User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiteMaestro

The statement, "Which is why you lose" is guilty of a fallacy as well. That statement assumes that TheJackal does not abide with/agree with logic, something that cannot be assumed from the statement made. "Affirming the consequent" is the name of this fallacy.


First of all I wasn't guilty of Ad Hominem.

Secondly that's not what affirming the consequent is. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirming_the_consequent

Thirdly if you're going to point out argumentative fallacies, I'm one of the last people in this thread that is guilty of them.
 
Zarus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by TheJackal

Originally posted by cbarge


Originally posted by TheJackal



Originally posted by cbarge




Originally posted by TheJackal





Logic always wins.


Which is why you lose.


Not really none of you have beaten or come close. Your arguments are weak and your insulting remarks rather amusing. Are you saying that the universe just poofed into existence? That's rather silly.


Just as silly as saying God made it.


Hmmm something poofing into existence of something creating it...

A chair suddenly appearing or a carpenter taking his time to make it...

Lol I don't think I need to say anymore. You're a funny guy.


Where did 'God' get the materials to create the Earth in such detail?

No one can be omnipotent...God simply can't exist.


Neither can the universe, but it does. All this we are discussing is beyond all of us. None of it can be explained by us.
 
NiteMaestro
offline
Link
 
There are facts. These are statements regarding the nature of an object. They can be true or false.
i.e., The sky is green.
That is a fact. It is false, but a fact nonetheless.

There are some facts, that we do not know if they are true or false.
i.e., John Doe is the fastest person in the world.
Well, there are ways to determine this, and Mr. Doe's speed can be measured. But we don't actually know if this is true or not.
Such a statement is a belief.

There are opinions. Opinions are never wrong, and never right. They are the individual's feelings regarding the said topic.
i.e., I love pizza.
Whether you like it or not, does not make me wrong, and it does not make me right. My opinion is something that is independent of any fact.

To put this into context, let's look at some facts vs. opinions.

God is real. (That is a fact. A belief)
God is not real. (Also a fact, and a belief)
I like that God is real. (That is an opinion. It is how someone feels about the existence of God.)
I cannot stand Christianity. (That is an opinion as well. It does not mean that there is anything wrong with Christianity, it simply means that the person does not like Christianity.)

Does that help with this whole "fact vs. opinion" deal?
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeramyhansen
Originally posted by rams78110

Originally posted by jeramyhansen


I think you guys need to look up the definition of the word "fact" and the word "opinion" and get back to me.


Fact: bible is hypocratic

Fact: bible is contradictory

Fact: bible has been re-written hundreds of time

Opinion: The bible doesnt seem all to great to worship


You can't prove hypocracy and contradictory. It is all a matter of opinion and how you read it. The 3rd one was a fact though. I'll give you that much


no, you need to look up the definition of both

Hypocratic: saying not to do one thing and then doing against it

Contradiction: Saying one thing and going against it
 
blankspace
offline
Link
 
I would like a third arm, would make things easier for me since two doesn't seem to get the job done. So for the next 60 years I'm going to sit and think about the extra arm until I get it, because if that happens, I have evolved!

But seriously, evolution probably isn't real IMO.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiteMaestro

God is real. (That is a fact. A belief)

That's wrong.
Originally posted by NiteMaestro

God is not real. (Also a fact, and a belief)

That's wrong.
Originally posted by NiteMaestro

I like that God is real. (That is an opinion. It is how someone feels about the existence of God.)

That's right.
Originally posted by NiteMaestro

I cannot stand Christianity. (That is an opinion as well. It does not mean that there is anything wrong with Christianity, it simply means that the person does not like Christianity.)

That's right.

You scored a 50%
 
jeramyhansen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by jeramyhansen

Originally posted by cbarge


Originally posted by jeramyhansen



I'm still waiting for a fact. Give me an example of what you think is contradictory or hypocritical. WHICH ARE OPINIONS!!!! LOL!!!


Contradictions are not opinions. To get a contradiction, all you need is to say one thing is true and then say the opposite thing is true.


Give me a fact (an example) of what you are talking about???


http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/jim_meritt/bible-contradictions.html


So your "fact" is based on somebody else's interpretation of the bible??? Well done my good sir...well done.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeramyhansen
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by jeramyhansen


Originally posted by cbarge



Originally posted by jeramyhansen




I'm still waiting for a fact. Give me an example of what you think is contradictory or hypocritical. WHICH ARE OPINIONS!!!! LOL!!!


Contradictions are not opinions. To get a contradiction, all you need is to say one thing is true and then say the opposite thing is true.


Give me a fact (an example) of what you are talking about???


http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/jim_meritt/bible-contradictions.html


So your "fact" is based on somebody else's interpretation of the bible??? Well done my good sir...well done.


Those aren't bible interpretations, they are DIRECT QUOTES.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiteMaestro
There are facts. These are statements regarding the nature of an object. They can be true or false.
i.e., The sky is green.
That is a fact. It is false, but a fact nonetheless.

There are some facts, that we do not know if they are true or false.
i.e., John Doe is the fastest person in the world.
Well, there are ways to determine this, and Mr. Doe's speed can be measured. But we don't actually know if this is true or not.
Such a statement is a belief.

