User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Page:
 
rjssob
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Cover 3 is a 3 deep zone, there is no man involved at all...
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 20:54:54
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KangarWhoDey
Originally posted by Jcdawg23

Originally posted by KangarWhoDey


Can someone tell me what this means (from the defensive AI output screen)?

"Defense Shell (no goal line)"

Does that mean I cannot choose between Cover1, Cover 2, etc if I have chosen a goal line formation? If that's the case, can someone give me a brief rundown of how the goal line D functions?

Thanks!


If you have 3 CB's on the field, and you choose cover 3, 1 CB drops back into zone, and the other two play man to man. I'm not sure which drops back though.

I understand how cover 3 is supposed to work, my question is, does it work that way with the goal line defenses.

"Defense Shell (no goal line)"

That comment, which appears in the AI, makes me wonder if the goal line D will somehow work differently, and I'm just looking for some clarification. Because if GL D works the same as the others, I'm not sure why that comment would be in the interface..

Kangar, this might not be exactly what you are looking for, but I've taken the "Defense Shell (no goal line)" to mean: in the goal line alignment, there is no shell call needed.

If you go back and check out your D when it's been in the goal line alignment in the past, you see two corners locked on to TE's, your LOLB also over a TE and then just the MLB and the SS backing the line (and watching the RB's), no "shell players" on the field. I assume the goal line D is set to play Cover 0 (all man) and just simply has no one playing in zone coverage and, therefore, no need for the shell determination.

All that said, Bort has made it clear that he has re-worked all of the D plays for season 4, so the goal line alignment may be different going forward and everything I just said may be out the window ... but we won't know until tomorrow.

 
force40
offline
Link
 
Probably already been asked, but I don't have the time or patience to read through 50-some pages; is the AI at go-live status for this upcoming season, or is it still getting worked out? Would like to know if I need to hurry up and spend a ton of time getting some defensive configs entered in or not. Thanks much,
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 21:03:51
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by force40
Probably already been asked, but I don't have the time or patience to read through 50-some pages; is the AI at go-live status for this upcoming season, or is it still getting worked out. Would like to know if I need to hurry up and spend a ton of time getting some defensive configs entered in or not. Thanks much,


Yep, hurry up.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=630838
 
KangarWhoDey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643

If you go back and check out your D when it's been in the goal line alignment in the past, you see two corners locked on to TE's, your LOLB also over a TE and then just the MLB and the SS backing the line (and watching the RB's), no "shell players" on the field. I assume the goal line D is set to play Cover 0 (all man) and just simply has no one playing in zone coverage and, therefore, no need for the shell determination.

All that said, Bort has made it clear that he has re-worked all of the D plays for season 4, so the goal line alignment may be different going forward and everything I just said may be out the window ... but we won't know until tomorrow.



Thanks for the reply turnit. This is my first season here, so I didn't know about the explanation you provided. I appreciate it.

I'm just wondering about setting up different goal line (zone) blitzes. For example, say, if I want to send the corners in toward the backfield, is there a way to have someone else play a zone in the space they have vacated? Would the LBs on the edge automatically take up the CBs responsibilities?

Are goal line formations so heavily automated that there really isn't much room for customization the way there is with the rest of the defensive schemes?

I guess I'll learn a lot from the scrimmages. I've set up a handful of blitzes for goal line situations. If the D does something completely differently from what I'd hoped, I'll go back and do some tweaking. Somehow I don't think I'll be the only one making adjustments to their playbook over the next few days
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 21:14:32
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KangarWhoDey

Thanks for the reply turnit. This is my first season here, so I didn't know about the explanation you provided. I appreciate it.

I'm just wondering about setting up different goal line (zone) blitzes. For example, say, if I want to send the corners in toward the backfield, is there a way to have someone else play a zone in the space they have vacated? Would the LBs on the edge automatically take up the CBs responsibilities?

Are goal line formations so heavily automated that there really isn't much room for customization the way there is with the rest of the defensive schemes?

I guess I'll learn a lot from the scrimmages. I've set up a handful of blitzes for goal line situations. If the D does something completely differently from what I'd hoped, I'll go back and do some tweaking. Somehow I don't think I'll be the only one making adjustments to their playbook over the next few days


I would be careful with zone blitzes. We don't know yet how players will adjust their zones to compensate for a blitzing LB or CB.

Not to say that you shouldn't try them, because that's what the preseason's for...trying out the AI. I'm just saying that there are a lot of differences between zone blitzing in GLB and in real life.

