User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gator93
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Gator93


Originally posted by Gator93



Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader




Originally posted by Gator93





Ok here is the comparison between my qbs on my team.
Level 13
6 more strength
4 more vision
6 less throwing
10 less confidence
2 in passer tree

Level 16
3 less strength
2 more vision
Same confidence
Same throwing
3 in every tree.

So mostly he has the same base stats as a level 16 and you expect him to compete against level 25's? Heck my level 13 qb is almost as good as him.



And yet oddly enough he was SIXTH in TD passes and NINTH in passing yards in one of the highest ranked leagues at GLB.


Because your running game carried him all season. When the running game was working his pass game worked. Almost everytime you threw more than 30 passes because the run game wasn't working your passer rating was below 50.


Here is one answer alone, should I bump all the rest of the times I have answered that same post Larry? Will you finally read it or will I be wasting my time?



"Poor performance on occassion" is part and parcel of a valid sim. "10 picks in a single playoff game" turns the entire sim engine into one giant joke.



Well your qb has 50 percent of the talent of normal qb's at his level, thats all I am trying to tell you.



Would you pay to play a golf sim that generated a score of (-18) 54 on a course designed for a major?

Would you pay to play a baseball sim that included one team striking out all 27 opposing hitters in a playoff game?

Would you ardently defend a football sim that included one team picking off another 10 times during a playoff game?

Apparently you would!

Last edited Jul 15, 2008 13:43:10
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Gator93

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by Gator93



Originally posted by Gator93




Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader





Originally posted by Gator93






Ok here is the comparison between my qbs on my team.
Level 13
6 more strength
4 more vision
6 less throwing
10 less confidence
2 in passer tree

Level 16
3 less strength
2 more vision
Same confidence
Same throwing
3 in every tree.

So mostly he has the same base stats as a level 16 and you expect him to compete against level 25's? Heck my level 13 qb is almost as good as him.



And yet oddly enough he was SIXTH in TD passes and NINTH in passing yards in one of the highest ranked leagues at GLB.


Because your running game carried him all season. When the running game was working his pass game worked. Almost everytime you threw more than 30 passes because the run game wasn't working your passer rating was below 50.


Here is one answer alone, should I bump all the rest of the times I have answered that same post Larry? Will you finally read it or will I be wasting my time?



"Poor performance on occassion" is part and parcel of a valid sim. "10 picks in a single playoff game" turns the entire sim engine into one giant joke.



Well your qb has 50 percent of the talent of normal qb's at his level, thats all I am trying to tell you.



Would you pay to play a golf sim that generated a score of (-18) 54 on a course designed for a major?

Would you pay to play a baseball sim that included one team striking out all 27 opposing hitters?

Would you ardently defend a football sim that included one team picking off another 10 times during a playoff game?

Apparently you would!



Not the golf game because that would be unreleastic, now if they had -10 yah.

Baseball well yah if they had a level 25 pitching to level 16's I would.

In football yah your guys build sucked and that is why it happened.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
You ready to take your ball and go home yet Larry, or are you still going to amuse us with your "BUT THIS WAS A PLAYOFF GAME!!!!!" posts?
 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
Larry I'll once again bring this point to you. Perhaps GLB isn't based on American Football. It may very well be based on the idea of a pick up game with your friends.

And when me and my friends play ....10 picks a game is usual lol.

I do agree that this happening in a playoff game is weird because your team shouldn't have even got their if they lost that much, but in real life (in both the NFL, NCAA, and Street Pickup games) even during a playoff their are HUGE score differences sometimes......
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Gator93


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



Originally posted by SCACE


larry...you're beating a dead horse. 12 INT's combined has happened in a Bowl game, since you are SO stuck to the playoff idea. Your game had 11 combined, just so happened they were weighted against one team.




There has never been a NFL playoff or college bowl game where ONE team was intercepted 10 times.

Has everyone here forgotten that "sim" stands for "simulation"? What "reasonable" simulation would include ONE team getting picked off 10 times in a single playoff game? Do you guys even watch football? I'm starting to think that I'm surrounded here by housewives and children who may have registered here by accident.


I believe there was a bowl game and there also has never been a middle schooler playing against nfl teams.



