User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
Fum, i see your point there, but think about that Speed DE, you could easily build a guy with 135-140 spd and 110-120 agility with that one. Sure you might only get him to 75 strength, but assuming Bort lets speed rushers loose again, that would be a very attractive choice imo. But if the game remains as strength oriented as it has been the past few seasons, then yeah, strength DL is a no brainer


See I don't think sub 90 strength DTs should be viable when powerbacks are rocking 110+ and guards have 140, DEs maybe but not DTs.

Now how those numbers should reflect in the sim is a whole 'nother conversation.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by burn_209
i think that no matter how you put it slow building is an expliot. it wasnt intended when the makers of the game started the game and now it makes others have to build that way. now that being said i cap build because i have to so i understand why the slowbuilders are angry. it basically trashs everything they have done. this i going to be interesting


Lol wat?
You can fast build and have a good dot if you still build within reason, IE common sense. But really, how does this thrash everything us slowbuilder/capbuilders have done?Originally posted by Ahrens858


Originally posted by Ahrens858

how was this not thought of at the creation time of the game?




Lol, not to sure, but I do know there have been threads through suggestions along the same lines, with pretty good support and very little to no negative feedback. So the comments that we haven't had any input in this is totally farce. It just took them forever to get around to doing it.

 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Edited by David Stern on Feb 11, 2010 00:56:50
 
Ahrens858
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
This is actually a really good list


x2
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Pocket Passer should get a bonus to Pocket Presence...hmm? That would seem like a more appropriate penalty SA for the Scrambler as well instead of Pump Fake.
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
i agree with that list a good deal (a lot more than the current one), but we're apparently not allowed to make suggestions.



edits: multiple spelling fails
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 10, 2010 23:34:36
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 10, 2010 23:34:01
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 10, 2010 23:32:46
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Lol, not to sure, but I do know there have been threads through suggestions along the same lines, with pretty good support and very little to no negative feedback. So the comments that we haven't had any input in this is totally farce. It just took them forever to get around to doing it.



yes, because those threads in suggestions were about this current sim, were made with the same knowledge of builds that people have now, everyone that wants a say got a say in those threads, and every single suggestion that could have been made on the subject -ever- has been made in those threads. no more good ideas could ever possibly arise. this idea is just so perfect already.

edits: more spelling fails... i really should go to bed
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 10, 2010 23:46:55
Edited by Worker 3 on Feb 10, 2010 23:45:57
 
DMeide
offline
Link
 
No one answered this in the 10 pages or so after my post, so I figured I'd ask it again, maybe it was answered before, maybe not.

For someone who enjoys building returners, I still don't see why you wouldn't choose Speed DL. He gets the THREE attributes that matter the most (BY FAR) to a returner - Speed, Agility and Vision. Yes, the returner archtypes get those 3 as majors, but they have to "share" it with a 4th major - the result is that speed, agility and vision only go up by .5 for the returner archytypes, but they go up .67 for the speed DL archtype.

That's not an insignificant amount. Yes, you don't get the best SAs as "bonuses", but you still get First Step; you don't get Juke or Return Specialist but it's not like First Step isn't important either. I know Carrying matters for returners, but Carrying PALES in comparision to Speed, Agility and Vision. .17 points a level is not a tiny amount.

Just my 2 cents.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Many of the archetypes have been revised:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3760560&page=last#33307101
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Seems like many are more even with current builds now.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
FB Scatback should have a fifth major. It is ridiculous to have a FB getting +.5 to speed. Take a great receiving FB like Larry Centers or Tom Rathman. They are possession guys, not speedsters, and shouldn't get better ALGs in speed than WRs.
Edited by foofighter24 on Feb 11, 2010 00:25:52
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Worker 3
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Lol, not to sure, but I do know there have been threads through suggestions along the same lines, with pretty good support and very little to no negative feedback. So the comments that we haven't had any input in this is totally farce. It just took them forever to get around to doing it.



yes, because those threads in suggestions were about this current sim, were made with the same knowledge of builds that people have now, everyone that wants a say got a say in those threads, and every single suggestion that could have been made on the subject -ever- has been made in those threads. no more good ideas could ever possibly arise. this idea is just so perfect already.

