User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Cylon
offline
Link
 
I only got to page six until it got pretty repetitive. I want to state that I'm not directly affected because my team is in Pro.

Seems like it'll be a moving average which means a temporary XP hit for the majority of players above the average and might change daily. I don't see anything about an in game performance hit so you can keep your player on your team as long as you like if you're willing to take an XP hit to be a winner.

I don't know the details of course but since you're indicating using the median I think it might be better to find the median by taking off the extremes. If there's only fifty people level 18+ out of 1000 players in a average level 13 league it could mean the median is actually different and people are taking a slight hit because of that.

It'd also probably do what it looks like it's intended to do and make it harder on the highest levels in the league and would benefit people who are just slightly above the moving average if those players are factored in but wouldn't be affected if they weren't.

P.S. edited due to sleepy math
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:02:14
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders

A team shouldn't be able to have a team full of players 8 levels higher than the median come in, sign for low contracts, and dominate the league.


I agree, but there's better ways of fixing that:

1: Have the doggone admins DO THEIR JOB and go after the individuals/teams that are stacking and fine/ban them. Don't punish good recruiting teams for bad teams' behavior.

2: Use the money system already in place to limit the number of high level players a low-tier team can get by implementing minimum salaries. Make it too expensive to sign a high level player by disallowing the current system of low-balling contracts. Do what the NFL does -- force teams to play a player in accordance to his time in the league (ie, level). You still allow teams to pick up a few good players, without hurting those players, continue relegation/elevations and in a few seasons the leagues will balance themselves --- all without punishing individual players.


Originally posted by

Even if you're just playing with your friends, you shouldn't be able to do that in a lower league. You can still do it, it's just going to cost you a little bit.


These people who have teams with friends have a tendency to boost. Boosting is how the site and the people who own it make their money. You're punishing paying customers for the sins of a few.

Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:02:07
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WVUFAN197


As the above poster states, there's only so many slots in the Pro leagues, and many people have no desire to sign as FA to a Pro level league, they want to go with a lower-tier team and EARN their way into the Pros.

For the most part, only affect those who have been with the game for the longest, and have paid money to play the game.

Those who do not boost, or are relatively new to the game, this will not affect.

Let's alienate long-term supporters. Great rule.


Yep there are only 32 teams in the USA Pros, and 32 teams in the USA AAA. Only 2 teams on the AAA move up. But the couple of teams in the AAA leagues that are good enough to move up but dont, might have some of their players punished.

Kind of sucks to think that my player in the AAA that is above the level median will be punished since the team didnt make the pros. I cant get a spot on the Pro roster, and he is now punished for staying on the AAA team because his level is to high.

That only 64 spots for a starting and back-up HB in the pro league. Those two positions will see the most playing time. What happens in the future when ther are more than 64 "pro level" HB's. Those that cant find a spot, but are above the level of the AAA league will be hurt.

What about those teams that drop down a league and now their player are above the level median?

Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:02:50
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
You guys are reading the whole damn thing wrong,

If the Median is 13, a LVL 14 player in that league WONT BE HIT, a LVL 15 wont be hit, hell even a 16 wont be hit, a LVL 22, yea, thats gonna get hit and deservedly so.

Read the post again.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
Originally posted by WVUFAN197



As the above poster states, there's only so many slots in the Pro leagues, and many people have no desire to sign as FA to a Pro level league, they want to go with a lower-tier team and EARN their way into the Pros.

For the most part, only affect those who have been with the game for the longest, and have paid money to play the game.

Those who do not boost, or are relatively new to the game, this will not affect.

Let's alienate long-term supporters. Great rule.


Yep there are only 32 teams in the USA Pros, and 32 teams in the USA AAA. Only 2 teams on the AAA move up. But the couple of teams in the AAA leagues that are good enough to move up but dont, might have some of their players punished.

Kind of sucks to think that my player in the AAA that is above the level median will be punished since the team didnt make the pros. I cant get a spot on the Pro roster, and he is now punished for staying on the AAA team because his level is to high.

That only 64 spots for a starting and back-up HB in the pro league. Those two positions will see the most playing time. What happens in the future when ther are more than 64 "pro level" HB's. Those that cant find a spot, but are above the level of the AAA league will be hurt.

What about those team that drop down a league and now their player are above the level median?