Players at the end of season 3 are somewhere between 50 and 75% of all they will ever be and only 7 years away from their demise. You can't play the "middle schooler" card at this point--its simply not accurate.


haha - you have no clue. They may be 50% at best, meaning they are probably at best freshmen in college or something along those lines at this point.


At what point do we get to use real life results as a basis for sim results, because it looks like many just want to always say, "These are middle schoolers" and the like?

They're more than 50%. This is major college level (and major college level players who are good enough, in general, to eventually be pros). Just about everyone over level 20 has soft-capped their primary attributes (except for positions that have a lot of primary attributes).

You've admitted defenses are overpowered. Hopefully you'd admit the developers should be looking to get NFL/NCAA style numbers. I'd even say that a level 1 playing against level 1's (outside of kickers and punters, whose results are truly not dependent much on anything but their own abilities) should be putting up such stats, even though that level is Jr. High or whatever.

And the defense bias is higher in general at higher levels.

The nerfing of QB's that was done for Season 3 was a bad move.

Originally posted by SCACE
The comment is that your college freshman QB is built like woody allen.


Now, this is the area where I think your argument has merit. It's a bad build. Poor confidence should lead to some very bad games. That's what it's supposed to do: A player with low confidence is supposed to be very easy to demoralize.

Take a poorly built QB, a huge sim bias against offense that is likely to be at least partially-- ideally fully-- corrected next season, and a series of early events that demoralize the low confidence QB, and this is explainable.

Larry, you should be showcasing this as further proof that Season 3's sim is broken. But it's a combination of factors, and even in a balanced sim that QB should have 6 interception games.

And saying 10 interception games should "never" happen...suppose his confidence were 10. If it were, given the other factors (intimidation skills on defense, heavily pass defense, and the like), I'd say that after his first three interceptions he should have more chance of an interception than a completion. 10 confidence would be the confidence of an immature junior high kid.

With this QB's confidence, that shouldn't happen in a balanced sim; but this is just another example of the anti-offense bias we've both complained about.

I'm glad that my level 21 QB's confidence points, well over 40, have been well spent.

Originally posted by SCACE
and, on the topic of decline, all we know is that something will happen after season 10 - I'm guessing a plateau, where you can only boost to gain levels but don't earn any XP for a few season, allowing minimal continued growth, followed by a decline, where you can still boost to slow the speed of the decline. Either that or you can boost for X number of plateau years just to maintain you same attributes before you are boosting to decline at a slower pace.


I'm reasonably sure you're wrong there. The 10th season is, itself, a plateau, and we will stop gaining experience after the player has played 9 seasons. Even the 10th season will include no experience gains.

Everything I've read, including from Bort, suggests that by about Season 16, players won't be viable at any level. This is not at all a complaint. Players need to be cleared out so that new generations can take their place.

But, by Season 12, they'll be falling back very fast. Season 11 the decline will likely be slow enough that they can hang on.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 14:56:40
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Footballmike


I do agree that this happening in a playoff game is weird because your team shouldn't have even got their if they lost that much, but in real life (in both the NFL, NCAA, and Street Pickup games) even during a playoff their are HUGE score differences sometimes......



Yeah, but you'll notice that I haven't said a word about the score--blowouts happen, even in playoff games.

But once I scrolled down through the boxscore and saw the 10 picks, that's when the sim became a bad joke. That's not how playoff football is played. (And those that wish to pretend that this was "midget football" cheapen the game--I can promise you that's not how Bort would describe this product, Beta or not.)

Its amazing that so many will pretend to defend the indefensible.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
*yawn* your arguments are stale Larry, eitehr come up with a real argument other than "10 picks shouldn't ever happen, ever ever" or just pack it up and let's be done with this thread.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Ken - if you're right that they will fall off steep after season 11 and won't grow in season 10, then I'll buy into them being college players now. That said, even the best college players can have awful games, and by no means is this QB a good college player build.

I do hope you're wrong and there is more than one plateau season.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I would really to know the confidence scores of the players on the losing team.


Plus, the cool thing about this game is their is a counter to just about every strategy and every build. I would wager that the other team was built almost perfectly to beat yours.
 