edits: more spelling fails... i really should go to bed


Evidently you are trying to..............I don't know whay you're trying to do, really.
Some odd reason you are trying to pick at my post in a way my post wasn't meant to be taken?
You make it sound like I said you can't post any more suggestions? And that I said this suggestion is perfect? Really, you should go to bed.
And yes, they do look for you input, which is what this thread that you are posting in is about. To discuss it. My post, which you decided to try and rip, was to offer proof that they do take the input and suggestion of users. Though, at times it might take longer than you would like. But again, how much of a users input should be good for the game is anyones best guess. Me, personally, I would just much rather Bort make the game the way he had it envisioned, tbh. Thing about it, Vet abilities was all based off of user input, the same users that eventually came back on complaining about them. Same with the realism stats. Same with the minor league structure. User input is valuable, but it can also hinder certain aspects of the game if the wrong majority puts in their input the most. The admins need to sort, debate, and finally fine tune/implement the done deal, based off the user input.
Of course, you could be in an uproar over JD being in an uproar because Catch doesn't want his inbox flooded with PM's about different suggestions from different users. In which case, I really don't blame him. Teh amount of PM's mods and lolmods gets is in excess, I can only imagine what an active Admin's inbox looks like.
Again, that is what the various Archetype threads are for. Use them.

 
DMeide
offline
Link
 
Well they fixed the Speed DL problem but now there's another problem - with stamina becoming a major for returner archetypes, Elusive HB becomes very attractive for returner builds.

Stamina ain't that important - yes, it's good to have for a returner, but it's not make or break. Now you've got elusive HBs getting .5 to speed, agility, vision (and carrying), the 3 most important attributes for returners (and a 4th one that's good to have), as opposed to the returner archetypes only getting .4, thanks to more points to stamina. .1 per level is not insigificant. Returners, more than any other position IMO, rely on the big three (speed, agility and vision), with carrying and confidence next, then stamina.

Plus, elusive HB gets juke as a bonus SA, and I think most returner builders would tell you that Juke is 2nd only to Return Specialist for importance - the current debate between HB and CB as which to use for returners centers on the difference in major/minor attributes for each as currently set-up, and having to choose between Juke and RS.

So, Elusive HB gets Juke as a bonus, and gets .5 to each major, whereas returner archetypes only get .4 (and the HB doesn't even get Juke as a bonus).

I understand Bort and Co do not want ONE TRUE PATH, I agree that you should have diversity and strategy to the build - but the diversity and strategy should be among the returner archtypes - no? That elusive HB is at least as good, if not even better, of a choice for returners, seems to me to defeat the purpose of archetypes - the decision should be whether to pick HB, WR or CB among the three returner archetypes, and then what to choose as your other SA once you've chosen which of the three.

I could think of many suggestions, here are a bunch of them:
1) Cut Stamina out of the major attributes for returners (making the big four at .5 each). It's not that important. Come on now. If you're a pure returner, you can easily train stamina (espeically if it's a minor) to get it to where it needs to be.
2) Make Return Specialist available ONLY to returner archetypes.
3) Develop a new SA that applies to returners. Perhaps something like "Gamebreaker" - a return TD can be absolutely demoralizing for the other team. For each level of Gamebreaker, the other team suffers an X% decrease in morale and confidence when your player returns a kick or punt to the house. If it's pumped up to a high level, this means that taking one to the house absolutely crushes the other team's morale. Or something along those lines. I know that the OG post said that they were looking into new SAs that would only be open to certain archetypes, so it's an idea.
4) Make Return Specialist part of the SA tree for HB and WR returner archetypes (but not elusive HB), and make Juke part of the SA tree for CB returner archetypes. I realize you're apparently allowed to choose one SA that's not in the normal build, but as currently constructed, nothing stops an elusive HB from choosing Return Specialist (unless plan 2 is chosen).

All I'm saying, and I'm done rambling now, is that, at least in my opinion, there is no reason for elusive HB to be one of the better (or I think, the best) option for building a returner if you're going to have returner archetypes. It defeats the entire purpose of the system.
Edited by DMeide on Feb 11, 2010 00:42:25
Edited by DMeide on Feb 11, 2010 00:37:09
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Elusive HB - 900 Flex per season
Returner - 600 Flex per season

Main reason why what you posted is correct, but also not a major concern.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
refunds for flex need to be looked into...if I'm restarting dots I just made last season...or for this season already...it seems like I fucking wasted flex on boosting just to have a crazy change come in that is gonna really affect my young dots...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.