There are opinions. Opinions are never wrong, and never right. They are the individual's feelings regarding the said topic.
i.e., I love pizza.
Whether you like it or not, does not make me wrong, and it does not make me right. My opinion is something that is independent of any fact.

To put this into context, let's look at some facts vs. opinions.

God is real. (That is a fact. A belief)
God is not real. (Also a fact, and a belief)
I like that God is real. (That is an opinion. It is how someone feels about the existence of God.)
I cannot stand Christianity. (That is an opinion as well. It does not mean that there is anything wrong with Christianity, it simply means that the person does not like Christianity.)

Does that help with this whole "fact vs. opinion" deal?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fact

Generally, a fact is defined as something that is true, something that actually exists, or something that can be verified according to an established standard of evaluation.
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 13:20:17
 
jeramyhansen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rams78110
Originally posted by jeramyhansen

Originally posted by rams78110


Originally posted by jeramyhansen



I think you guys need to look up the definition of the word "fact" and the word "opinion" and get back to me.


Fact: bible is hypocratic

Fact: bible is contradictory

Fact: bible has been re-written hundreds of time

Opinion: The bible doesnt seem all to great to worship


You can't prove hypocracy and contradictory. It is all a matter of opinion and how you read it. The 3rd one was a fact though. I'll give you that much


no, you need to look up the definition of both

Hypocratic: saying not to do one thing and then doing against it

Contradiction: Saying one thing and going against it


Thank you, but I know the definitions of hypocratic and contradiction. But to simply say something is hypocratic isn't enough to say it is a fact that it is hypocratic. It is all a matter of how you take it.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blankspace
I would like a third arm, would make things easier for me since two doesn't seem to get the job done. So for the next 60 years I'm going to sit and think about the extra arm until I get it, because if that happens, I have evolved!

But seriously, evolution probably isn't real IMO.


When you people do your critiques of evolution you do it in a metter of a 2 year old, exaggerating things.

Evolution occurs when your life and future of your species is in danger. Will having a 3rd arm keep you from dryin or keep humans from going extinct? no. Also, evulution taked hundreds of thousands of years, not 60, and thinking about it will not make it happen. Stay out of this thread you fucking retard.
 
jeramyhansen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiteMaestro
There are facts. These are statements regarding the nature of an object. They can be true or false.
i.e., The sky is green.
That is a fact. It is false, but a fact nonetheless.

There are some facts, that we do not know if they are true or false.
i.e., John Doe is the fastest person in the world.
Well, there are ways to determine this, and Mr. Doe's speed can be measured. But we don't actually know if this is true or not.
Such a statement is a belief.

There are opinions. Opinions are never wrong, and never right. They are the individual's feelings regarding the said topic.
i.e., I love pizza.
Whether you like it or not, does not make me wrong, and it does not make me right. My opinion is something that is independent of any fact.

To put this into context, let's look at some facts vs. opinions.

God is real. (That is a fact. A belief)
God is not real. (Also a fact, and a belief)
I like that God is real. (That is an opinion. It is how someone feels about the existence of God.)
I cannot stand Christianity. (That is an opinion as well. It does not mean that there is anything wrong with Christianity, it simply means that the person does not like Christianity.)

Does that help with this whole "fact vs. opinion" deal?


Wrong. Good attempt, but wrong. For example, to say that john doe is the fastest person in the world is by no means a fact. That is an opinion. The only way it would be a fact is if every person in the world was involved in a race and he won it.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeramyhansen
Originally posted by rams78110

Originally posted by jeramyhansen


Originally posted by rams78110



Originally posted by jeramyhansen




I think you guys need to look up the definition of the word "fact" and the word "opinion" and get back to me.


Fact: bible is hypocratic

Fact: bible is contradictory

Fact: bible has been re-written hundreds of time

Opinion: The bible doesnt seem all to great to worship


You can't prove hypocracy and contradictory. It is all a matter of opinion and how you read it. The 3rd one was a fact though. I'll give you that much


no, you need to look up the definition of both

Hypocratic: saying not to do one thing and then doing against it

Contradiction: Saying one thing and going against it


Thank you, but I know the definitions of hypocratic and contradiction. But to simply say something is hypocratic isn't enough to say it is a fact that it is hypocratic. It is all a matter of how you take it.


Its not a metter of how you take it. for example, "You shall not pass judgement" next to "Gays are immoral and should be killed."

that is contradictory and hypocratic.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
I hate to nitpick, but everyone is spelling hypocritical wrong.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by jeramyhansen

Originally posted by cbarge


Originally posted by jeramyhansen



Originally posted by cbarge




Originally posted by jeramyhansen





I'm still waiting for a fact. Give me an example of what you think is contradictory or hypocritical. WHICH ARE OPINIONS!!!! LOL!!!


Contradictions are not opinions. To get a contradiction, all you need is to say one thing is true and then say the opposite thing is true.


Give me a fact (an example) of what you are talking about???


http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/jim_meritt/bible-contradictions.html


So your "fact" is based on somebody else's interpretation of the bible??? Well done my good sir...well done.


Those aren't bible interpretations, they are DIRECT QUOTES.


BIBLE FAIL!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.