User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
I noticed you made some improvements again to the archetypes, and i have to admit they are looking really good.

The changes you made to the HB, TE, WR, and LB look spot on.

i have 2 suggestions if I may about FB and DB.

For FB no matter which type they should all have strength and blocking somewhere on their list. All teams pretty much use FB on special teams so we kind of need those 2 to go up either as a major or minor.

2nd, for DBs jumping should be a major for both man and zone archetypes. right now zone has tackling. The problem is this makes the man choice way better. They both have a great bonus SA in super vision or shutdown for corners so that is equal. Why not let jumping be the 4th major for both to keep that equal as well. Tackling as a 4th for the zone choice is meh...

Anyway, thanks for trying to improve the archetypes already.
 
Link
 
Question: Will the various penalties to SAs vary in the amount across archetypes/positions? ie a defensive player may have a 10% penalty to shed blocks, and an offensive player may have a 30% penalty to pocket presence?
 
jkid2
offline
Link
 
Scrambling QB- Speed and not agility should be a major skill. How can scrambling QBs not have speed as a major?
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by monsterkill
just how intense are the new archetype-specific SAs going to be? seems like a lot of the discussion around archetype balance is kind of premature if we're not able to take into account these new SAs. especially if these new archetypes are on par with stuff like SDC/SV but for their respective roles


This.

The whole returner/elusive debate could be irrelevant if the returner SA is good enough. Many of these debate could end with good arch specific SAs.
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Evidently you are trying to..............I don't know whay you're trying to do, really.
Some odd reason you are trying to pick at my post in a way my post wasn't meant to be taken?
You make it sound like I said you can't post any more suggestions? And that I said this suggestion is perfect? Really, you should go to bed.
And yes, they do look for you input, which is what this thread that you are posting in is about. To discuss it. My post, which you decided to try and rip, was to offer proof that they do take the input and suggestion of users. Though, at times it might take longer than you would like. But again, how much of a users input should be good for the game is anyones best guess. Me, personally, I would just much rather Bort make the game the way he had it envisioned, tbh. Thing about it, Vet abilities was all based off of user input, the same users that eventually came back on complaining about them. Same with the realism stats. Same with the minor league structure. User input is valuable, but it can also hinder certain aspects of the game if the wrong majority puts in their input the most. The admins need to sort, debate, and finally fine tune/implement the done deal, based off the user input.
Of course, you could be in an uproar over JD being in an uproar because Catch doesn't want his inbox flooded with PM's about different suggestions from different users. In which case, I really don't blame him. Teh amount of PM's mods and lolmods gets is in excess, I can only imagine what an active Admin's inbox looks like.
Again, that is what the Archetype thread are for. Use it.



fyp

i have nothing against the idea... if you looked through those suggestion threads (not saying you didnt), you find my name in the supporters of one of those threads... in fact im pretty sure it was my idea exclusively for each "sub type" as i called them to have a "sub type" exclusive SA which catch has apparently been thinking about implementing if he can think one for every arch type (although, i think in the current sim, i think this would work better as an exclusive VA) i just think things would be going much much smoother if:

Originally posted by Worker 3
B.) threw out that GLB will be going to an arch-type system, and let users discuss, argue, and figure out what most of the arch types and their ALGs should be (ridiculous ones like rushing QB would of course be thrown out), then take it to the mod forum or whatever and let them maybe fine tune and perfect it a little bit.


then release what the archtypes are gonna be after carefully examining them in the mod forum (its really not too difficult to see if one is over powered. we spotted them within 48 hours, and had there been a user discussion before hand, there wouldnt be all the changes because most of the work would already be done for you guys.) yeah, there will still be some cryers, but that will be the minority that catch doesnt want to give in to.

my issue isnt with the idea, its with how its being implemented. even if catch had all these archtypes planned out ahead of time, having a user discussion before hand would have at least made us think that our opinions on the matter count. now we just know that they dont.

i hardly consider "oh this is over powered" an opinion. thats more of fact than anything.
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 11, 2010 10:06:04
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 11, 2010 10:04:18
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 11, 2010 10:03:59
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
When you make a change to the proposed archetypes, can you note the change in another post in the proposed archetype thread?
 
ZoSo1
offline
Link
 
this new system will promote cookie cutter builds imo
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ZoSo1
this new system will promote cookie cutter builds imo


The current system promotes cookie-cutter builds.... this will just promote more different cookies. More cookies is better.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
Originally posted by ZoSo1

this new system will promote cookie cutter builds imo


The current system promotes cookie-cutter builds.... this will just promote more different cookies. More cookies is better.


 
allstarpdc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
The current system promotes cookie-cutter builds.... this will just promote more different cookies. More cookies is better.


Originally posted by ZoSo1
this new system will promote cookie cutter builds imo


Both are right on. Until there are more than 7 skills & attributes and the same 5 SAs per set ...the cookies will keep coming
 
AggieSig
offline
Link
 
The game will always be in Beta. We shouldn't be paying for the constant changes anymore.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AggieSig
The game will always be in Beta. We shouldn't be paying for the constant changes anymore.


No one is making you. You know that because the game is beta that they are going to keep tweaking and fixing and changing things around. Pay less money, pay more money, pay no money... those are up to you.

As for me, I'm glad that they are focusing on making the changes to make the game better and that this is a spot for doing so...

The new archetypes are a great idea and I look forward to being able to use them next season.
 
bgharst
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by some shitty mod

Thread locked by moderator.

You're getting over 70% back. Also, no one is making you start over.


This is bullshit. Im getting over 70 back oooooh aaaaaah so awesome. Im getting shit on is what is happening. The last change looked like the big change so we went ahead and started our team again. Now you come out with a complete overhaul of the system a little over a season later and dont offer a full refund?

And as for no one making me start over? You did when you fixed half the stupid shit you acted like you were ignoring for so long.
Edited by bgharst on Feb 11, 2010 12:14:45
Edited by bgharst on Feb 11, 2010 12:13:31
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I'm a big fan of yesterday's changes to the Archetypes.
Bravo, admins.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I'm a big fan of yesterday's changes to the Archetypes.
Bravo, admins.


Are those changes detailed somewhere or am I going to have to look through 56 pages to find them or remember exactly what they were before they changed?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.