User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
the problem (and I said this in the past) is that there are multiple teams doing this - Stern's team just happens to be one of the most blatant offenders and because of his behavior it's easy to point a finger at him. If we're going to punish him team, we need to punish all the teams that are doing it and I don't know any easy way of figuring out who is doing it and who isn't and it's not something I have time to be investigating on my own. Stern's definitely done some funny stuff, of that there is no doubt and it's easy to see just from looking at team cash histories and transactions. So do we set an example of his organization and let others go unpunished? Isn't that hypocritical and a bad precedent to set? I think it is.
 
kmart
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
the problem (and I said this in the past) is that there are multiple teams doing this - Stern's team just happens to be one of the most blatant offenders and because of his behavior it's easy to point a finger at him. If we're going to punish him team, we need to punish all the teams that are doing it and I don't know any easy way of figuring out who is doing it and who isn't and it's not something I have time to be investigating on my own. Stern's definitely done some funny stuff, of that there is no doubt and it's easy to see just from looking at team cash histories and transactions. So do we set an example of his organization and let others go unpunished? Isn't that hypocritical and a bad precedent to set? I think it is.


Well you have to start somewhere. If the alternate course of action is to just do nothing, it sets an equally bad precedent.
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
If we're going to punish him team, we need to punish all the teams that are doing it


Sounds good to me.

Originally posted by Catch22
I don't know any easy way of figuring out who is doing it and who isn't


Understood. But, if we set some examples out of team making it obvious and that show we won't tolerate it, I'm willing to bet the rats will start coming out of the sewers. People love tattling.

And, if nothing else, we stop people from doing it excessively and blatently, that's a win in my book.
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
I have a player on the $194mil team

oops
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Understood. But, if we set some examples out of team making it obvious and that show we won't tolerate it, I'm willing to bet the rats will start coming out of the sewers. People love tattling.

And, if nothing else, we stop people from doing it excessively and blatently, that's a win in my book.


I have talked to stern many times on aim and such. I honestly think if we where to make an example out of his team he would start to point the finger the other way's.

The way he see's it hes put to much " Effort " into this then to be the only one taken down and to loose it all.

If and or When doing this im sure there will be alot of backlash for it, in the long term for glb it is much needed.

 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
What makes this different is that Stern's group isn't trying to compete with all these teams. That one you linked has players of all sorts of levels, obviously pumping them with cash to start off their careers.


It is a lot more widespread that Stern, though...hell, both of my teams could be described in the quoted post, and Catch has players on them (I think...I know I have a few people from when we absorbed one of his old teams, and he has guys in the system), so don't ban me please. A few people I know own teams that used to compete, now are all CPU, and they sign guys to them, fix their EQ, then go elsewhere for the season...anything we do needs to sweep up a lot of people.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
the problem (and I said this in the past) is that there are multiple teams doing this - Stern's team just happens to be one of the most blatant offenders and because of his behavior it's easy to point a finger at him. If we're going to punish him team, we need to punish all the teams that are doing it and I don't know any easy way of figuring out who is doing it and who isn't and it's not something I have time to be investigating on my own. Stern's definitely done some funny stuff, of that there is no doubt and it's easy to see just from looking at team cash histories and transactions. So do we set an example of his organization and let others go unpunished? Isn't that hypocritical and a bad precedent to set? I think it is.


OK, lets look at it this way: how do we handle multi-accounts?

For the most part, we all rely on tips and things popping up on forums to tip us off. Do we catch everyone? Of course not. Do we catch quite a few? The 3150+ post thread says yes.

So why would we look at multi-accounts and say, "we'll rely on reports and what we can dig up and that'll have to be good enough because it's better than nothing" and then turn around and say, "if we can't get them all, we'll get none" when it comes to teams BLATANTLY cheating like this?

It makes NO sense and tells the userbase that we're fine with people cheating like this. Throw on the fact that we're going to allow users to actually own multiple teams again and it's just game-on for this crap.


Start with Stern, allow people to report times they see this crap happening, and take it from there. If we come up with a foolproof way in the future to take care of this, great. If not, at least we're doing SOMETHING.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
OK, lets look at it this way: how do we handle multi-accounts?

For the most part, we all rely on tips and things popping up on forums to tip us off. Do we catch everyone? Of course not. Do we catch quite a few? The 3150+ post thread says yes.

So why would we look at multi-accounts and say, "we'll rely on reports and what we can dig up and that'll have to be good enough because it's better than nothing" and then turn around and say, "if we can't get them all, we'll get none" when it comes to teams BLATANTLY cheating like this?

