Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by NiteMaestro
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by TheJackal
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by TheJackal
Logic always wins.
Which is why you lose.
Not really none of you have beaten or come close. Your arguments are weak and your insulting remarks rather amusing. Are you saying that the universe just poofed into existence? That's rather silly.
Just as silly as saying God made it.
Ok... at this point, I'm gonna have to ask Mr. cbarge here to make one point that doesn't involve bashing another belief... If you can't do that, then you're wasting everyone's time here.
There's a difference between attacking a belief, and attacking a person. Get up to snuff on how to prevent the latter. ASAP.
Aren't you bashing his belief now?No. I never said that he was wrong or right.
I simply said that his methods are incorrect, a fallacy of argument. "Ad hominem" as a matter of fact.
--NOTE--
TheJackal was guilty of this too, but it was in response to a fallacy in the first place, dooming the conversation to more fallactic statements.
Moreover, TheJackal does commit fallacies, but he also presents cases that aren't fallactied. On the other hand, I have yet to see cbarge do that. Perhaps I have missed something, and if so, my apologies cbarge, but like I said, from my position, I have not seen it.
--END NOTE--
The statement "Just as silly as saying God made it" does not attack the belief that God created the universe, rather it simply disregards the fact as nonsense, and moves to declare that since the statement is so ludicrous, everyone that makes such a statement is as 'silly'.
The statement, "Which is why you lose" is guilty of a fallacy as well. That statement assumes that TheJackal does not abide with/agree with logic, something that cannot be assumed from the statement made. "Affirming the consequent" is the name of this fallacy.
So, to answer your question Firenze, no I am not. Though the statement I made was rather pointed, it was not bashing his beliefs at all. Bashing his statement? Yes. Bashing his argumentative methodology? Yes. But his beliefs? Not at all.
(at least I'm not trying to

)