Read through 50+ pages (OK, I skimmed the last handful), didn't see much (any?) mention of player weight being considered.
The 210 lb power back taking on a 245 lb LB should be part of the equation somewhere, no?
And, as for Bort's out-loud thought about Tackling Style settings ...
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe just
Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked
I don't like having to make that call for the entire game when so many offenses employ both types of back. Defenders know who they are tackling when they are tackling them (or trying to tackle them), they would adjust. Why force them to decide before the game starts if they are going to attempt every tackle in the same manner, no matter who their target is?
Maybe if defenses could have some opportunity to react to offensive personnel changes (if this RB enters the huddle, then this LB takes the field), you could play matching games and it could work. But, without that, high sub-rate rotating RB's could leave opposing defenders at a tackling disadvantage every other play, either way they go.
The 210 lb power back taking on a 245 lb LB should be part of the equation somewhere, no?
And, as for Bort's out-loud thought about Tackling Style settings ...
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe just
Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked
I don't like having to make that call for the entire game when so many offenses employ both types of back. Defenders know who they are tackling when they are tackling them (or trying to tackle them), they would adjust. Why force them to decide before the game starts if they are going to attempt every tackle in the same manner, no matter who their target is?
Maybe if defenses could have some opportunity to react to offensive personnel changes (if this RB enters the huddle, then this LB takes the field), you could play matching games and it could work. But, without that, high sub-rate rotating RB's could leave opposing defenders at a tackling disadvantage every other play, either way they go.






























