User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
why will the 440s have an advantage?


because they will be a full season of training and VAs ahead of the 400's. By the end of next season they will be equal.

The following season the 440's and 480's will be a full season ahead of the 400's, by the end of the next season they will be equal.

From then on, you would have the 440's, 480's and 520's all starting the season on equal footing which is ultimately what the extended plateau should be about. No reason that should take 2 full seasons to make a reality though, when you can just balance things right now to start next season.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
The league structure alone explode with competitiveness from the addition of adding those s5d0 dots.


THis being one of the biggest +'s to the announcement.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
then you don't have a real plateau, and this whole thing is rather pointless. please let that one go.


Yeah, I prolly will, why boost to just pick my ass. Retarded with nothing to do.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology


I hear you, and as a significant spender and long-term planner, I sympathize.

However, every decision made will benefit some party at the expense of others.

Season 1 dots had a huge advantage in VA points for quite a few seasons...we learned to live with it.

There were early dots that had significant advantages in weight minimums that played for 12 seasons with that advantage. We lived with that.

Early players had advantages in initial rolling poer (when you could have minimum 7s on attributes).


Just aim for the long term goal and let the chips fall where they may.




This hits every objective you have

Make the cut off d480, hand out 8 va's to every player in the game over 25, and hand out training pts pro rated

s5d40 = 80
ss6d40 = 70
s7d40 = 60
8 50
9 40
10 30
11 20
1210
13 none

Then going forward with the va's do something like every player ever born gets an immediate 11 va's when they hit level 25(early leagues be 10x more fun)

Then give every player in the game 25+ -s6d0 8 bonus va's on d41, everyone wins, balanced, and it adds a fun aspect for the entire user base without being IMBA.


The only possible problem with this is bort can't code it. and if thats the case let us know
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by jrry32

Ok, cut it off at Day 440 so we don't have to worry about trying to do all these work arounds.


yup. easy choice. you get your 3 season plateau, and no season is at an advantage.

not sure why we're still discussing it.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Its not the loudmouth Minority. I have over 250 glb agents on my aim/msn, and everyone was stoked about this change. s5d0 dots aren't the issue man. If you balance it for all of us, it just makes it way way better. s6d0 dots won't complain if they get their training pts. its 150bt, balance it and we will have so many great teams next yr. The league structure alone explode with competitiveness from the addition of adding those s5d0 dots.

Its a win win bp, if bort balances it, the game will be better for it


+1 That post is right on.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by jdros13

If the point is to make the player base bigger, there is no reason not to start now. I don't want the 441-480's out of the game, I just don't want them to have an advantage and that is not supposed to be the point of the plateau.

Make the plateau longer and immediately increase the player base. If you do a hard cutoff at 440, the 440's will have the advantage to start next season and it will take a couple of seasons for that to work itself out. Keep everyone, balance it out, and have more teams with a chance to put their best out there to start next season.


Are you saying we should let everyone who is old reset their VP's, etc?


Yes. I know you don't want that, but how else can you take away VP's and do it fairly? Round robin? Because that's not how they were assigned. People wouldn't go for it otherwise. They would just opt not to do it and/or retire.
Edited by Mr. Me2 on Jun 24, 2010 16:36:07
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by jrry32

Ok, cut it off at Day 440 so we don't have to worry about trying to do all these work arounds.


I don't believe that's what they said, you joined the thread a little late...see the previous pages.


I saw all of it and have been here, I just think trying to do all these work arounds is pointless, cutting it off at D440 makes everything better and allows me to retire my dot.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
1) Make training to day 480 viable
Negative: 2 season plateau instead of 3

2) Dont allow training past 440 and apply a penalty (VA or TP or %) to even out season 5 dots
Negative: Season 6 dots plans for AEQ negatively impacted

3) Change cutoff to 440
Negative: A ton of teams changed roster already based on the original announcement. Totally opposite from original announcement and will hurt a ton of players and teams.

Every option has a negative. Some of the other suggestions are too complex IMO


#3 isn't actually a negative. those changes were all verbal and can be undone.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
This hits every objective you have

Make the cut off d480, hand out 8 va's to every player in the game over 25, and hand out training pts pro rated

s5d40 = 80
ss6d40 = 70
s7d40 = 60
8 50
9 40
10 30
11 20
1210
13 none

Then going forward with the va's do something like every player ever born gets an immediate 11 va's when they hit level 25(early leagues be 10x more fun)

Then give every player in the game 25+ -s6d0 8 bonus va's on d41, everyone wins, balanced, and it adds a fun aspect for the entire user base without being IMBA.


The only possible problem with this is bort can't code it. and if thats the case let us know


I actually like this idea because the extra VA's give the ability to diversify the builds more.
 
mer
offline
Link
 
I'm on the day 440 cut off now bandwagon now. Maybe Bort will change his mind...
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
yup. easy choice. you get your 3 season plateau, and no season is at an advantage.

not sure why we're still discussing it.


Yeah this seems like the obvious choice to me, why would you want to implement something that gives a season/s of players complete advantage for the next couple seasons? Just start a fresh where nobody will have that period of advantage.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Are you saying we should let everyone who is old reset their VP's, etc?


absolutely. Your player base who will end this season at 520-560 days old is really small and they would get another shot at glory if they stuck it out (minus their VA points of course). Why not?
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
allows me to retire my dot.


So I see you are objectively keeping your own benefit out of this discussion
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Its not the loudmouth Minority. I have over 250 glb agents on my aim/msn, and everyone was stoked about this change. s5d0 dots aren't the issue man. If you balance it for all of us, it just makes it way way better. s6d0 dots won't complain if they get their training pts. its 150bt, balance it and we will have so many great teams next yr. The league structure alone explode with competitiveness from the addition of adding those s5d0 dots.

Its a win win bp, if bort balances it, the game will be better for it


I think the people who want the 480 day thing are

1) WL people
2) People who already made decisions based on this post

440 is logical and works, I think DD and Bort understand both side...whatever they decide is fine with me, it really doesn't effect my Dots per se, just making a case for the obvious.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.