User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Link
 
I'm not reading through 200 pages to see if this has been said but why not just take three of the more vocal complainers and allow them to have test server access for 72 hours. That will give the 'public' a chance to see exactly what being a 'tester' is with GLB and perhaps much of this stuff can be put to rest.

I can't imagine it is a giant advantage unless actual teams are allowed to be used as the testing fodder and I can't see that being the case. Probably testers are quite limited in what they can do within the constraints of the testing environment.

Just my two cents after reading through a few pages.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
We have 53 pages of people posting what what they are afraid of, which is that some people, with access to the test server, got an unfair advantage.

What we are lacking is a solution that people can live with.

There is no need to argue weather or not people with access to the Test Server could have gotten an advantage. The simple fact is that they could have.

Because there is no way to determine which of the Test Server people abused that advantage, you have to assume 1 of 2 things. Either they are all innocent, or they are all guilty.

If even one is presumed guilty, then they all have the potential to be guilty, and thus their ability to play on a level playing field in GLB is tainted.

Releasing the names of the testers, will only lead to a presumption of guilty. I purpose that you assume they are all guilty of the worst thing you can imagine. At this point, you as a player can let the management of GLB take care of the situation.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by groveboy101
Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake

why not open up test servers for the masses to test?

I dont like this whole test server thing


Because unlike the few people testing, the rest of GLB are NOT honest people and would use it to try to exploit the sim.


what makes the people testing honest?

how do you know they are honest?

does having moderator under your name prevent you from divulging secrets to your friend on aim

do you think the people on the test server figure out a good build and then build their player in an opposite manner because they are "honest"
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Smith_FPS
I'm not reading through 200 pages to see if this has been said


And with that, this random guy I've never heard of makes the argument the entire moderating and administrative staff refuses to acknowledge.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Smith_FPS
I'm not reading through 200 pages to see if this has been said but why not just take three of the more vocal complainers and allow them to have test server access for 72 hours. That will give the 'public' a chance to see exactly what being a 'tester' is with GLB and perhaps much of this stuff can be put to rest.

I can't imagine it is a giant advantage unless actual teams are allowed to be used as the testing fodder and I can't see that being the case. Probably testers are quite limited in what they can do within the constraints of the testing environment.

Just my two cents after reading through a few pages.


i agree, take 3 nominated users from these forums and give them access, let them speak to the masses on what they see
 
Cowboys101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
]

Oh yeah the fact you make a simple point thats important will be over looked enjoy your locked thread imo.


not
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Smith_FPS

I'm not reading through 200 pages to see if this has been said


And with that, this random guy I've never heard of makes the argument the entire moderating and administrative staff refuses to acknowledge.


 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
We have 53 pages of people posting what what they are afraid of, which is that some people, with access to the test server, got an unfair advantage.

What we are lacking is a solution that people can live with.

There is no need to argue weather or not people with access to the Test Server could have gotten an advantage. The simple fact is that they could have.

Because there is no way to determine which of the Test Server people abused that advantage, you have to assume 1 of 2 things. Either they are all innocent, or they are all guilty.

If even one is presumed guilty, then they all have the potential to be guilty, and thus their ability to play on a level playing field in GLB is tainted.

Releasing the names of the testers, will only lead to a presumption of guilty. I purpose that you assume they are all guilty of the worst thing you can imagine. At this point, you as a player can let the management of GLB take care of the situation.


One point your missing is that if this is supposed to be a beta game then we are all supposed to be testers. The fact that there was secret testing going on by only certain users undermines the equality of all GLB users who have been paying to be "testers".

Having secret testing that is only available to some users basically means that the beta tag this game has been hiding behind for the last few months is literally bullshit. For me, thats the biggest problem.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by groveboy101

Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake


why not open up test servers for the masses to test?

