User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology

Seems to me that the best decision will be the one that serves the long range goals of the game.

If 3 seasons of player parity is the target, then the answer is obvious.

This would give certain players and advantage for a few seasons...but that is hardly new to the game.



Yep, but you still have to account for the entire game having spent 100-1000+ on our dots aiming for a d479 peak only to lose out on 150 bt. We need it pro rated, and its pure gold.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology

Seems to me that the best decision will be the one that serves the long range goals of the game.

If 3 seasons of player parity is the target, then the answer is obvious.

This would give certain players and advantage for a few seasons...but that is hardly new to the game.



do you think it's worth it? if it's unavoidable, sure. but seeing as there have been a bunch of suggestsions that do avoid the temporary advantage, i'm not sure that it makes sense.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Originally posted by Mr. Me2

I think he's saying the good of the entire user base > all of you saying +1. Not everyone is in your recruiting boat, but everyone will be affected by this change. In other words, think beyond you.


Every forum I'm in has talk about changes to their method of recruiting....I AM thinking beyond me bud.


Not really. Not when you start with *I'm* or *I* but whatever...
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah, I like the idea, though I am not entirely sold on the everybody past the 480 days old part.

Basically just make a "reset my VP's" page that removes a season's worth of VP's and resets your skills when hit the button. And if you don't opt in, you just follow old rules.


my only argument would be that going forward dots will be viable to day 560 - why shut that part of your player base out? It's small but it is there and it makes the player pool that much bigger immediately next season which is supposed to be the goal.

Any dot that is still active could hang on for one more season, plenty of dots for everyone. Win.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by tautology


Seems to me that the best decision will be the one that serves the long range goals of the game.

If 3 seasons of player parity is the target, then the answer is obvious.

This would give certain players and advantage for a few seasons...but that is hardly new to the game.



do you think it's worth it? if it's unavoidable, sure. but seeing as there have been a bunch of suggestsions that do avoid the temporary advantage, i'm not sure that it makes sense.


I think we should just cut it off at D440...I want to retire my older dot and I need an excuse.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah, I like the idea, though I am not entirely sold on the everybody past the 480 days old part.

Basically just make a "reset my VP's" page that removes a season's worth of VP's and resets your skills when hit the button. And if you don't opt in, you just follow old rules.


too complicated Bort. You don't need to cater to the loud minority voices of the Mods and current WL'ers. Just cuz THEY have day 478 players they want to keep rolling on in the WL with is no reason to throw logic out the window.

Usually the first instinct is the correct one, 440 day cutoff...if you are day 442, that does suck...but the people who are 2-5 days older then the cutoff is miniscule vs. how complex the operation is you are trying to outline.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Originally posted by Mr. Me2

Which means 8 teams from each conference, or 16 teams total...or half the WL like he said.


or the bottom (worst) half..which isn't what he said...and it's not 8 anymore I don't beleive


Bottom 8 would be obvious. And it's hasn't changed.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah, I like the idea, though I am not entirely sold on the everybody past the 480 days old part.

Basically just make a "reset my VP's" page that removes a season's worth of VP's.


I like this idea.
Edited by ImTheScientist on Jun 24, 2010 16:28:25
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr. Me2
Not really. Not when you start with *I'm* or *I* but whatever...


I thought you meant beyond my team.....

I guess I'm just thinking if I'm affiliated w/ 20ish teams and nearly 100% of them are talking about changing their recruiting process....I'm pretty confident the overall GLB percentage is pretty high as well.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Originally posted by Bort

Yeah, I like the idea, though I am not entirely sold on the everybody past the 480 days old part.

Basically just make a "reset my VP's" page that removes a season's worth of VP's and resets your skills when hit the button. And if you don't opt in, you just follow old rules.


too complicated Bort. You don't need to cater to the loud minority voices of the Mods and current WL'ers. Just cuz THEY have day 478 players they want to keep rolling on in the WL with is no reason to throw logic out the window.

Usually the first instinct is the correct one, 440 day cutoff...if you are day 442, that does suck...but the people who are 2-5 days older then the cutoff is miniscule vs. how complex the operation is you are trying to outline.


the first instinct? The original announcement stands? OK cool
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
.
Edited by 5STAR on Jun 24, 2010 16:29:01
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
I think we should just cut it off at D440...I want to retire my older dot and I need an excuse.


lol, i kinda feel the same way with my TE, although playing another 2 seasons would be pretty fun.

the only real downside is people that have unfinished pieces of AEQ that would become useless, but that could be sorted out if there was some sort of refund to crafted AEQ pieces.
 
RyanCane26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Yep, but you still have to account for the entire game having spent 100-1000+ on our dots aiming for a d479 peak only to lose out on 150 bt. We need it pro rated, and its pure gold.


+10
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
What if we keep the current system we outlined and to remove VA points from the 441-480 day old group (based on their age)?

Decent compromise?

They'd still have some extra TP, but they wouldn't have as large of an advantage.


but continue training forever.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
too complicated Bort. You don't need to cater to the loud minority voices of the Mods and current WL'ers. Just cuz THEY have day 478 players they want to keep rolling on in the WL with is no reason to throw logic out the window.

Usually the first instinct is the correct one, 440 day cutoff...if you are day 442, that does suck...but the people who are 2-5 days older then the cutoff is miniscule vs. how complex the operation is you are trying to outline.


If the point is to make the player base bigger, there is no reason not to start now. I don't want the 441-480's out of the game, I just don't want them to have an advantage and that is not supposed to be the point of the plateau.

Make the plateau longer and immediately increase the player base. If you do a hard cutoff at 440, the 440's will have the advantage to start next season and it will take a couple of seasons for that to work itself out. Keep everyone, balance it out, and have more teams with a chance to put their best out there to start next season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.