User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Slew Foot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
As a member of the team, WTF was Slim thinking? lol Just kidding, Really 10 , wow and we are pretty good, love Borts Statement about the randomizer, why the hell was a 10 even in the randomizer list to begin with? should be no higher than 4. I code a little as well and you can set limitations on how high and low numbers go. No matter how anyone tries to defend the reasoning behind 10 INTs, it just shouldn't of happened. I'm not bitter we lost either, hell I play on two teams that are a combined 2-38 so losing I can deal with.



It shouldnt be capped at 4..because that is where you will get those instances where a CB watches the game and thinks there is no way in the world he should have gotten that pass. But because his team met their supposed quota of the game with 4 INTS..it really shouldnt matter where or how the QB throws it now because they cant pick it off any longer...

The first game was close yes. But alot can change from one meeting to the next one...and by that I mean in terms of them boosting and getting better..a Guy with 20 strength lets say isnt going to be the same with regular lvl ups and 3 boosts and his strength next time you play is almost 50... He is going to play better, as I am sure this team did.. Besides ok you keep saying the QB only through 15 INTS all year..Well it seems that if Bort said you just got the bad side of the randomizer this game. with only 15 all year you obviously were getting the goodside for 16 games.. Not to mention despite the fact you talked about how this doesnt work when two evenly matched teams are playing This entire conversation would not even be taking place if you had beaten them in this fashion.

Majority of those INTS were on Long passes anyway. So if Bort said they were set to defend the pass. and if that happened to be Long passes. Couple that with the fact your QB has low Confidence for his level..Yes..we know he only threw 15 all season..no need to remind us again.. But he has low confidence..there is in game morale..and this is a big playoff game which always gives people the jitters and it may for this game as well and if it does then that would totally be cool..He got rattled..Its a mixture of things. I mean they only gave up 29 yards rushing per game all season...and you didnt have a good rushing game.. they matched you guys in INTS with 39 on the season. so they have shown they could grab them down.. 31 forced fumbles..119 hurries..48 sacks..they are a stout defensive team....And you keep telling everyone you played them before this season and it was close..but come on..that was the 4th game of the season... Your speaking about that game as if it happened week 14 or something.. alot has gone on since that game and it led to your loss..just deal with it..

And no not all of this was directed at the guy I quoted lol. I just wanted to get it all in
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 09:51:13
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
superman - that is a question I don't have the answer to. I think it was mentioned before that given the way the SIM is currently set up, it is unlikely.

Turnovers generally lead to points for the opposition, esp. when there are multiple turnovers. Point spreads, in this SIM, when over 10, lead to a much heavier passing attack, to the point where the running game is abandoned.

Given those facts, the odds of a 7 fumble game right now are pretty slim I would think.
 
bolo_76
offline
Link
 
This thread is insane. I started reading it last night and made it about 20 pages in and when I realized every time I read a page I two more were already up I said screw it, and then apparently it went on all night.

From what I can tell the QB build wasn't real good, which contributed to it all happening.
This game was somewhat of an anomaly and probably shouldn't have happened, but it did so get over it. The guy goes around the board and bashes everyones ideas, under the guise of "sticking up for the game", only to have one bad thing happen and cry foul and want his money back. He torn down any suggestion made, then he makes one of the worst ever...refund my money! And when Bort explains it he continues to whine. I'm not gonna lie I would be pissed about the situation also, I might even post and say this game was messed up, but I wouldn't argue to the death that the system is broken. There are tweaks that need to be made and they are going to be, but you can't change everything over one game, that's like the suggestion of recoding the entire game a few months back!

I agree there needs to be a bottom for morale, once your confidence is down its down and shouldn't spiral quite so bad. There should also be options for subs like everyone has mentioned, but to go off and say the game is broke and I want my money is childish.

This post makes all the sense in the world...
Originally posted by Forbin

In the NFL, a single season is half as many games as GLB simulates EACH DAY.

In the course of season3, we simmed what? 30k regular season games? That's 60 years worth of NFL games. You're bound to see statistical anomalies more often when you're simming that many games.


So every year you get about 60 years of NFL seasons...so that means in beta alone we have played 180 years of football! That's roughly half of what has actually been played if you go back to the beginning (1920) Not to mention those games involved humans with real logic and not a computer sim which no matter how hard you try will never be totally accurate.

When it comes down to it the game needs some minor tweaks, some of which are already on the way. Everything will work itself out, the game is a whole half a year old or so!
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
superman - that is a question I don't have the answer to. I think it was mentioned before that given the way the SIM is currently set up, it is unlikely.

Turnovers generally lead to points for the opposition, esp. when there are multiple turnovers. Point spreads, in this SIM, when over 10, lead to a much heavier passing attack, to the point where the running game is abandoned.

Given those facts, the odds of a 7 fumble game right now are pretty slim I would think.


QB's should fumble more than they do as well. Seriously, how many QB's do you know with 20 carrying? None, they all have them in the teens and yet you never see QB's fumble.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by SCACE

superman - that is a question I don't have the answer to. I think it was mentioned before that given the way the SIM is currently set up, it is unlikely.

Turnovers generally lead to points for the opposition, esp. when there are multiple turnovers. Point spreads, in this SIM, when over 10, lead to a much heavier passing attack, to the point where the running game is abandoned.

Given those facts, the odds of a 7 fumble game right now are pretty slim I would think.


