Well they fixed the Speed DL problem but now there's another problem - with stamina becoming a major for returner archetypes, Elusive HB becomes very attractive for returner builds.
Stamina ain't that important - yes, it's good to have for a returner, but it's not make or break. Now you've got elusive HBs getting .5 to speed, agility, vision (and carrying), the 3 most important attributes for returners (and a 4th one that's good to have), as opposed to the returner archetypes only getting .4, thanks to more points to stamina. .1 per level is not insigificant. Returners, more than any other position IMO, rely on the big three (speed, agility and vision), with carrying and confidence next, then stamina.
Plus, elusive HB gets juke as a bonus SA, and I think most returner builders would tell you that Juke is 2nd only to Return Specialist for importance - the current debate between HB and CB as which to use for returners centers on the difference in major/minor attributes for each as currently set-up, and having to choose between Juke and RS.
So, Elusive HB gets Juke as a bonus, and gets .5 to each major, whereas returner archetypes only get .4 (and the HB doesn't even get Juke as a bonus).
I understand Bort and Co do not want ONE TRUE PATH, I agree that you should have diversity and strategy to the build - but the diversity and strategy should be among the returner archtypes - no? That elusive HB is at least as good, if not even better, of a choice for returners, seems to me to defeat the purpose of archetypes - the decision should be whether to pick HB, WR or CB among the three returner archetypes, and then what to choose as your other SA once you've chosen which of the three.
I could think of many suggestions, here are a bunch of them:
1) Cut Stamina out of the major attributes for returners (making the big four at .5 each). It's not that important. Come on now. If you're a pure returner, you can easily train stamina (espeically if it's a minor) to get it to where it needs to be.
2) Make Return Specialist available ONLY to returner archetypes.
3) Develop a new SA that applies to returners. Perhaps something like "Gamebreaker" - a return TD can be absolutely demoralizing for the other team. For each level of Gamebreaker, the other team suffers an X% decrease in morale and confidence when your player returns a kick or punt to the house. If it's pumped up to a high level, this means that taking one to the house absolutely crushes the other team's morale. Or something along those lines. I know that the OG post said that they were looking into new SAs that would only be open to certain archetypes, so it's an idea.
4) Make Return Specialist part of the SA tree for HB and WR returner archetypes (but not elusive HB), and make Juke part of the SA tree for CB returner archetypes. I realize you're apparently allowed to choose one SA that's not in the normal build, but as currently constructed, nothing stops an elusive HB from choosing Return Specialist (unless plan 2 is chosen).
All I'm saying, and I'm done rambling now, is that, at least in my opinion, there is no reason for elusive HB to be one of the better (or I think, the best) option for building a returner if you're going to have returner archetypes. It defeats the entire purpose of the system.