User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Read through 50+ pages (OK, I skimmed the last handful), didn't see much (any?) mention of player weight being considered.

The 210 lb power back taking on a 245 lb LB should be part of the equation somewhere, no?

And, as for Bort's out-loud thought about Tackling Style settings ...

Originally posted by Bort
Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


I don't like having to make that call for the entire game when so many offenses employ both types of back. Defenders know who they are tackling when they are tackling them (or trying to tackle them), they would adjust. Why force them to decide before the game starts if they are going to attempt every tackle in the same manner, no matter who their target is?

Maybe if defenses could have some opportunity to react to offensive personnel changes (if this RB enters the huddle, then this LB takes the field), you could play matching games and it could work. But, without that, high sub-rate rotating RB's could leave opposing defenders at a tackling disadvantage every other play, either way they go.
 
cbtd10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Read through 50+ pages (OK, I skimmed the last handful), didn't see much (any?) mention of player weight being considered.

The 210 lb power back taking on a 245 lb LB should be part of the equation somewhere, no?

And, as for Bort's out-loud thought about Tackling Style settings ...

Originally posted by Bort

Maybe just

Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked


I don't like having to make that call for the entire game when so many offenses employ both types of back. Defenders know who they are tackling when they are tackling them (or trying to tackle them), they would adjust. Why force them to decide before the game starts if they are going to attempt every tackle in the same manner, no matter who their target is?

Maybe if defenses could have some opportunity to react to offensive personnel changes (if this RB enters the huddle, then this LB takes the field), you could play matching games and it could work. But, without that, high sub-rate rotating RB's could leave opposing defenders at a tackling disadvantage every other play, either way they go.
Weight shouldnt be a factor IMO.

 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Looks like you continue to prove that you're an ignorant fuck. I've retired players and don't boost. I've been here since season 1. I don't GM 6 teams. 4 are from notoriety. 1 is because the owner of a better team than my own from last season in my league wanted me to help make his players better and give his players build advice in the forums.

And you saying that when defense put points in strength and tackling, while the offense puts more into speed and burns them because there's no balance? No, you have no idea what you're talking about.


So you suck at this game and had to retire your players? ahh, gotcha. Now I understand.


My players and players on my teams are just fine, they don't get burned by speed (my lb has 80+speed) but they also don't miss many tackles either. Looks like I don't have the problem here. Looks like you do.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 23:27:52
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
There was a mention on weight. And agree with turnit about on-the-fly changes.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
im not even sure why im arguing here...my LB pwns and has at every level of competition in this game....
 
cbtd10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Originally posted by Bort

Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too


I'd say you need a better build.


Originally posted by Bort

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?


On balanced tackling adv. tactic, I would say 70-ish TAC and 60-ish STR, assuming the DEF has decent AGI, SAs/VAs and Adv. Eq. too. If that player wanted to stop that RB EVERY time, I'd say he needs to have quite a bit more TAC and STR (i.e., 70/60 should stop that RB about 70% of the time).


70% Really? With 70/60? Thats just ridiculous...so 1/3 of the time he misses the tackle with these stats? No way. Thats pretty good for a LB and 1/3 is A LOT. No doubt that would lead to a bunch of 50-60 broken tackles game.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fletch03
Originally posted by Iceman16

Looks like you continue to prove that you're an ignorant fuck. I've retired players and don't boost. I've been here since season 1. I don't GM 6 teams. 4 are from notoriety. 1 is because the owner of a better team than my own from last season in my league wanted me to help make his players better and give his players build advice in the forums.

And you saying that when defense put points in strength and tackling, while the offense puts more into speed and burns them because there's no balance? No, you have no idea what you're talking about.


So you suck at this game and had to retire your players? ahh, gotcha. Now I understand.


My players and players on my teams are just fine, they don't get burned by speed (my lb has 80+speed) but they also don't miss tackles many tackles either. Looks like I don't have the problem here. Looks like you do.


