User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami


it is uncommon for this elite test server to be kept a secret and to have these "elite" compete against paying customers


exactly
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Anyone have thoughts of if/what I should add to the OP?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich

If you are trying to speak about the trust issue in general, then there is no real solution. If you play the game you MUST give that trust to the owners of that game.


Or the test servers could be set up in a way that we don't need blind faith...

That's still ignoring the point though. Even if they are honest, which I firmly believe they are, they are still not going to build opposite of what they see working on the test server. They are not going to make a test player and pay 50 dollars and wait 8 months to see how it works when they can put in a few numbers on the test server and get it for free.

Every minute and every dime that people have paid to try and figure out the minor details in the game, like how much strength helps, how much confidence is needed, which SA's work, all of that is useless compared to the golden key to infinite knowledge that the testers have gotten. Some people have paid thousands of dollars for this, and spent nearly a year trying to figure it out...how is that not a slap in the face to those people?

Granted, the testers should be knowledgeable about the game, but the few I know about, and seeing their builds, REALLY suggests otherwise. Not in the "built good, but doing a weird build" kind of bad, but a "level 20 and 30 in every attribute and 2 in SA's" bad. Not saying that they are not knowledgeable, they have really good heads on their shoulders and generally have a good idea of where the game should be going,..but as far as knowledge about the way the sim works and how everything factors in, I'm not so sure.
Last edited Feb 14, 2009 15:40:16
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Cryptotich


If you are trying to speak about the trust issue in general, then there is no real solution. If you play the game you MUST give that trust to the owners of that game.


Or the test servers could be set up in a way that we don't need blind faith...

That's still ignoring the point though. Even if they are honest, which I firmly believe they are, they are still not going to build opposite of what they see working on the test server. They are not going to make a test player and pay 50 dollars and wait 8 months to see how it works when they can put in a few numbers on the test server and get it for free.

Every minute and every dime that people have paid to try and figure out the minor details in the game, like how much strength helps, how much confidence is needed, which SA's work, all of that is useless compared to the golden key to infinite knowledge that the testers have gotten. Some people have paid thousands of dollars for this, and spent nearly a year trying to figure it out...how is that not a slap in the face to those people?

Granted, the testers should be knowledgeable about the game, but the few I know about, and seeing their builds, REALLY suggests otherwise. Not in the "built good, but doing a weird build" kind of bad, but a "level 20 and 30 in every attribute and 2 in SA's" bad. Not saying that they are not knowledgeable, they have really good heads on their shoulders and generally have a good idea of where the game should be going,..but as far as knowledge about the way the sim works and how everything factors in, I'm not so sure.


deathblade been pwnin it up recently
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami


not the same at all, there are legal repercussions for my credit card or pay pal number (whatever the fuck that is) being abused

there is no proof or way to determine that these secret testers are in fact honest, so to claim that they are is bogus


That is exactly my point. We as players have no possible way to know if the "testers" cheated or not.

Someone said "Show us the names and we can see how the improved". Hell my RB improved from a 5.9 to a 9.4 average from season 6 to 7. That is one hell of a jump. How did I get that jump? I had a RB that was on my team in season 6 who was better than me, and I put my points into the same things he did.

There is no measure of these "secret testers" that says they are dishonest either. You can not account for any leap in ability to any inside knowledge. They could have just put the points into the right places according to the same knowledge you had.

You can not "Prove" that any tester used advanced knowledge, that could not be accounted for by the knowledge that is in the Wiki right now.




 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by nfratami



not the same at all, there are legal repercussions for my credit card or pay pal number (whatever the fuck that is) being abused

there is no proof or way to determine that these secret testers are in fact honest, so to claim that they are is bogus


That is exactly my point. We as players have no possible way to know if the "testers" cheated or not.

Someone said "Show us the names and we can see how the improved". Hell my RB improved from a 5.9 to a 9.4 average from season 6 to 7. That is one hell of a jump. How did I get that jump? I had a RB that was on my team in season 6 who was better than me, and I put my points into the same things he did.

There is no measure of these "secret testers" that says they are dishonest either. You can not account for any leap in ability to any inside knowledge. They could have just put the points into the right places according to the same knowledge you had.

