User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Arya Stark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sniper24
This idea sucks because it penalizes people that just want to win. If you're so concerned about getting your ass kicked by higher lvls, go out and recruit. I've worked hard to recruit FA lvl.15-17's to my new African AA team, and now I'm gonna get penalized for it? This always happens with MMORPG's. Somebody makes a piss-ass update that ruins the game, and the game never recovers. Just leave the game alone...


This is an excellent idea. Here is one good proof:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1900
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WVUFAN1971
I'll give y'all an example:

I have a Level 18 Linebacker currently playing in East Europe AAA league. His contract ends at the end of this season. The median level of most AAA leagues is 15. I'm fine, right?

Yes, but only if I don't boost.

If I boost at the beginning of this season, I got to 21 -- hitting that threshhold where I'm gonna get punished for being too high of a level. Still, with the rules Bort mentioned, it should be that bad ... this season.

Next year, when I go into free agency, and if I boost again, assuming I went up 2 levels during Season 3, that makes my linebacker Level 26, and FORCING me to ONLY pick Pro Level Leagues unless I really want to take a hit.

If I don't boost, AT ALL -- ie, I don't give GLB any money, I'm 20th or 21 at the end of Season 3, still within threshold of most AAA leagues and Pro Leagues, thus giving me more options when I hit FA.

So ... why in the living hell should I boost knowing it'll going to severely limit my player in the coming season?



I see, so in your theory, you are the only player on GLB boosting.
 
Link
 
WVU: because others are boosting also, the Median+8 Max level is the start of the XP Loss penalty, and it is recalculated every night, so since others are boosting and leveling up, the median in increasing at the same rate.
You can be a couple of levels above it with a perfect sportsmanship score and take little/no penalty.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nyte
Less QQ

More reading comprehension

Great decision Bort!


Yes. Emphasis on "More reading comprehension"
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sniper24
This idea sucks because it penalizes people that just want to win. If you're so concerned about getting your ass kicked by higher lvls, go out and recruit. I've worked hard to recruit FA lvl.15-17's to my new African AA team, and now I'm gonna get penalized for it? This always happens with MMORPG's. Somebody makes a piss-ass update that ruins the game, and the game never recovers. Just leave the game alone...


"Now I'm pretty much giving everybody a clean slate at this point with a max sportsmanship score EXCEPT for some of the teams that have recently done some obvious stack/gut jobs."

You have nothing to worry about. In addition, your team isn't stacked.

This update is SO not about you. Chances are if you had to build your team under these rules, it still wouldn't affect you.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by WVUFAN1971

I'll give y'all an example:

I have a Level 18 Linebacker currently playing in East Europe AAA league. His contract ends at the end of this season. The median level of most AAA leagues is 15. I'm fine, right?

Yes, but only if I don't boost.

If I boost at the beginning of this season, I got to 21 -- hitting that threshhold where I'm gonna get punished for being too high of a level. Still, with the rules Bort mentioned, it should be that bad ... this season.

Next year, when I go into free agency, and if I boost again, assuming I went up 2 levels during Season 3, that makes my linebacker Level 26, and FORCING me to ONLY pick Pro Level Leagues unless I really want to take a hit.

If I don't boost, AT ALL -- ie, I don't give GLB any money, I'm 20th or 21 at the end of Season 3, still within threshold of most AAA leagues and Pro Leagues, thus giving me more options when I hit FA.

So ... why in the living hell should I boost knowing it'll going to severely limit my player in the coming season?



I see, so in your theory, you are the only player on GLB boosting.


Exactly -- SO many players boost that boosting will not hurt you at all, I'm figuring. It also gives you a boost to sportsmanship. If you're scared of the XP hit that much, boost once midseason and give your sportsmanship a little nudge (though I'm sure it won't be an issue if you're playing fair)
 
sturge
offline
Link
 
I love this idea. Just like in any MMORG if you go beat up on low level monsters you don't get as much xp.

I agree though he should've done this before the offseason started so people could better prepare.
 
hazyblue
offline
Link
 
Couldn't be bothered to read all of the thread but the first 9-10 pages its the same people complaining over and over. Anyone who signs their lvl 20 to a basement league deserves to suffer. If a top player went and played in a minor league sure he'd dominate but he wouldn't improve as a player like he would playing against similar opposition in a better league, thats common sense.

This rule is aimed at the minority of people who like to try and game the system or rack up huge stats and now they've had their cake taken away they are throwing their toys out of the pram.

Thanks Bort, at least in GLB cheaters won't prosper.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:21:57
 
sniper24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by sniper24

This idea sucks because it penalizes people that just want to win. If you're so concerned about getting your ass kicked by higher lvls, go out and recruit. I've worked hard to recruit FA lvl.15-17's to my new African AA team, and now I'm gonna get penalized for it? This always happens with MMORPG's. Somebody makes a piss-ass update that ruins the game, and the game never recovers. Just leave the game alone...


"Now I'm pretty much giving everybody a clean slate at this point with a max sportsmanship score EXCEPT for some of the teams that have recently done some obvious stack/gut jobs."

You have nothing to worry about. In addition, your team isn't stacked.

This update is SO not about you. Chances are if you had to build your team under these rules, it still wouldn't affect you.


Alright, thanks for the clarification.
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay



I see, so in your theory, you are the only player on GLB boosting.


You can't account for other players boosting or not. You cannot assume that the median will rise in accordance to your player if your player is already way about the standard median.

This rule will cause people to stop boosting, and will seriously affect GLB in the coming months. Mark my words.

And what about my second example, re: my TE?
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:24:44
 
Hiccup
offline
Link
 
To recap Bort.

Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ?

Instead of making strict rules that affect everyone, why not have severe discipline for cheaters.


