Originally posted by DMeide
Returner CB, yes (unless I'm missing something). But then there's no point to doing a returner HB archetype as the Elusive HB is still better than the HB returner archetype. And, further, if I'm correct and elusive HB is still the best choice if you want to build a returner, the best returners would be the ones who went to the guys who were willing to drop 900 Flex as opposed to 600 Flex (though that may be something Bort and Co want, heh). Even if I'm not, then you'd never have any reason to choose HB or WR returner archetypes, which would bring us back to the one true path - everyone would choose CB returner archetype, add Juke as their one extra SA, and go from there.
I understand, at least I think I do, why Bort and Co don't want to just make Speed/Agility/Vision the ONLY three major attributes for the returner archetype - namely, that the entire reverse of what I'm arguing about would happen - those wanting Elusive HBs or Speedster WRs would pick the returner archetype anyway because of the .67 level increase to Speed, Agility and Vision. But there's got to be other ways. Perhaps nerf the returner archetype's catching (I'm talking like make it frozen at 1.2) and nerf the returner archetype's tackling (also frozen at 1.2). This way you can try to make a returner archetype into say, an elusive HB, but good luck with a catching like that, he's useless in the passing game entirely. And you'd also have to make sure there was no interaction between having no catching and his ability to "catch" the return and not fumble if he's got the appropriate carrying.
I'm sure I, and many people, could come up with a bunch of other ways to do it as well. I've already mentioned a few. I know you don't want people using the returner archetype to make elusive HBs or speedster WRs, which you would do if you got rid of stamina as a major attribute / moved it to minors. But I also know you don't want elusive HBs being the best option for returners, which right now, they are. Right now the pendulumn is too far to one side, and the key is finding a middle point.
remember... just because you select returner archtype doesn't mean you can't STILL play as a HB... maybe a team wants a return man that will be the 3rd HB, so more of their CBs can be coverage types etc.
One thing I thought of (and to be honest might have already been suggested in 55 pages). Could you maybe make an archtype "Classic" For each position, and have it be basically the same as it currently is, with no bonus or penalty SAs etc?