you are saying at this point. Go to bed, get some sleep, you might think a little clearer in the morning.


LOL @ your moral victory. Leaving on a high note? Fact is power back need 6 TOPS skills to be effective. LBs need 8. Again, DUCY you're wrong yet? Amazingly stubborn.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by fletch03



So a RB has no need to catch the ball? No need to see holes?

Ok since this is your thought process, I'll eliminate everything but the bare essentials for LBs

Speed
Agility
Vision
Tackling
Stamina
Strength

There now they have the equal amount.



Power RB's dont really need vision at all....Confidence doesnt really pay off as much as people think at HB....and why would you put catching on your Power Back much at all? Thats the elusive's job more or less..


And you know that from all the HB's you have created? Confidence is very underrated for RB's .... Important at the Pro level.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.