User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
I like the ideas DD and Bort tossed up regarding amending the original announcement.

The conversation now is starting to diverge into many unrelated paths so I say we fine tune those.

Edit: Stern's idea is also worth considering.
Edited by Skanker irl on Jun 24, 2010 16:31:25
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Gart888
the smart people decided that they'd wait and see the final ruling before making any recruiting decisions today.
i'm sorry that you jumped the gun, but you've been around long enough that you should have known better.


I was under the impression an announcement from Admin was a final ruling. Its not jumping the gun and please stop trolling.


Please do stop trolling...
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by jrry32

I think we should just cut it off at D440...I want to retire my older dot and I need an excuse.


lol, i kinda feel the same way with my TE, although playing another 2 seasons would be pretty fun.

the only real downside is people that have unfinished pieces of AEQ that would become useless, but that could be sorted out if there was some sort of refund to crafted AEQ pieces.


Good thing I am going to get mine finished up.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
If the point is to make the player base bigger, there is no reason not to start now. I don't want the 441-480's out of the game, I just don't want them to have an advantage and that is not supposed to be the point of the plateau.

Make the plateau longer and immediately increase the player base. If you do a hard cutoff at 440, the 440's will have the advantage to start next season and it will take a couple of seasons for that to work itself out. Keep everyone, balance it out, and have more teams with a chance to put their best out there to start next season.


so pretty much what dpride is saying....
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by BP

too complicated Bort. You don't need to cater to the loud minority voices of the Mods and current WL'ers. Just cuz THEY have day 478 players they want to keep rolling on in the WL with is no reason to throw logic out the window.

Usually the first instinct is the correct one, 440 day cutoff...if you are day 442, that does suck...but the people who are 2-5 days older then the cutoff is miniscule vs. how complex the operation is you are trying to outline.


If the point is to make the player base bigger, there is no reason not to start now. I don't want the 441-480's out of the game, I just don't want them to have an advantage and that is not supposed to be the point of the plateau.

Make the plateau longer and immediately increase the player base. If you do a hard cutoff at 440, the 440's will have the advantage to start next season and it will take a couple of seasons for that to work itself out. Keep everyone, balance it out, and have more teams with a chance to put their best out there to start next season.


why will the 440s have an advantage?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Originally posted by tautology


Seems to me that the best decision will be the one that serves the long range goals of the game.

If 3 seasons of player parity is the target, then the answer is obvious.

This would give certain players and advantage for a few seasons...but that is hardly new to the game.



Yep, but you still have to account for the entire game having spent 100-1000+ on our dots aiming for a d479 peak only to lose out on 150 bt. We need it pro rated, and its pure gold.




I hear you, and as a significant spender and long-term planner, I sympathize.

However, every decision made will benefit some party at the expense of others.

Season 1 dots had a huge advantage in VA points for quite a few seasons...we learned to live with it.

There were early dots that had significant advantages in weight minimums that played for 12 seasons with that advantage. We lived with that.

Early players had advantages in initial rolling poer (when you could have minimum 7s on attributes).


Just aim for the long term goal and let the chips fall where they may.


 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
too complicated Bort. You don't need to cater to the loud minority voices of the Mods and current WL'ers. Just cuz THEY have day 478 players they want to keep rolling on in the WL with is no reason to throw logic out the window.

Usually the first instinct is the correct one, 440 day cutoff...if you are day 442, that does suck...but the people who are 2-5 days older then the cutoff is miniscule vs. how complex the operation is you are trying to outline.


Its not the loudmouth Minority. I have over 250 glb agents on my aim/msn, and everyone was stoked about this change. s5d0 dots aren't the issue man. If you balance it for all of us, it just makes it way way better. s6d0 dots won't complain if they get their training pts. its 150bt, balance it and we will have so many great teams next yr. The league structure alone explode with competitiveness from the addition of adding those s5d0 dots.

Its a win win bp, if bort balances it, the game will be better for it
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
but continue training forever.


then you don't have a real plateau, and this whole thing is rather pointless. please let that one go.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
I like the ideas DD and Bort tossed up regarding amending the original announcement.

The conversation now is starting to diverge into many unrelated paths so I say we fine tune those.


Ok, cut it off at Day 440 so we don't have to worry about trying to do all these work arounds.
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Well, we all know I'm not a math guy or a spectacular builder, so I didn't even attempt to follow the math.

All I know is, I was one of those "foolish" enough to immediately smile & buy the announcement and go look @ all my teams dots that fit under 480 days!

Just keep that part however/whatever you have to do it, I don't care if it benefits the Haves like Hali & Kai, I think anything that keeps a lot of loved dots around is a good thing.

Do what you said, with the minor compromises to make it "fair", .
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
If the point is to make the player base bigger, there is no reason not to start now. I don't want the 441-480's out of the game, I just don't want them to have an advantage and that is not supposed to be the point of the plateau.

Make the plateau longer and immediately increase the player base. If you do a hard cutoff at 440, the 440's will have the advantage to start next season and it will take a couple of seasons for that to work itself out. Keep everyone, balance it out, and have more teams with a chance to put their best out there to start next season.


Are you saying we should let everyone who is old reset their VP's, etc?
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Ok, cut it off at Day 440 so we don't have to worry about trying to do all these work arounds.


I don't believe that's what they said, you joined the thread a little late...see the previous pages.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Originally posted by Mr. Me2

Not really. Not when you start with *I'm* or *I* but whatever...


I thought you meant beyond my team.....

I guess I'm just thinking if I'm affiliated w/ 20ish teams and nearly 100% of them are talking about changing their recruiting process....I'm pretty confident the overall GLB percentage is pretty high as well.


Well any change is going to change the recruiting process, but saying "this announcement was made today and I changed my recruiting process today and it needs to stay as it is" when we are still in that day in question is not thinking beyond yourself. Sorry, I should have been more clear.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Ok, cut it off at Day 440 so we don't have to worry about trying to do all these work arounds.


yup. easy choice. you get your 3 season plateau, and no season is at an advantage.

not sure why we're still discussing it.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
1) Make training to day 480 viable
Negative: 2 season plateau instead of 3

2) Dont allow training past 440 and apply a penalty (VA or TP or %) to even out season 5 dots
Negative: Season 6 dots plans for AEQ negatively impacted

3) Change cutoff to 440
Negative: A ton of teams changed roster already based on the original announcement. Totally opposite from original announcement and will hurt a ton of players and teams.

Every option has a negative. Some of the other suggestions are too complex IMO
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.