LOL. You're ignorance is of epic proportions. Why don't you ask the majority of USA Pro if they retired builds because they didn't know how to slow-build? I don't have an issue. My guys don't miss tackles either. You can continue making up facts though if that's what you get off on.

Keep ignoring your bullshit argument about how fixing the defense fixes the offense too.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
would one say that 90% of the USA Pro West d coordinators suck because they couldnt stop HHW or MEM from pwning them? I wouldnt...


MEM and HHW are awesome teams...they deserve to win a lot of games. I will need to bite my tongue on the percentage I would quote in reference to your question though...it would only start a flame fest
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by Iceman16





The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


The only reason people are complaining is because they have made these SUPER FAST, Low tackling, Low Strength Lber's. Yes you should get put on your ass. Do something besides pumping all your points into speed and agility. There are other skills and attributes. Instead of "nerfing" something force people to man up and adjust.


I'm saying that the system is wrong. Something should be done to make LBs put more points into strength and tackling. But something should ALSO be done to tone down the offense.


To tone down the offense, put more points into strength and tackling. Its not that difficult and its what most people have been saying the whole time.


While they do that, the offense get SP too. That's far from solving the issue.


 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by fletch03

Originally posted by Iceman16


Looks like you continue to prove that you're an ignorant fuck. I've retired players and don't boost. I've been here since season 1. I don't GM 6 teams. 4 are from notoriety. 1 is because the owner of a better team than my own from last season in my league wanted me to help make his players better and give his players build advice in the forums.

And you saying that when defense put points in strength and tackling, while the offense puts more into speed and burns them because there's no balance? No, you have no idea what you're talking about.


So you suck at this game and had to retire your players? ahh, gotcha. Now I understand.


My players and players on my teams are just fine, they don't get burned by speed (my lb has 80+speed) but they also don't miss tackles many tackles either. Looks like I don't have the problem here. Looks like you do.


LOL. You're ignorance is of epic proportions. Why don't you ask the majority of USA Pro if they retired builds because they didn't know how to slow-build? I don't have an issue. My guys don't miss tackles either. You can continue making up facts though if that's what you get off on.

Keep ignoring your bullshit argument about how fixing the defense fixes the offense too.


If you don't have an issue then what the fuck are you arguing about. Get a clue.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
^^ Read above post, troll.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
im not even sure why im arguing here...my LB pwns and has at every level of competition in this game....


Just from the scouting bars and season stats, I would have to agree...congrats
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bhall43

would one say that 90% of the USA Pro West d coordinators suck because they couldnt stop HHW or MEM from pwning them? I wouldnt...


MEM and HHW are awesome teams...they deserve to win a lot of games. I will need to bite my tongue on the percentage I would quote in reference to your question though...it would only start a flame fest


ha...i just threw out a number...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.


That's kinda why I'm asking this, Larry. People complain about missing tackles, but missing 3-4 tackles in a game vs one of these guys when you have 30 strength and 40 tackling and aren't running full speed with your 90 spd/agility doesn't really seem that out of line to me, even with "wrap up" settings.

I mean, you don't want power backs to be the end-all build, but you want to make their skills worthwhile as well, so a tiny weak CB doesn't take him down every time.


Im glad Bort has said this....maybe all the crying little kids with 90spd/agility will stop crying and start build more well rounded builds.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
In real life, I am not sure how much strength plays a role in tackling a stronger player. It is usually about leverage, timing and good tackling skills. In GLB agility vision and tackling should play a major role in tacking no matter who you try to tackle. At any rate the combination of skills required should not need to be greater in total than the total skills that the power back has.

For example 60+ strength and 60+ tackling just because a powerback has 100 strength seems crazy and excessive. Tackling should be worth more and more important to all defensive players but I see many builds ignore it. Especially on the D line. I am guilty of this as well.

In closing and in a real world example strength vs strength usually turns into a battle of toughness and stamina. Strength vs smarts usually goes one of two ways. The weaker but smarter player gets crushed or the smarter player shuts down the stronger player and the stronger player gets frustrated.

Thats my two cents.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.