Originally posted by Herram
I understand that earthquake data may correlate with Elenin alignments, but there is a distinction between correlation and causation.
Moderate amount of math to follow:
It has been estimated that the total mass of all of the comets in our solar system approaches 2% of the mass of the sun. http://www.springerlink.com/content/q2p26v0521hj7lg3/
If Elenin was ~190 million miles away from the Earth on March 11th, and gravity is the only known force that Celestial bodies can impart on one another at that distance (forces that may influence plate tectonics, that is), then it needs to have a significant gravitational force.
The mass of the Earth is ~ 6 x 10^24 kilograms, and (to be fair, I'll make an assumption on the mass of Elenin based on the average mass of comets in the solar system) Elenin is probably close to 4 x 10^12, maybe as much as 4 x 10^16 kilograms.
Using the heavier of the weights for Elenin there, the difference between the Earth and Elenin's mass is ~ 10^8 kilograms, or 100 million kilograms. Using the lesser (10^12), it would be 1 trillion kilograms.
At ~190 million miles, a heavier Elenin would deliver 38,504,806.3 pounds of force on our dear old Earth. A lighter Elenin would deliver 3,850.5 pounds of force.
The Moon exerts its gravitational pull at a fairly constant rate of 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 kilograms from a mere 250,000 miles away.
In comparison, that is 4,200,000,000,000,000,000, or 4.2 quintillion pounds of force. This is a significant difference, for anyone unfamiliar with the term quintillion.
On March 11, 2011 that means Elenin got to pull on Earth at 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 / 38,504,806.3 = 1.1 x 10^12 (heavy Elenin) or 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 / 3,850.5 = 1.1 x 10 ^ 16 less force than the Moon applies to the Earth all day every day.
So, even using the probably way too heavy number for Elenin, it exerted 1/1,100,000,000,000 of the Moons effect on the Earth that day. With the lighter Elenin, 1/11,000,000,000,000,000 of the Moons effect on the Earth.
For all of the additional force of the Moon, its only appreciable effect on our planet is the tides.
Edit: Incorrectly referenced May 11th as the date of the Japanese earthquake.
Edit: Typo
Can we lock this thread on this note?
I understand that earthquake data may correlate with Elenin alignments, but there is a distinction between correlation and causation.
Moderate amount of math to follow:
It has been estimated that the total mass of all of the comets in our solar system approaches 2% of the mass of the sun. http://www.springerlink.com/content/q2p26v0521hj7lg3/
If Elenin was ~190 million miles away from the Earth on March 11th, and gravity is the only known force that Celestial bodies can impart on one another at that distance (forces that may influence plate tectonics, that is), then it needs to have a significant gravitational force.
The mass of the Earth is ~ 6 x 10^24 kilograms, and (to be fair, I'll make an assumption on the mass of Elenin based on the average mass of comets in the solar system) Elenin is probably close to 4 x 10^12, maybe as much as 4 x 10^16 kilograms.
Using the heavier of the weights for Elenin there, the difference between the Earth and Elenin's mass is ~ 10^8 kilograms, or 100 million kilograms. Using the lesser (10^12), it would be 1 trillion kilograms.
At ~190 million miles, a heavier Elenin would deliver 38,504,806.3 pounds of force on our dear old Earth. A lighter Elenin would deliver 3,850.5 pounds of force.
The Moon exerts its gravitational pull at a fairly constant rate of 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 kilograms from a mere 250,000 miles away.
In comparison, that is 4,200,000,000,000,000,000, or 4.2 quintillion pounds of force. This is a significant difference, for anyone unfamiliar with the term quintillion.
On March 11, 2011 that means Elenin got to pull on Earth at 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 / 38,504,806.3 = 1.1 x 10^12 (heavy Elenin) or 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 / 3,850.5 = 1.1 x 10 ^ 16 less force than the Moon applies to the Earth all day every day.
So, even using the probably way too heavy number for Elenin, it exerted 1/1,100,000,000,000 of the Moons effect on the Earth that day. With the lighter Elenin, 1/11,000,000,000,000,000 of the Moons effect on the Earth.
For all of the additional force of the Moon, its only appreciable effect on our planet is the tides.
Edit: Incorrectly referenced May 11th as the date of the Japanese earthquake.
Edit: Typo
Can we lock this thread on this note?






























