User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Page:
 
Link
 
There is too much you need to do on the defense AI, it's much more complicated then the offense. Because the down, distance and # of WR's are huge factors that need to be in the input and the output has a lot of variables to add as well. Something slightly more simpler would be better IMO. Though that's not gonna happen I'm pretty sure we are stuck with these.

I just think it's a little TOO time consuming if you want it to work right....
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 11:54:51
 
bdstolar
offline
Link
 
i love the settings.

not complicated.

perfect for developing a shutdown D.

 
BucJordan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersFanatic
There is too much you need to do on the defense AI, it's much more complicated then the offense. Because the down, distance and # of WR's are huge factors that need to be in the input and the output has a lot of variables to add as well. Something slightly more simpler would be better IMO. Though that's not gonna happen I'm pretty sure we are stuck with these.


I guess I'm one of the few who likes it this complicated. I thought it was a lot of fun setting up different tactics for different situations/formations.
 
GalapagosJoe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sleepyfool
does anyone else have the problem of the new AI not actually working in their scrimmage game? We have implemented the 3-4 defense and I didn't see it at all in our scrimmage game.


We had the same problem. My RILB didn't play one down in the game. It ran a 4-3 the entire time.
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by magicalmrrich
If any of you haven't seen the other threads about this, apparently there was a bug in these games where the opponents base defence was being called instead of your own.


Any word when this bug will be fixed?
 
miner49er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just uploaded the latest version of the Defense AI Builder interface for everyone (team owners and DC's) to play with.

Building and testing the ridiculous number of plays required for all the possible settings is turning out to be the major time sink on this - there are a lot of combinations that can come up! I keep adding options as I go, too, making more plays I have to put in.

You should be able to play with the interface for now, and I'll make an announcement when it's actually ready to go for sims. It's be the sort of thing you can turn on and off to make the play calling algorithm call a different code path dependent on your settings (new vs old).

Please note that this is step 1 of the advanced tactics update. Additional adds, later, will include setting defensive matchups, and per-package subs/depth charts.

BTW, the offense AI builder will be similar: based on inputs/outputs so you build up your custom "AI."


Edit by scarletmbb:

I've posted up screenshots over here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=408231

Here's a preliminary guide that might help people who don't understand football as well:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=409918


 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersFanatic
There is too much you need to do on the defense AI, it's much more complicated then the offense. Because the down, distance and # of WR's are huge factors that need to be in the input and the output has a lot of variables to add as well. Something slightly more simpler would be better IMO. Though that's not gonna happen I'm pretty sure we are stuck with these.

I just think it's a little TOO time consuming if you want it to work right....


Actually once you get your base defense set up it should be pretty simple to make adjustments per opponent.
 
Dark Gable
offline
Link
 
For playing a 3-4, Is the lineman going to be 3 DE or 3 DT's or 2 DT's and 1 DE or vice versa?
 
rwblake
offline
Link
 
There are a lot of things to consider when creating the defense.
I have created about 100 plays already for a team. Some general and some situation specific.
I am by no means finished. There are lots of additional situations to create a play scheme for I've not touched yet.

I like being able to be creative with the blitz, LB shifts, the type of pass coverage, etc.

I'd like to see more complication for those who want it, like being able to say what the D-linemen do on a rush(pass or run blitz, going into coverage, bull rush, speed or finesse rush).
I can finally utilize the strengths of my teams defense instead of the stupid things the SIM would do.

Rob
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dark Gable
For playing a 3-4, Is the lineman going to be 3 DE or 3 DT's or 2 DT's and 1 DE or vice versa?


It would be your choice, you can play DE DT DE or any combo by how you set up your depth chart
 
Rudog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brutus Buckeye
Originally posted by Dark Gable

For playing a 3-4, Is the lineman going to be 3 DE or 3 DT's or 2 DT's and 1 DE or vice versa?


It would be your choice, you can play DE DT DE or any combo by how you set up your depth chart


The literal positions from the depth chart they take are LDE NT RDE. Who you put in those positions is your business.
 
Rudog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GalapagosJoe
Originally posted by sleepyfool

does anyone else have the problem of the new AI not actually working in their scrimmage game? We have implemented the 3-4 defense and I didn't see it at all in our scrimmage game.


We had the same problem. My RILB didn't play one down in the game. It ran a 4-3 the entire time.


Question for you guys. Did you double check your input scenarios? One of my friend's didn't work right because he had 'Between 5 and 3 yards' instead of 'Between 3 and 5 yards'. At least we're pretty sure that was it.
 
Link
 
Bort has said there was Bug that actually was picking your opponents AI settings on defense in some games, that should be fixed now. Your opponent must have been running the 4-3.
 
snakesplace
offline
Link
 
the sestem doesnt work in simms yet !!! its there to tinker with.
 
kevindurant35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by snakesplace
the sestem doesnt work in simms yet !!! its there to tinker with.


he said its available for you to test in scrimmages. how else can poeple run a 3-4
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.