You can not "Prove" that any tester used advanced knowledge, that could not be accounted for by the knowledge that is in the Wiki right now.






lol @ that use of logic

yeah you are right, 0 of the people on the test server discovered anything they didnt already know about building players
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
ever noticed how random people who never post always show up in defense of GLB

admin multis imo


 
Link
 
It is so lame that mods keep trying to flex their muscles by locking threads. Why is there no freedom of speech?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by quzur
It is so lame that mods keep trying to flex their muscles by locking threads. Why is there no freedom of speech?


We don't need 345746736 threads about it.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
no freedom of speech on a private forum
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Cryptotich

Originally posted by nfratami




not the same at all, there are legal repercussions for my credit card or pay pal number (whatever the fuck that is) being abused

there is no proof or way to determine that these secret testers are in fact honest, so to claim that they are is bogus


That is exactly my point. We as players have no possible way to know if the "testers" cheated or not.

Someone said "Show us the names and we can see how the improved". Hell my RB improved from a 5.9 to a 9.4 average from season 6 to 7. That is one hell of a jump. How did I get that jump? I had a RB that was on my team in season 6 who was better than me, and I put my points into the same things he did.

There is no measure of these "secret testers" that says they are dishonest either. You can not account for any leap in ability to any inside knowledge. They could have just put the points into the right places according to the same knowledge you had.

You can not "Prove" that any tester used advanced knowledge, that could not be accounted for by the knowledge that is in the Wiki right now.






lol @ that use of logic

yeah you are right, 0 of the people on the test server discovered anything they didnt already know about building players


Errr you missed the point. My point is that you must assume that either 0 people learned anything, or All of them learned something.
 
Link
 
Well I think the 4 threads we had were valuable because each one had a different aspect of the test server discussion going on. you can't all of a sudden end that and bring it to a new thread.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by nfratami



not the same at all, there are legal repercussions for my credit card or pay pal number (whatever the fuck that is) being abused

there is no proof or way to determine that these secret testers are in fact honest, so to claim that they are is bogus


That is exactly my point. We as players have no possible way to know if the "testers" cheated or not.

Someone said "Show us the names and we can see how the improved". Hell my RB improved from a 5.9 to a 9.4 average from season 6 to 7. That is one hell of a jump. How did I get that jump? I had a RB that was on my team in season 6 who was better than me, and I put my points into the same things he did.

There is no measure of these "secret testers" that says they are dishonest either. You can not account for any leap in ability to any inside knowledge. They could have just put the points into the right places according to the same knowledge you had.

You can not "Prove" that any tester used advanced knowledge, that could not be accounted for by the knowledge that is in the Wiki right now.






You also cannot "Deny" that testers were givin a way to gain advanced knowledge that is not available to any other of us GLB users/"Beta Testers"
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by quzur
Well I think the 4 threads we had were valuable because each one had a different aspect of the test server discussion going on. you can't all of a sudden end that and bring it to a new thread.


You can...people just choose to complain and spam more threads.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by nfratami

Originally posted by Cryptotich


Originally posted by nfratami





not the same at all, there are legal repercussions for my credit card or pay pal number (whatever the fuck that is) being abused

there is no proof or way to determine that these secret testers are in fact honest, so to claim that they are is bogus


That is exactly my point. We as players have no possible way to know if the "testers" cheated or not.

Someone said "Show us the names and we can see how the improved". Hell my RB improved from a 5.9 to a 9.4 average from season 6 to 7. That is one hell of a jump. How did I get that jump? I had a RB that was on my team in season 6 who was better than me, and I put my points into the same things he did.

There is no measure of these "secret testers" that says they are dishonest either. You can not account for any leap in ability to any inside knowledge. They could have just put the points into the right places according to the same knowledge you had.

You can not "Prove" that any tester used advanced knowledge, that could not be accounted for by the knowledge that is in the Wiki right now.






lol @ that use of logic

yeah you are right, 0 of the people on the test server discovered anything they didnt already know about building players


Errr you missed the point. My point is that you must assume that either 0 people learned anything, or All of them learned something.


no

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.