QB's should fumble more than they do as well. Seriously, how many QB's do you know with 20 carrying? None, they all have them in the teens and yet you never see QB's fumble.


Valid point, but that has nothing to do with this topic. For one, I think you'll see more fumbling with offensive AI next season if teams force the SIM to stick with their running game, even when it isn't working. You could test that out next season, but I'd imagine that is one way 7 fumbles could be possible, esp. with the expected boost of important to carrying I've read about for season 4.

As for the QB's, go make a suggestion they should fumble more on sacks. You are probably right.
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by SCACE

superman - that is a question I don't have the answer to. I think it was mentioned before that given the way the SIM is currently set up, it is unlikely.

Turnovers generally lead to points for the opposition, esp. when there are multiple turnovers. Point spreads, in this SIM, when over 10, lead to a much heavier passing attack, to the point where the running game is abandoned.

Given those facts, the odds of a 7 fumble game right now are pretty slim I would think.


QB's should fumble more than they do as well. Seriously, how many QB's do you know with 20 carrying? None, they all have them in the teens and yet you never see QB's fumble.


Alot of qbs have carrying in the 20's I have mine at 22.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gator93
Originally posted by superman8456

Originally posted by SCACE


superman - that is a question I don't have the answer to. I think it was mentioned before that given the way the SIM is currently set up, it is unlikely.

Turnovers generally lead to points for the opposition, esp. when there are multiple turnovers. Point spreads, in this SIM, when over 10, lead to a much heavier passing attack, to the point where the running game is abandoned.

Given those facts, the odds of a 7 fumble game right now are pretty slim I would think.


QB's should fumble more than they do as well. Seriously, how many QB's do you know with 20 carrying? None, they all have them in the teens and yet you never see QB's fumble.


Alot of qbs have carrying in the 20's I have mine at 22.


Your QB is made to scramble as well right? The one on my team (Yes, I keep making comparisons to him) has 14.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
again superman, its off topic -- if you think QB's and HB's should fumble more, create a topic and state why and have a discussion about it, but whether they should or should not has zip to do with this topic
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by Gator93

Originally posted by superman8456


Originally posted by SCACE



superman - that is a question I don't have the answer to. I think it was mentioned before that given the way the SIM is currently set up, it is unlikely.

Turnovers generally lead to points for the opposition, esp. when there are multiple turnovers. Point spreads, in this SIM, when over 10, lead to a much heavier passing attack, to the point where the running game is abandoned.

Given those facts, the odds of a 7 fumble game right now are pretty slim I would think.


QB's should fumble more than they do as well. Seriously, how many QB's do you know with 20 carrying? None, they all have them in the teens and yet you never see QB's fumble.


Alot of qbs have carrying in the 20's I have mine at 22.


Your QB is made to scramble as well right? The one on my team (Yes, I keep making comparisons to him) has 14.


Your qb hasn't even been sacked though....
 
chicagojoe16
offline
Link
 
blahblahblahblabhablabhalbhalbh there will never be a refund in this game ever ever, I can't believe you'd expect that or even expect them to change a sim for the playoffs. That's what would be unfair. Change the sim after it's been the same the whole season? You can't implement changes during the middle of a season let alone right before the playoffs.
 
mlbtrader23
offline
Link
 
30 missed tackles will do that to you.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chicagojoe16
blahblahblahblabhablabhalbhalbh there will never be a refund in this game ever ever, I can't believe you'd expect that or even expect them to change a sim for the playoffs. That's what would be unfair. Change the sim after it's been the same the whole season? You can't implement changes during the middle of a season let alone right before the playoffs.


I think he was basically just calling attention to, what he considered, an egregious error in the current simming code.

Agree or not, he did exactly that - calling attention to the current simming code.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I still don't believe the "code" is where the error is. Options available to the user...sure, definite improvements that could make this type of result highly unlikely. But the code worked as intended given the QB's build, confidence level, and randomized bad luck early in the game that couldn't be recovered from.

If anything, Larry brought to light the need for more options at the user level, both GM/Owner and Player side.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


Everybody is just making up excuses for the sim. It doesnt matter if your running game carried him the whole season, look at the stats. If he is going to have 1 game like this wouldnt it show in previous sims? Atleast a 4-5 INT game would show this, but it didnt, thus leading you to the conclusion the formula is flawed.


Why would a 4-5 INT game show up before this? What logical reason do you reach for that? Especially given the fact that his team RUSHED the ball almost the entire season.


You're saying that his build is so horrible. You cant have both sides to the argument. Bad build would show atleast a game with 4-5 INT's for the team to know. It didnt happen that way, this was an out of the blue thing and you guys are making up excuses for it.


And you keep talking out of your ass for some reason saying the same broken record. We are too, but the difference is we tend to be right. The QB build sucked, he got out game planned and taken advantage of, this shit does happen in real life sports. Points and proof have been presented throughout all 50 semi pages. Go back and read it.
I love how people blame the sims when things go bad against there teams or if they wanna whine about it, someone elses team. I have not seen ONE person come on here and blame the sim for blowouts that THEY were a part of on the good side. No, I'm not talking bout complaining of gutted teams but actual complaints that the sim went hay wire cuz "your" team won 200-0. Most of you look forward to that cupcake of a gutted team on your schedule to pad some stats. When you people start complaining more about that then I will take you serious here.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Believe it or not but this was a productive thread.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.