Because bringing in a high leveled team of ringers isn't cheating per se. It's just bad sportsmanship. We are doing this to encourage higher leveled players to find more suitable competition.

I love the complaints, guys. Keep them coming. You have no idea how big or small the effect will be, how the math will work, and yet you are worried it will allow other people to catch up and compete (including the other players on your own team!), or that it will somehow decimate your team. That helps prove to me that we're targeting the right area of the game: the part that people actually care enough about that they will think about fair play.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by MD

Originally posted by Houndster

Originally posted by MD

So if this is based on that average league player level list, our entire league will be penalized almost.

That doesn't make any sense. If your entire league is good your average will reflect your players.

Yes it does. Our league has an average of like 14.xx. But theres a ton of players around Level 17 and up. Do all the players higher than level 14 get penalized?


I never said it was based on average level. It will be based on median level, which is quite a bit different. I also never said what the "fudge factor" would be. I said that if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see zero to little effect on your player. Take that at its word.

This is not an update to punish teams who recruit well. We are not adding this willy-nilly with no thought to players who stick with teams for the long haul. Like I said, the formula will not be given, but all of these things will be taken into account.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by hexone

Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.

Like I said in the post, if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see little to no effect from this update. Things such as length of time with the team and in the league are all part of the formula I have worked out.

The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!

Ye of little faith, yeesh.

Seriously, though, all this concern really does prove to me that XP is the proper target. Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by LJ

this is my first complaint against something bort has added, ive DEDICATED my players to the Krakow Outlaws, And the Northwest Nighthawks.
Yes im a higher level been in Outlaws since first season and nighthawks since beginning of second. Now im faced with the dilema... Either get released now and abandon these teams i promised to stay with and take the hit in EXP. or move.
sure i could most but these guys i gotten quite close to its just not that easy, ill feel bad if i did it now. And also i paid to be the level i am and now ill be penalized for this to bring me straight back down with the non paying kiddie? uh uh i dont think so

so because of this, Im leaving my teams cause if i dont i woulda wasted 200+ dollars to get ahead of these others.


Just sayin: Based on the formula I'm using, if you've been with your team that long, there will be no effect on your player.



Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by FairForever

I thought about it. Sure.

The main problem is that it was implemented so late in the off-season, teams don't have time to adjust. I just wish it was said earlier in the offseason.


Like most other things I've done that affect performance and whatnot, the plan would be to start off with a really small max modifier and work up to a higher one as needed.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

People WILL be getting refunds for the Flex they bought that they will never use because they will just get punished for it, right?


Because boosting couldn't POSSIBLY be part of the formula I've been talking about (along with contract length, etc)...


Originally posted by Bort


No, the formula will not be released. I don't want people finding ways to exploit it.

I agree that I'm probably coming off as gruff...it's 1:30am and I've been dealing with a lot of players doing crappy things lately. I need to go to bed


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thehazyone

I spend a lot of money on this site and I like the rule. I think many people are overreacting. I don't think Bort is meaning to punish level 18 players in a league where the median is level 14 or 15, he's looking to punish level 18 players in a league where the median is level 10.


Wow, somebody gets it! And perhaps those who recently moved there from a higher median region, with a bunch of their buddies?


In summation of Bort’s posts.
- Cheaters and poor sports will be most affected. Bringing your level 18 player into a BBB league to play with friends will probably not be hit by this. Your friends bringing ALL their level 18-20’s players from an upper league to a lower league will probably be affected.
- It will be based on median level, not average.
- If you are playing within the “spirit of the game” you have no worries. I would imagine this to mean that recruiting and boosting are safe.
- Quote verbatim - The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!
- The formula, and sportsmanship score will not be released because it will be exploited if it is avalible.
- Read http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=355508

Anything that is not in the above, or in the linked thread is just speculation and overreaction.
 
saltman241
offline
Link
 
Great solution to a very dynamic problem. Many props to Bort. Perhaps GLB isn't doomed after all.
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay


A. if the Median for AAA is 30, more than likely the median for Pro will be, 36,37,38 that number

So B.

If your HB is 38, why wouldnt he find a spot in a "Pro" league, there are more than one of them around.



When there are more level 38 and above HB's than there are spots in the Pro League. Are you saying there will never be a time when there are more than 64 level 38 and above HB's?

2 spots per team, starting and the back-up they both will see a lot of playing time. The third string guy might not. What am I going to do with my level 40 HB and all the pro spots are filled? I hope I dont have to take a third string spot to avoid being punished by being to high to stay in the AAA leagues. Plus if I leave the AAA team it might hurt their chance of getting to the pros next season.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WVUFAN1971
Originally posted by sjmay




I see, so in your theory, you are the only player on GLB boosting.


You can't account for other players boosting or not. You cannot assume that the median will rise in accordance to your player if your player is already way about the standard median.

This rule will cause people to stop boosting, and will seriously affect GLB in the coming months. Mark my words.


So you are assuming that out of the what, 2500 people in one league, no one but you will boost, therefore you will be "out" of that league,

I don't know what to tell you, because you are right, if you are the only one out of 2500 to boost, you are dead on,

Now ask me how unlikely it is that you are the only one boosting.
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97

Don't you mean 64 * 8 = 512 starting HB slots in the PRO leagues?

As for teams that get relegated. The longer you play for a team, the better your score. I imagine if a player has been with a team a few seasons, played 40 games with them, resigned three times, and boosted regularly (all pluses to sportsmanship), that player won't have a problem.


I am confused with this, forgive me if I am an idjit.

This is what I have.... 32 Pro teams in the USA, 16 per conference.

2 spots for the No.1 and No.2, since those will see a lot of playing time.

32 teams X 2 spots = 64 players that will see a lot of snaps

Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:27:27
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.