I dont like this whole test server thing


Because unlike the few people testing, the rest of GLB are NOT honest people and would use it to try to exploit the sim.


what makes the people testing honest?

how do you know they are honest?

does having moderator under your name prevent you from divulging secrets to your friend on aim

do you think the people on the test server figure out a good build and then build their player in an opposite manner because they are "honest"


Honestly bro, if you do not trust the game enough to make those questions mute, then don't play.

If you are trying to speak about the trust issue in general, then there is no real solution. If you play the game you MUST give that trust to the owners of that game.

As a paying player, you have to trust they will not abuse your credit card, or pay pal number.

I put $100 into this game. If I did not trust the game, I wouldn't have.

So the question becomes, how can I trust this game, if I am playing against people who have inside information?
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by groveboy101

Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake


why not open up test servers for the masses to test?

I dont like this whole test server thing


Because unlike the few people testing, the rest of GLB are NOT honest people and would use it to try to exploit the sim.


what makes the people testing honest?

how do you know they are honest?

does having moderator under your name prevent you from divulging secrets to your friend on aim

do you think the people on the test server figure out a good build and then build their player in an opposite manner because they are "honest"


Thaat guy knows everything. How? He just does!

 
civil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62

One point your missing is that if this is supposed to be a beta game then we are all supposed to be testers. The fact that there was secret testing going on by only certain users undermines the equality of all GLB users who have been paying to be "testers".

Having secret testing that is only available to some users basically means that the beta tag this game has been hiding behind for the last few months is literally bullshit. For me, thats the biggest problem.


odg62 just hit the nail on the head for how I'm feeling about this entire situation.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by nfratami

Originally posted by groveboy101


Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake



why not open up test servers for the masses to test?

I dont like this whole test server thing


Because unlike the few people testing, the rest of GLB are NOT honest people and would use it to try to exploit the sim.


what makes the people testing honest?

how do you know they are honest?

does having moderator under your name prevent you from divulging secrets to your friend on aim

do you think the people on the test server figure out a good build and then build their player in an opposite manner because they are "honest"


Honestly bro, if you do not trust the game enough to make those questions mute, then don't play.

If you are trying to speak about the trust issue in general, then there is no real solution. If you play the game you MUST give that trust to the owners of that game.

As a paying player, you have to trust they will not abuse your credit card, or pay pal number.

I put $100 into this game. If I did not trust the game, I wouldn't have.

So the question becomes, how can I trust this game, if I am playing against people who have inside information?


not the same at all, there are legal repercussions for my credit card or pay pal number (whatever the fuck that is) being abused

there is no proof or way to determine that these secret testers are in fact honest, so to claim that they are is bogus
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62


One point your missing is that if this is supposed to be a beta game then we are all supposed to be testers. The fact that there was secret testing going on by only certain users undermines the equality of all GLB users who have been paying to be "testers".

Having secret testing that is only available to some users basically means that the beta tag this game has been hiding behind for the last few months is literally bullshit. For me, thats the biggest problem.


It is not unusual for a Game Company to create a "elite" level of pre - game testing. These are the players that have shown an advanced knowledge of game testing, and or the game in general. In game testing these are the people who are put on the hardest game issues to replicate.

Having said that, I believe that when you start taking money, the game is no longer "Beta".



 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
ever noticed how random people who never post always show up in defense of GLB

admin multis imo
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by odg62



One point your missing is that if this is supposed to be a beta game then we are all supposed to be testers. The fact that there was secret testing going on by only certain users undermines the equality of all GLB users who have been paying to be "testers".

Having secret testing that is only available to some users basically means that the beta tag this game has been hiding behind for the last few months is literally bullshit. For me, thats the biggest problem.


It is not unusual for a Game Company to create a "elite" level of pre - game testing. These are the players that have shown an advanced knowledge of game testing, and or the game in general. In game testing these are the people who are put on the hardest game issues to replicate.

Having said that, I believe that when you start taking money, the game is no longer "Beta".





it is uncommon for this elite test server to be kept a secret and to have these "elite" compete against paying customers
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.