User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by HurricaneBear



Originally posted by beenlurken




Originally posted by Gart888





I really don't see how promoting 2 teams from each reason every season isn't equal opportunity. o_O


Again, the better players/gms go to USA. Sure, they have an equal opportunity to reach the WPL but not to say. Both teams will make the WPL but the USAPL team will be stronger and have much better chance of staying. I really dont see how you dont understand this yet.


who is forcing these "better" players/gms to go to USA? Not everyone thinks USA is god's gift to GLB


Not everyone . . . but 70%+ are deceived by nationalistic fervor into believing the region your dot plays in actually matters.


So rename the regions by colors. If it becomes the Orange league the only reason to go there is because it is your favorite color right?


If we do this then why not just go to a complete pyramid system (considering regions will no longer matter)?


It is a pyramid! Just one with a tiny peak that widens very quickly then slows down.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by HurricaneBear


Originally posted by beenlurken



Originally posted by Gart888




I really don't see how promoting 2 teams from each reason every season isn't equal opportunity. o_O


Again, the better players/gms go to USA. Sure, they have an equal opportunity to reach the WPL but not to say. Both teams will make the WPL but the USAPL team will be stronger and have much better chance of staying. I really dont see how you dont understand this yet.


who is forcing these "better" players/gms to go to USA? Not everyone thinks USA is god's gift to GLB


Not everyone . . . but 70%+ are deceived by nationalistic fervor into believing the region your dot plays in actually matters.


So rename the regions by colors. If it becomes the Orange league the only reason to go there is because it is your favorite color right?


Color doesn't carry to same identify formation power that nationality does.

I'm all in favor of blowing regions to smithereens.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by HurricaneBear



Originally posted by beenlurken




Originally posted by Gart888





I really don't see how promoting 2 teams from each reason every season isn't equal opportunity. o_O


Again, the better players/gms go to USA. Sure, they have an equal opportunity to reach the WPL but not to say. Both teams will make the WPL but the USAPL team will be stronger and have much better chance of staying. I really dont see how you dont understand this yet.


who is forcing these "better" players/gms to go to USA? Not everyone thinks USA is god's gift to GLB


Not everyone . . . but 70%+ are deceived by nationalistic fervor into believing the region your dot plays in actually matters.


So rename the regions by colors. If it becomes the Orange league the only reason to go there is because it is your favorite color right?


If we do this then why not just go to a complete pyramid system (considering regions will no longer matter)?


Yes. We should eliminate the regions (no more USA, Africa, Oceania, etc.). The pro leagues become AAAA leagues and the WL become Pro. Problem solved.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Don't get rid of regions.

It gives the game flavor.


Well, maybe we should name the leagues after flavors then . . . Salty League, Sweet League, Sour League, Bile League . . .
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Don't get rid of regions.

It gives the game flavor.


Well, maybe we should name the leagues after flavors then . . . Salty League, Sweet League, Sour League, Bile League . . .


I want to be in Bile League!
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
sounds like a bunch of USAPL players wish they hadn't thought of themselves as the greatest thing ever. No one told all of you to flock to USAPL. not any of the other regions fault that you went there. WPL shouldn't have to worry about a few players pissed because they suddenly aren't "top dog" any more. If the USAPL teams that don't make it the first season are so good, they will make it the second season. Get in line like the rest of the teams that didn't make it.

World Pro League is supposed to be about the entire game, not some USAPL douches who think they are better than everyone else
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
IF we eliminate the regions...

then we should randomly shuffle all the teams in the regions across their respective levels

for example blue region would teams from every other region

same for red region, green region, brown region, etc.

otherwise we'd still know who was USA Pro and who was OPL, and who was weak, and who was not
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by beenlurken

Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by HurricaneBear

Originally posted by beenlurken

Originally posted by Gart888

I really don't see how promoting 2 teams from each reason every season isn't equal opportunity. o_O

Again, the better players/gms go to USA. Sure, they have an equal opportunity to reach the WPL but not to say. Both teams will make the WPL but the USAPL team will be stronger and have much better chance of staying. I really dont see how you dont understand this yet.

who is forcing these "better" players/gms to go to USA? Not everyone thinks USA is god's gift to GLB

Not everyone . . . but 70%+ are deceived by nationalistic fervor into believing the region your dot plays in actually matters.

So rename the regions by colors. If it becomes the Orange league the only reason to go there is because it is your favorite color right?

If we do this then why not just go to a complete pyramid system (considering regions will no longer matter)?


Yes. We should eliminate the regions (no more USA, Africa, Oceania, etc.). The pro leagues become AAAA leagues and the WL become Pro. Problem solved.


I think you overestimate "virtual nationalistic fervor" and underestimate the relationships and rivalries that teams develop as they make their way up the ladder to their respective Pro leagues. THOSE are the reasons that people are clinging to their regional "roots"---not some blind loyalty to some fictional geographic designation. I tend to be a loner, but there are still those I've met along the way that I enjoy competing against/commiserating with. Put me in a different region/ladder, whether you call it USA/Oceania, Orange/Blue or AAAA/AAA and I lose all those and the game becomes a lot less fun.

Edited by Knightman on Jul 27, 2009 23:48:33
Edited by Knightman on Jul 27, 2009 23:46:57
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
sounds like a bunch of USAPL players wish they hadn't thought of themselves as the greatest thing ever. No one told all of you to flock to USAPL. not any of the other regions fault that you went there. WPL shouldn't have to worry about a few players pissed because they suddenly aren't "top dog" any more. If the USAPL teams that don't make it the first season are so good, they will make it the second season. Get in line like the rest of the teams that didn't make it.