NilanJ92
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Footballmike



I do agree that this happening in a playoff game is weird because your team shouldn't have even got their if they lost that much, but in real life (in both the NFL, NCAA, and Street Pickup games) even during a playoff their are HUGE score differences sometimes......



Yeah, but you'll notice that I haven't said a word about the score--blowouts happen, even in playoff games.

But once I scrolled down through the boxscore and saw the 10 picks, that's when the sim became a bad joke. That's not how playoff football is played. (And those that wish to pretend that this was "midget football" cheapen the game--I can promise you that's not how Bort would describe this product, Beta or not.)

Its amazing that so many will pretend to defend the indefensible.


Dude, will you quit being so defiant and just try fixing your crappy build with 52 stamina? Why do you insist on comparing it to real life football? The difference with this and that is you can create crappy players that have a high level in this, which is what your QB is. In the NFL sure I guess they'd be the equivalent of level 26-30 or so, but their "builds" don't change (a college player will be built like a college player, and an NFL player will be built like an NFL player). The sim itself does have problems, but I'm sure you wouldn't have thrown 10 picks if your build was better or what not...
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
I would really to know the confidence scores of the players on the losing team.


Plus, the cool thing about this game is their is a counter to just about every strategy and every build. I would wager that the other team was built almost perfectly to beat yours.


We know the QB was 29, which is a key fact in this loss. On top of the low confidence, the rest of his build is also poor, which didn't help matters.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Its amazing that so many will pretend to defend the indefensible.


That's how I feel about boosting.

But I also feel that way about your QB's stats (and though many others also claim that your QB has terrible stats, I see many high level QBs who have stats similar - "low" confidence and very high Stamina).

The game, and therefore Bort, did many Agents a disservice by not having more depth chart options. Right now the ONLY way to put a backup QB into the game is to set the breath settings high enough that the Starter gets tired. Once a starting QB has a very high Stamina - they are stuck. Backup Player won't get any plays, and a faltering QB will just continue to wither on the field. In short: the game absolutely needs to have additional checks to pull players out. Breath? Great, but also Moral and even a way to divide up playing time between multiple players.
 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Footballmike



I do agree that this happening in a playoff game is weird because your team shouldn't have even got their if they lost that much, but in real life (in both the NFL, NCAA, and Street Pickup games) even during a playoff their are HUGE score differences sometimes......



Yeah, but you'll notice that I haven't said a word about the score--blowouts happen, even in playoff games.

But once I scrolled down through the boxscore and saw the 10 picks, that's when the sim became a bad joke. That's not how playoff football is played. (And those that wish to pretend that this was "midget football" cheapen the game--I can promise you that's not how Bort would describe this product, Beta or not.)

Its amazing that so many will pretend to defend the indefensible.


Yes Larry, but once again when me and my friends go play backyard football (not too often since we all work now lol) 10 picks is nothing. Now we don't really have playoffs, but we do play some other people sometimes and still 10 picks per team isn't that bad. The QBs are decent and the defense is pretty good its just how it goes....
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I know it's NOT 10 PICKS, but here are a few gem games that I found...


Orange Bowl:

Most Passes Had Intercepted: 7
Missouri (vs. Penn State), 1970

Most Passes Had Intercepted, Both Teams: 10
Georgia (6) vs. Texas Christian (4), 1942

Sun Bowl:

Most Passes Had Intercepted, Both Teams: 12
Arizona (8) vs. Auburn (4) 1968

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigdawg_56
Yeah, I know it's NOT 10 PICKS, but here are a few gem games that I found...


Orange Bowl:

Most Passes Had Intercepted: 7
Missouri (vs. Penn State), 1970

Most Passes Had Intercepted, Both Teams: 10
Georgia (6) vs. Texas Christian (4), 1942

Sun Bowl:

Most Passes Had Intercepted, Both Teams: 12
Arizona (8) vs. Auburn (4) 1968



What Larry keeps missing is that more options for subbing the QB out would solve the problem and we wouldn't even be having a discussion about 10 picks. If anything is broken or missing here, its that (along with no ability to throw the ball away or eat a sack).

Confidence is working as intended by the programmer/creator, the problem lies in the fact that the user can't sub the player out when low confidence becomes a serious issue in a game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.