User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by Iceman16

^^ Read above post, troll.


You are an idiot.

Example

Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Carrying
Catching (if planning on catching the ball out of the back field at all)

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage)

Now obviously each attribute needs a different amount of SP's but as you can see they have the same amount of needs. So when you say "oh noes the LB has to add some SP's to tackling, therefore reducing his speed/agility" It can be said as well that a power RB has to sacrifice strength at some point to put points into carrying. Either way it is a wash.


Lol. Idiot thinks vision and catching are vital to HB success. The single most famous HB in the game just told me today to never even train vision. DUCY you're a moron?
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Carrying

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?

Last edited Dec 29, 2008 23:43:50
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Modok

I like the gang tackling idea as well. But I also think that while being "gang tackled" the powerback should be more apt to fumble.


agreed...


Powerbacks are already more prone to fumbling...not sure you want to pile gang tackling AND gang stripping at the same time? Unless you want to kill the powerback as a concept...
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 23:44:15
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crawly
Originally posted by fletch03

Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Carrying

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



Your list will not build an elite powerback. Sorry.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 23:45:55
 
cbtd10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by cbtd10


I think something that should be added is the HB carrying a defender for 5-10 yards...happens in the league and would be great for the game. While the HB carries the player, he's slowed down obviously but still moving forward so it would be very useful for the HB but would allow other defensive players to tackle him.

At the moment, the HB plows over the defender and leaves him on the ground or SOMETIMES can dive and fight for an extra yard or two. Need some wiggle room out there for the powerbacks.


IF (and that's a big one) Bort can get the dragging right and not do it really excessively, it would be awesome.


I can already see some poor-ass CBs getting dragged 40 yards to the endzone.

Rug burn, ftw!
Hmmm...no. If the HB is dragging someone, he gradually loses speed, that's just normal. And as he loses speed either there would be a trigger to make the CB tackle him (cant drag him forever) or he gets so slow that an other D player catches up to him.

 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crawly
Originally posted by fletch03

Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Carrying

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



well in that case, lets get rid of confidence, jumping, strength and tackling for a LB. Because there are plenty of those builds as well.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Bort....my only concern is that in real life you can substitute based on the personnel of the offense. If a power HB is in than you put in your slower stronger high tackling guy in and when its a speed back you put in your speed LB's.

We dont have that option and if we have slower LB's out there trying to run down 90-100 speed HB pitches than we get burned!!

Is there a way to set it up where if the opponents #2HB is in than LB#3 enters the game kind of thing.

LB's cant get enough speed and agility to chase down the elusive HB's AND get strength and tacking where it needs to be for power HB's.

We need the option on defense to pick which LB's faces their HB's based on the depth chart???
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 23:47:44
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by Crawly

Originally posted by fletch03


Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Carrying

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



well in that case, lets get rid of confidence, jumping, strength and tackling for a LB. Because there are plenty of those builds as well.


You really fail at arguing your point, considering he took out things you ACTUALLY don't need.

EDIT: For the most part. Stamina and Confidence are important for HBs.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 23:48:27
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by Modok


I like the gang tackling idea as well. But I also think that while being "gang tackled" the powerback should be more apt to fumble.


agreed...


Powerbacks are already more prone to fumbling...not sure you want to pile gang tackling AND gang stripping at the same time? Unless you want to kill the powerback as a concept...


False...power backs rarely fumble if built right. Gang tackling should improve the fumble chance considering he is carrying players...if he has the ability to force extra yardage...the defense should have the ability to force a fumble out of it...
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crawly
Originally posted by fletch03

Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Carrying

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



lol fail

Seriously, I think CBs should be able to slow down HBs, or have the ability to try and push HBs to the sidelines (strength). A really good-tackling CB can also take down the HB (tackling). However, the gang tackles are more important. As well, both HB and tacklers are much more tired out from the sequence, as opposed to an elusive back.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
well in that case, lets get rid of confidence, jumping, strength and tackling for a LB. Because there are plenty of those builds as well.

That's exactly the point - if LBs like you describe can't tackle power-backs, then that build no longer works and all of the sudden you need extra strength/tackling (to tackle) and confidence (to avoid spiraling after the inevitable broken tackles). I'm willing to pass up jumping as a concept for the sake of this discussion, though I think jumping for LBs means more than any of the stats I took out for power HBs.

 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by Modok


I like the gang tackling idea as well. But I also think that while being "gang tackled" the powerback should be more apt to fumble.


agreed...


Powerbacks are already more prone to fumbling...not sure you want to pile gang tackling AND gang stripping at the same time? Unless you want to kill the powerback as a concept...


You cant have the ying without the yang. If you are going to up Power Thru and make it more difficult to tackle him, the defense has to have something to counter it. Get 5 people jerking on him, common sense tells you that he is going to be more susceptible to fumble.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by bhall43


Originally posted by Modok



I like the gang tackling idea as well. But I also think that while being "gang tackled" the powerback should be more apt to fumble.


agreed...


Powerbacks are already more prone to fumbling...not sure you want to pile gang tackling AND gang stripping at the same time? Unless you want to kill the powerback as a concept...


False...power backs rarely fumble if built right. Gang tackling should improve the fumble chance considering he is carrying players...if he has the ability to force extra yardage...the defense should have the ability to force a fumble out of it...


Maybe if defenses actually used something other than wrap-up, or got some of the SAs/VAs that help cause fumbles.
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Crawly


Originally posted by fletch03



Power RB need SP in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Carrying

LB needs SPs in the following to be successful (no particular order):
Strength
Speed
Agility
Vision
Stamina
Confidence
Tackling
Jumping (if planning on any PD's while in coverage) [Also for diving tackles]

Fixed to only include the stuff a power-back actually needs. Not so even anymore, is it?



well in that case, lets get rid of confidence, jumping, strength and tackling for a LB. Because there are plenty of those builds as well.


You really fail at arguing your point, considering he took out things you ACTUALLY don't need.


Your right. A power back has no need for confidence, vision, catching. None whatsoever.
 
Link
 
I think one thing that hampers the current sim is that there are too many 1 vs 1 tests.

In real football, there are seldom pure 1 on 1 showdowns. The other players who are "in on the play" play a big part, even if they're not making the tackle or making a block directly in front of the ball carrier.

GLB's foundation of machine gun style one-on-ones makes the simulation rather fragile and kinda flaky IMO.

Stratomatic football, which is a fantastic sim, is uses aggregate defensive values as a starting point. These values are calculated by the various strengths and weaknesses of a particular part of the defense being tested - kind of an average ability score for the unit. Depending on how the play goes, the "test" might emphasize the offensive player's ability (ie a WR or the LT), offensive unit's ability (ie the O-Line as a whole) the defensive unit's ability (ie secondary), or it might call for a test on one of the specific defensive players involved (ie the CB or a blitzing LB). Or an opposed test....

I think shifting away from the pure 1v1 approach we have now and emphasizing teams as a whole a little more (or "aspects" of teams) would really help the sim.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.