Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by ICRockets
OMFG the division idea doesn't work. You just freakin admitted that it's possible for a 14-2 team to get demoted based on your system.
BULLSHIT. It's only a mathematical possibility for a 14-2 team to be flagged for demotion... in reality it won't happen.
In the current GLB system, a 4-12 can make the playoffs as an eighth seed. Does that mean it should be scrapped??
it's a highly possible reality that a 10-6 or 9-7 tema that should be in the playoffs won't because in one of your shitty divisions they lost to a ton of WPL so a 7-9 team gets in. Divisions fail because they give automatic bids based on an arbitrary subgrouping rather than on round-robin performance like the regional Pro leagues.
What? That makes no sense. A 10-6 would make the playoffs ahead of a 7-9 team every time. I never said that division champions should be guaranteed a playoff spot (that would be a different debate).
And if you're talking about promotion or demotion, it's pretty obvious that the promotion would be based on your "arbitrary subgroupings" (i.e. the freakin' Pro leagues) regardless of what else is decided here. No one is suggesting anything other than promoting all the league/conference champs each season. It's merely a question of how to decide which teams go back down. Why the hell does it not make sense for an OPL team to take the place of another OPL team?
The idea is to promote parity, right? If over the first few seasons of the WPL, we wind up having 8-10 USAPL teams and other regions can't produce a team that sticks, doesn't that just mean that the best players who can't find spots in the WPL would just continue signing with USAPL teams, because they're the ones that are filling up the WPL and sticking? How is that parity? I agree with the sentiment posted elsewhere. If the best players believe their best chance into the WPL is to sign on with a "soft" Pro league rather than try to gut through a "hard" one like USAPL, then those players will sign on with other leagues instead of USAPL. Bam, parity.
First, that "different debate" is very important. Second, isnt your idea that the bottom 2 in each division gets demoted? Third, having arbitrary groupings in Pro is wrong because we've filtered tthrough hundreds of teams to get aa Pro champion and runner up. Fourth, arbitrary divisions also introduce a completely retarded and unnecessary scheduling bias, one well beyond the one that is, sadly, a necessary evil in the conference setup in GLB.
No, I actually think only eight teams should get bounced each season. if you bounce 16 teams each season, then divisions become a much tougher sell, because you'll almost always have a playoff team who isn't top two in their division and would be in line for bouncing, or you'd need a complex system to prevent them from bouncing. With only eight teams, it would be extremely rare for a playoff team to be in line for demotion.
You seem to have a reading comprehension problem here; as myself and many others have pointed out, you can implement divisions without ANY changes in scheduling. I think the NFL-style scheduling would be a benefit, but it's OPTIONAL. Not mandatory.
So you want to bounce the worst team in each of the 8 divisions, even though it is HIGHLY likely that in a given conference, the worst 4 teams are not all in different divisions? You want the same schedule, the same working as a conference EXCEPT then you want to allow for the 4th worst team in a conference to stay while the 5th worst has to go?
My opinion is that divisions do either zero or worse to the current structure. They cannot ever do better, because they can never go so far as to rank the worst teams the way a round-robin conference does. You can't ever prove that divisions will find teams that are more deserving than conference breakdown because round-robin is proven to be the best way.
In my eyes, demoting a 5-11 team while a 4-12 team stays is an acceptable aberration. It's not like that one extra win makes your season suddenly okay. What's not acceptable is taking a team that has spent its entire existence in a single region, building an identity, building friendships and rivalries, building a reputation, building regional pride, and then forcing them into some other region because they were good enough to win their Pro conference but not quite able to make the WPL playoffs. Take a losing WPL season and then throw on a random reassignment to some other region? That's not a prize, that's a penalty. Whether you promote eight teams or 16, the WPL will have a high circulation rate, and there won't be any shame in getting there and not quite hacking it. A team could go 2-14 in the WPL and still be good enough to win their Pro league the next season and get right back in. But if you take the upper crust of every Pro league and turn it into some mindless hash, with teams discarded out of the WPL in a random fashion, you're going to drive some of your most loyal owners to give up their teams in frustration. Guaranteed. Sure, there are agents who don't care about their regional identity, and that's fine... but for those who do care, it's IMPORTANT. As ITS said, there are a lot of people who love the WPL idea but would vote against it if it meant risking losing their place in their own Pro league.
I think the divisional system is a convenient and easy way to solve this problem with a bare minimum of changes required, AND it has the added benefit of being flexible and extensible for future seasons. But ultimately I'm fine with any scheme with the following properties:
1. Start off with the top four teams from each Pro league.
2. Promote each Pro league champion and maybe each Pro conference champion.
3. Demote either eight or sixteen teams, and ensure that each one goes back to its original league.
Any other details are unimportant.