World Pro League is supposed to be about the entire game, not some USAPL douches who think they are better than everyone else


Huh?

Have you read this thread at all?
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
sounds like a bunch of USAPL players wish they hadn't thought of themselves as the greatest thing ever. No one told all of you to flock to USAPL. not any of the other regions fault that you went there. WPL shouldn't have to worry about a few players pissed because they suddenly aren't "top dog" any more. If the USAPL teams that don't make it the first season are so good, they will make it the second season. Get in line like the rest of the teams that didn't make it.

World Pro League is supposed to be about the entire game, not some USAPL douches who think they are better than everyone else


Your USA-envy is showing.....

What's being advocated is NOT a system designed to favor USA per se, but one that puts the BEST teams in GLB in the WPL---not just the best from each region. Each region has an opportunity to be represented, but once in the WPL, individual TEAMS must prove they belong--it's a merit system. You win and you EARN the right to stay.

The division system that was being proposed mandated that inferior teams be allowed to stay just because they came from an inferior region. That's hardly the way to showcase the "Best of the Best."

It basically boils down to whether teams should be required to EARN the right to stay in WPL, or get it handed to them based on the lottery of which league they came from.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
I may or may not be wrong with how the past few pages of this thread sound to me, but if you think I am envious of USA your out of your mind.
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Gabrosin


I think the divisional system is a convenient and easy way to solve this problem with a bare minimum of changes required, AND it has the added benefit of being flexible and extensible for future seasons. But ultimately I'm fine with any scheme with the following properties:

1. Start off with the top four teams from each Pro league.
2. Promote each Pro league champion and maybe each Pro conference champion.
3. Demote either eight or sixteen teams, and ensure that each one goes back to its original league.

Any other details are unimportant.
Everyone agrees with that, this entire thread is basically "8 or 16", "divisions" and "where do they go" ... your solution says we need divisions to do step 3, the most common suggestion, it seems, is to force them down and use Pro-AAA traffic to even out the Pros. another one has been to try to force it and only screw over those teams that really did badly in Pros.


Oh believe me, not everyone agrees with that. But I think enough do. And I don't say we NEED divisions... once again that reading comprehension problem comes out.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

Originally posted by Gabrosin



I think the divisional system is a convenient and easy way to solve this problem with a bare minimum of changes required, AND it has the added benefit of being flexible and extensible for future seasons. But ultimately I'm fine with any scheme with the following properties:

1. Start off with the top four teams from each Pro league.
2. Promote each Pro league champion and maybe each Pro conference champion.
3. Demote either eight or sixteen teams, and ensure that each one goes back to its original league.

Any other details are unimportant.
Everyone agrees with that, this entire thread is basically "8 or 16", "divisions" and "where do they go" ... your solution says we need divisions to do step 3, the most common suggestion, it seems, is to force them down and use Pro-AAA traffic to even out the Pros. another one has been to try to force it and only screw over those teams that really did badly in Pros.


Oh believe me, not everyone agrees with that. But I think enough do. And I don't say we NEED divisions... once again that reading comprehension problem comes out.


The personal attacks don't help your argument, fwiw.

Even number of promotions from each league every season, 16 non-playoff demotions every season FTW.

If the 14th, 13th, or even 12th seed in a Pro Conference gets bumped down to make this work, so be it. It's the fairest system.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
I'm confused, because in your suggestion I seeOriginally posted by Gabrosin
Have four divisions in each conference. Name each one for a region. Keep each of the Pro teams that promoted initially together as part of that division.
followed byOriginally posted by Gabrosin
At the end of the season, demote the lowest team in each division back to the Pro league from whence it came, and promote the league champion from that league.
andOriginally posted by Gabrosin
I've promoted the idea of divisions a couple times before but never seen them gain much traction. You could use them to implement any number of cool things across ALL leagues:
and finallyOriginally posted by Gabrosin
a little bit of UI rework to provide a page for each division
so your suggestion doesn't need divisions? it seems to be the entire suggestion.

also, i would like for you to find a suggestion in this thread that doesn't involve
- rapid overturn (8 or 16 demoted),
- regional/random demotion (do we make them choose? do we force them? do we demote AAA), and
- should we change the structure from conferences or otherwise rework WPL

i've read every post in all 56 pages and i haven't found a single suggestion that isn't just some answer combination to those three questions
 
Talcion
offline
Link
 
Lets say that these teams fail to make the cut of the playoffs

4x OPL
3x SEAPL
2x APL
2x WEPL
2x EEPL
2x SAPL
1x CPL

Give these teams the same option that exists within the ML - a drop down box of where they would like to be relegated to, and start with the #9 seeds in both leagues, and work your way down...

No offense but if it works for the Minor Leagues going up - it should work for the WPL/Pro Leagues

After promoting the conference Champions the WPL would look like this

USAPL x6
CPL x 5
EEPL x4
WEPL x4
SAPL x4
APL x4
SEAPL x3
OPL x2

And so on and so forth... teams that have been to the big dance (WPL - much like Premier League in English Soccer) should have a much easier time recruiting based on the fact that they were in WPL, and you damn well know once you get a taste of being at the top you always want to go back... Shouldn't matter what region you get dropped into.

Either way, I'm pretty sure teams would like the chance to play some of their scrimmage rivals without paying 25 cents...

Meh, either way I'm an outsider... Just someone who possibly has an idea.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.