User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
helmanj
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
What is going to happen when all the starting and back-up spots in the Pro leagues are taking? What happens when your starting HB in the AAA leagues is going to be punished for playing above his level, because he does not want to take a third string spot in the Pros.

Not every team that is good enough to advance does advance does move up. Are the players going to be punished for staying on the team to win next season, since they might be above the level median?

This is nothing but forced level caps for leagues, someting that in the long run will hurt this game.


It doesn't mean you have to move to the pro leagues. This is setup to make people not move a level 20 guy to single A. Most teams are evened out as it is, this will effect some of the newer teams with the people who bought one and took their 2 or 3 level 20's to that team to dominate since they couldnt do it with the big boys. Basically trying to prevent small dick syndrome
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xnahog
Doesn't affect owners? Are you nuts? I'm sure guys will be wanting off the team pretty quick instead of re signing. That will make your forum a wonderful place.


You don't even know how many of your players will be affected (although that Level 20 is sticking out like a sore thumb pretty good).

The fact is we don't know what the gap is. All we know is some vague description "way too high". I don't know what that means exactly, but if you're within 2 or 3 levels, I'm pretty sure that is NOT "way too high".

Think of it this way, if you trade a Level 20, you're still getting a good back-up or two from the higher leagues who want the opportunity to start. Only a fool would consider this opportunity as something negative. A Level 20 player is an asset... whether it be on the team or trade bait.
 
WVUFAN1971
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
What is going to happen when all the starting and back-up spots in the Pro leagues are taking? What happens when your starting HB in the AAA leagues is going to be punished for playing above his level, because he does not want to take a third string spot in the Pros.

Not every team that is good enough to advance does advance does move up. Are the players going to be punished for staying on the team to win next season, since they might be above the level median?

This is nothing but forced level caps for leagues, someting that in the long run will hurt this game.


As the above poster states, there's only so many slots in the Pro leagues, and many people have no desire to sign as FA to a Pro level league, they want to go with a lower-tier team and EARN their way into the Pros.

For the most part, only affect those who have been with the game for the longest, and have paid money to play the game.

Those who do not boost, or are relatively new to the game, this will not affect.

Let's alienate long-term supporters. Great rule.
 
xnahog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe_B
Originally posted by xnahog

I'm going to love having to tell the new guys I spent my teams money on that they're abilities are penalized because they're what??? Too good?

It's hard enough trading for, much less recruiting guys to BBB that are LVL 16+. Now that I've spent money on them, or spent a TON of time convincing them to be part of our organization I run the risk of them wanting off the team and playing for A, AA, AAA or Pro. That should do WONDERS for my team forum.

They should have told us this BEFORE offseason. Much appreciated.


USA BBB #8: 10.7484

Your level 17's probably won't take the hit. But that level 20 probably will.


Let's do some math. 11+8? 19. When a LVL 16 boosts 3 times that equals what? 19. Anything after boosting on the first day becomes a penalty. Anyone 16 and over on my team is penalized.
 
aprjem
offline
Link
 
This is awful. It takes all of the fun out of recruiting, because instead of trying to land one big gamebreaker for your squad and having that sense of pride in recruiting almost ruins the offseason. I dont get the point, I really dont. People are still going to cheat. Ugh... I have lived on his game for months now, and this happens.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WVUFAN1971
Originally posted by kinglehr

Here's my thoughts:

Forget about the cheating. This is bigger than that.

The fact is that players shouldn't be getting XP in this game for playing weaker players.


I disagree. EVERY SINGLE TEAM has the ability to recruit. EVERY SINGLE TEAM has the capacity to go after any FA they want. If one team or owner is better at recruiting, they, nor the players they go after, should suffer for it. Money, along with the natural relegation, will eventually cause teams and leagues to balance on their own.


Originally posted by


If you are a high 20something Level player who joined a league full of Level 13s, 14s, 15s... I have no sympathy for you. You intentionally signed with a team with the intent to beat up and pile on stats against weaker competition. Basically, you are Terrell Owens deciding to play the college CBs.


I love how you have the INCREDIBLE ability to know WHY someone signed with a team. Such talent. Mind-reading, that is.

Oh, you can't mind-read? You mean you might actually be talking out of your ass with baseless assumptions? Imagine that.



A team shouldn't be able to have a team full of players 8 levels higher than the median come in, sign for low contracts, and dominate the league.

We're not talking about one or two players. We're not talking about a team that has a player 3 or 4 levels above the league median. You're talking about a TEAM of players 8 levels above the median.

Even if you're just playing with your friends, you shouldn't be able to do that in a lower league. You can still do it, it's just going to cost you a little bit.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stewart85
i think borts new rule sucks, what happens to the teams who have been together since season 1 that are very high level but are in a low league? never cheated, never gutted, never stacked, just played together and now they get punished


The types of things that improve or reset sportsmanship to the max:
- Signing with a team where you are one of only 1-3 players above the recommended level (mentoring)
- Playing a game with your team (sticking with the team)
- Resigning with a team (limits per season apply)
- Boosting
- Being one of 3 or less players on the team owned by the same agent

So, a group of friends in a low league since season one will have...played lots of games, resigned with the team, boosted for the team, and possibly only have three players with the team.