If they drop down, chances are, the median is going to rise, even if it is a lvl it will rise.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
well, my son and i brought a few of our level 12-15 players to the AA team he just got. this is gonna hurt bort's bankroll because i cant boost these players tomorrow because i'll be penalized even more as their levels rise. it's one thing to recruit a bunch of high level players and quite another to want ur own players on ur team. thats the whole idea for me. i didnt pick the level i started at. i have plenty of low level players, also, so im not "stacking".
 
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Originally posted by Finnious Cretin



actually in time the "sophmore" leagues will probably outlevel these gutters/stackers you seem to fear so badly.

Also people tell me why you think a team that gut/stacks more than one season won't be kicked out of the game?


No. Sophomore leagues will never outlevel guys who are higher level than a sophomore league. A second-year league start with levels 12-17 EVERY SINGLE TIME, and the stackers will STILL be much higher than that.


what are you talking about here. the players in sophmore leagues level up just like anyone, this season they are 14-17, next season they are 20-24, etc. whole leagues aren't moved up, only 2 teams a season.


NO, you moron. The players in a sophomore league start at 12-17... then next year, the players in a sophomore league start at 12-17... then next year, the players in a sophomore league start at 12-17.

That won't change.

Neither will your intelligence, unfortunately.


oh yes personal attacks that helps your argument.
I'm sorry though i thought when you said sophomore leagues you meant Lower Tiered leagues.
I see now what you mean, but i don't think it's important, since you still seem to think a group of people can continuously gut and stack a team every season without getting banned.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
You guys are reading the whole damn thing wrong,

If the Median is 13, a LVL 14 player in that league WONT BE HIT, a LVL 15 wont be hit, hell even a 16 wont be hit, a LVL 22, yea, thats gonna get hit and deservedly so.

Read the post again.


If that's really how it works, then the system is pointless and ineffective.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Mark,

A. If you two are the only ones that boost, then you are probably right.

B. Do you really think in a 36 team division or 34 or whatever it is, with 40 players, that you two are gonna be the only ones that boost?
 
crag79
offline
Link
 
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:07:44
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
Lets say the median for the AAA league is 30 (just picking a number), lets say your HB is level 38. Lets say there are 100+ HB's in the league over level 38. Like I said 64 can see serious playing time in the Pro's but your level 38 "Pro material" HB is out of luck. He can be punished for staying in the AAA League or he can take that third roster spot and sit on the bench. Either way his development is hampered.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
This was a decision that will hurt the game. New owners have no control over where their teams are placed. This a rule that says yes you can pay real money for FP and use them how you want but once you spend them the game controls what you spent them on. This is less about the extreme cases where players do it just to pad stats against weak players/teams and more about screwing teams and players that want to play this game with friends or have their own players on the same team. All teams have an equal opportunity for recruitment so here we are punishing teams for being better at it or even putting forth the effort in the first place. These changes do not affect me or any of the teams that I play for but I think this is a BS move.Welcome to a game where competition doesn't matter and cuddling carebears share their feelings.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by sjmay

You guys are reading the whole damn thing wrong,

If the Median is 13, a LVL 14 player in that league WONT BE HIT, a LVL 15 wont be hit, hell even a 16 wont be hit, a LVL 22, yea, thats gonna get hit and deservedly so.

Read the post again.


If that's really how it works, then the system is pointless and ineffective.


Are you kidding me??? Seriously, you're joking right?

The system is pointless and ineffective, because it hits LVL 22 players playing with LVL 13s, but not LVL 14s playing with 13s,

My god.
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crag79
Actually aren't their 64 teams in USA AAA leagues?


32 Pro teams, with starting and back-up spots.

32 x 2spots = 64 spots.

 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye


That only 64 spots for a starting and back-up HB in the pro league. Those two positions will see the most playing time. What happens in the future when ther are more than 64 "pro level" HB's. Those that cant find a spot, but are above the level of the AAA league will be hurt.

What about those teams that drop down a league and now their player are above the level median?


Don't you mean 64 * 8 = 512 starting HB slots in the PRO leagues?

As for teams that get relegated. The longer you play for a team, the better your score. I imagine if a player has been with a team a few seasons, played 40 games with them, resigned three times, and boosted regularly (all pluses to sportsmanship), that player won't have a problem.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:08:31
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.