The major thing that sticks out to me is that the zone blitz relies on confusing the quarterback...he doesn't know at the start of the play who will be in coverage and who will be coming at him. That "confusion" isn't going to exist for a sim quarterback I don't think...all that will count is the pressure, if you're able to get some.
 
KangarWhoDey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dfitzo53
Originally posted by KangarWhoDey


Thanks for the reply turnit. This is my first season here, so I didn't know about the explanation you provided. I appreciate it.

I'm just wondering about setting up different goal line (zone) blitzes. For example, say, if I want to send the corners in toward the backfield, is there a way to have someone else play a zone in the space they have vacated? Would the LBs on the edge automatically take up the CBs responsibilities?

Are goal line formations so heavily automated that there really isn't much room for customization the way there is with the rest of the defensive schemes?

I guess I'll learn a lot from the scrimmages. I've set up a handful of blitzes for goal line situations. If the D does something completely differently from what I'd hoped, I'll go back and do some tweaking. Somehow I don't think I'll be the only one making adjustments to their playbook over the next few days


I would be careful with zone blitzes. We don't know yet how players will adjust their zones to compensate for a blitzing LB or CB.

Not to say that you shouldn't try them, because that's what the preseason's for...trying out the AI. I'm just saying that there are a lot of differences between zone blitzing in GLB and in real life.

The major thing that sticks out to me is that the zone blitz relies on confusing the quarterback...he doesn't know at the start of the play who will be in coverage and who will be coming at him. That "confusion" isn't going to exist for a sim quarterback I don't think...all that will count is the pressure, if you're able to get some.


Good point. Thanks.
 
BucJordan
offline
Link
 
New question: If I want to put my Nickel Defense formation on the field for the Single Back set, will my 3rd CB automatically go to cover the TE that's split to the (defense's) right, or will he stay on the left since he replaced the LOLB? Same question goes for 3 WR sets where the third receiver is on the offense's left, or D's right.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BucJordan
New question: If I want to put my Nickel Defense formation on the field for the Single Back set, will my 3rd CB automatically go to cover the TE that's split to the (defense's) right, or will he stay on the left since he replaced the LOLB? Same question goes for 3 WR sets where the third receiver is on the offense's left, or D's right.


He'll line-up over the slot receiver.
 
T2
Killuh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rjssob
Cover 3 is a 3 deep zone, there is no man involved at all...


That's not ture...you can play cover 3 with man coverage underneath, just like cover 1,2 and 4.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by TenTwo
Originally posted by rjssob

Cover 3 is a 3 deep zone, there is no man involved at all...


That's not ture...you can play cover 3 with man coverage underneath, just like cover 1,2 and 4.



Well yes, but normally when you here someone call cover 3 you think zone coverage. You are thinking 3 man under, commonly used in the Quarter - 3 Deep formation. I should really stop talking, too much Madden
 
Hampe
offline
Link
 
I was just messing with the AI, and found something that seems a bit confusing.

We all know that the individual quarter AI overrides the "All quarters" general AI. My problem has to do with the I formation.

When choosing the formation, you can either choose "Weak I", "Strong I", or "I (any variation)". Now, if you make a few input/outputs for the weak or strong I in the general AI, will they get overridden if you make a 1st quarter input/output using "I (any variation)"?

If the answer is yes, then there needs to be an offense formation that is just the normal I, perhaps in addition to the "I (any variation)".
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 03:34:31
 
magicalmrrich
offline
Link
 
If you have put that towards the top of the list, say for instance created an input based on the offence calling a Strong I play, it will be called every time.

It works from the top down. Basically finding something that matches what is out there from the offence.

If you have a 4-3 2 receiver defensive play in before the Weak I special play, the 4-3 2 receiver play will be called.

Best put it towards the top of the list.
 
Hampe
offline
Link
 
Yea, I was hoping to have a general AI for the weak formation and quarter specific AIs for normal I, but it looks like I have to do both per quarter the way I want, and just put the I (any variation) at the bottom.
 
T2
Killuh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by TenTwo

Originally posted by rjssob


Cover 3 is a 3 deep zone, there is no man involved at all...


That's not ture...you can play cover 3 with man coverage underneath, just like cover 1,2 and 4.



Well yes, but normally when you here someone call cover 3 you think zone coverage. You are thinking 3 man under, commonly used in the Quarter - 3 Deep formation. I should really stop talking, too much Madden



Right, I understand that. I underatand that when you say "cover 3" you are refering to cover 3 zone. That knowledge is useless for Defensive AI settings though. You always have to specify underneath coverage (man or zone) regardless if you select cover 2, cover 3, etc. It's isn't "understood" with the exception of cover 0 (always man), I believe.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.