Me thinks this won't be much of an issue.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xnahog
Let's do some math. 11+8? 19. When a LVL 16 boosts 3 times that equals what? 19. Anything after boosting on the first day becomes a penalty. Anyone 16 and over on my team is penalized.


BOOSTING IMPROVES YOUR SPORTSMANSHIPS AND MAKES THE PLAYER LESS LIKELY TO RECEIVE A PENALTY!

Not to mention, if they resign with the team, play games, boost, have only a few players on your team and they are only one of a few level 19/20's on your tea you will be fine.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xnahog
Originally posted by Joe_B

Originally posted by xnahog


I'm going to love having to tell the new guys I spent my teams money on that they're abilities are penalized because they're what??? Too good?

It's hard enough trading for, much less recruiting guys to BBB that are LVL 16+. Now that I've spent money on them, or spent a TON of time convincing them to be part of our organization I run the risk of them wanting off the team and playing for A, AA, AAA or Pro. That should do WONDERS for my team forum.

They should have told us this BEFORE offseason. Much appreciated.


USA BBB #8: 10.7484

Your level 17's probably won't take the hit. But that level 20 probably will.


Let's do some math. 11+8? 19. When a LVL 16 boosts 3 times that equals what? 19. Anything after boosting on the first day becomes a penalty. Anyone 16 and over on my team is penalized.


If others boost in the league guess what? The median now becomes higher! Not to mention that boosting increases or resets your sportsmanship score, so the boosting is a moot point.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WVUFAN1971
Originally posted by kinglehr

Here's my thoughts:

Forget about the cheating. This is bigger than that.

The fact is that players shouldn't be getting XP in this game for playing weaker players.


I disagree. EVERY SINGLE TEAM has the ability to recruit. EVERY SINGLE TEAM has the capacity to go after any FA they want. If one team or owner is better at recruiting, they, nor the players they go after, should suffer for it. Money, along with the natural relegation, will eventually cause teams and leagues to balance on their own.


Player XP is not about recruiting players. If you recruited Michael Jordan from the Chicago Bulls and onto your high school team - versus other high school players -, is Michael Jordan supposed to learn from that experience. That is the question to answer. I'm sorry it hurts the recruiting efforts of your high school team, but in the end... that is not what XP is all about.

XP in this game is the engine for development of skills. No one is stopping you from recruiting players of a "way too high" caliber. This is just acknowledging the fact that those kinds of players shouldn't improve in the same way that the high school kid would improve if he played Michael Jordan.

Originally posted by WVUFAN1971
Originally posted by kinglehr


If you are a high 20something Level player who joined a league full of Level 13s, 14s, 15s... I have no sympathy for you. You intentionally signed with a team with the intent to beat up and pile on stats against weaker competition. Basically, you are Terrell Owens deciding to play the college CBs.


I love how you have the INCREDIBLE ability to know WHY someone signed with a team. Such talent. Mind-reading, that is.

Oh, you can't mind-read? You mean you might actually be talking out of your ass with baseless assumptions? Imagine that.



And I love how you can't think and don't even know the meaning of the word Experience in a game or what it is used for in the game.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
So thunderdoozer I noticed you are on a team with another gm who has 9 players there. Did he bring all of his high level guys there appropiately?


Actually, he created all but 1 or 2 of those guys RIGHT BEFORE the start of our first season (or during the season), so there's no "drop-down" issue involved there.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 07:05:22
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by Finnious Cretin


actually in time the "sophmore" leagues will probably outlevel these gutters/stackers you seem to fear so badly.

Also people tell me why you think a team that gut/stacks more than one season won't be kicked out of the game?


No. Sophomore leagues will never outlevel guys who are higher level than a sophomore league. A second-year league start with levels 12-17 EVERY SINGLE TIME, and the stackers will STILL be much higher than that.


what are you talking about here. the players in sophmore leagues level up just like anyone, this season they are 14-17, next season they are 20-24, etc. whole leagues aren't moved up, only 2 teams a season.


NO, you moron. The players in a sophomore league start at 12-17... then next year, the players in a sophomore league start at 12-17... then next year, the players in a sophomore league start at 12-17.

That won't change.

Neither will your intelligence, unfortunately.
 
ClemsonJaguar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by somecut8
It shouldn't affect high level players that are already on the team. He should have also gave us a warning. I sent my high level CB to an African team because I wanted to play in Africa and now I get punished.

Also, what does he mean by XP modifier? Does it mean the player gets less XP for each game or does it just mean his performance sucks.
Agreed. If I had known this info prior to the FA period, I would have altered how I considered contracts.

 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Leahmic223
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by Leahmic223


They couldn't get away with it multiple times.


They don't have to do it multiple times to ruin an entire league.

You seem to think that it's okay if they "only" do it one time.


I never said it was okay for them do it. I'm replying to your theory that a group of guys could just do this every season without no one noticing.


No, my point is that this change does NOTHING to stop it.

And, I'm right.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaff
Absolutely sucks. Made all my lengthy comments in the original forum discussing this. Wish I would have known I was buying a farm team (BBB#3) before I spent the money. Glad I only signed up for 4 yrs. This is nice for all the A and Pro league guys I'm developing players for. FUCK!!!


Fact.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.