It makes NO sense and tells the userbase that we're fine with people cheating like this. Throw on the fact that we're going to allow users to actually own multiple teams again and it's just game-on for this crap.


Start with Stern, allow people to report times they see this crap happening, and take it from there. If we come up with a foolproof way in the future to take care of this, great. If not, at least we're doing SOMETHING.


maybe stop letting people GM,Co-Own multiple teams? say if im an owner of drinkin. and stobie wanted to make me a gm he could do so but i wouldn't have any powers on his team. means no signing trading or eq fund access...i would just be there for the lol trophy.

i dont know if this could help but its a small step
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fondo the Wise

maybe stop letting people GM,Co-Own multiple teams? say if im an owner of drinkin. and stobie wanted to make me a gm he could do so but i wouldn't have any powers on his team. means no signing trading or eq fund access...i would just be there for the lol trophy.

i dont know if this could help but its a small step


Bort's thinking about letting people own multiple teams again...so limiting co-owning would be bad.

Perhaps limiting people's ability to move between teams with the same GM...but what if they're following someone who no longer coordinates.
 
kmart
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fondo the Wise
Originally posted by Jed

OK, lets look at it this way: how do we handle multi-accounts?

For the most part, we all rely on tips and things popping up on forums to tip us off. Do we catch everyone? Of course not. Do we catch quite a few? The 3150+ post thread says yes.

So why would we look at multi-accounts and say, "we'll rely on reports and what we can dig up and that'll have to be good enough because it's better than nothing" and then turn around and say, "if we can't get them all, we'll get none" when it comes to teams BLATANTLY cheating like this?

It makes NO sense and tells the userbase that we're fine with people cheating like this. Throw on the fact that we're going to allow users to actually own multiple teams again and it's just game-on for this crap.


Start with Stern, allow people to report times they see this crap happening, and take it from there. If we come up with a foolproof way in the future to take care of this, great. If not, at least we're doing SOMETHING.


maybe stop letting people GM,Co-Own multiple teams? say if im an owner of drinkin. and stobie wanted to make me a gm he could do so but i wouldn't have any powers on his team. means no signing trading or eq fund access...i would just be there for the lol trophy.

i dont know if this could help but its a small step


This is a discussion for another thread. Let's not get off-topic here haha.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Team equipment is probably the best way, i.e. eliminate money from the team/player interaction and make it more about building your own stadium and salary. This has already been proposed and met with general approval so I feel like I am rehashing it. It's just a matter at this point of going forward with it. Most of these schemes are directly related to trying to get players equipment. You could be creative as well, like giving players certain things that allow them to get equipment without it being directly related to team money.

I think a rethinking of the team money/player salary/stadium building/player equipment needs to happen. We have some very creative and smart people here so I think someone could come up with something really excellent like the new player archetypes (like them in the sense that they are a good update of a major feature of the game). This IS directly related to the problem at hand, because it would solve the root issue behind all of the monetary collusion.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Team equipment is probably the best way, i.e. eliminate money from the team/player interaction and make it more about building your own stadium and salary. This has already been proposed and met with general approval so I feel like I am rehashing it. It's just a matter at this point of going forward with it. Most of these schemes are directly related to trying to get players equipment. You could be creative as well, like giving players certain things that allow them to get equipment without it being directly related to team money.

I think a rethinking of the team money/player salary/stadium building/player equipment needs to happen. We have some very creative and smart people here so I think someone could come up with something really excellent like the new player archetypes (like them in the sense that they are a good update of a major feature of the game). This IS directly related to the problem at hand, because it would solve the root issue behind all of the monetary collusion.


I think it will happen , judging by the chatter on the test server it will be the prime subject for S15.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Yea, the big issue is how to do so without completely fucking up the game.


In the meantime, people doing this need to be punished.
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
OK, lets look at it this way: how do we handle multi-accounts?

For the most part, we all rely on tips and things popping up on forums to tip us off. Do we catch everyone? Of course not. Do we catch quite a few? The 3150+ post thread says yes.

So why would we look at multi-accounts and say, "we'll rely on reports and what we can dig up and that'll have to be good enough because it's better than nothing" and then turn around and say, "if we can't get them all, we'll get none" when it comes to teams BLATANTLY cheating like this?

It makes NO sense and tells the userbase that we're fine with people cheating like this. Throw on the fact that we're going to allow users to actually own multiple teams again and it's just game-on for this crap.


Start with Stern, allow people to report times they see this crap happening, and take it from there. If we come up with a foolproof way in the future to take care of this, great. If not, at least we're doing SOMETHING.


Totally agree. The longer we let it go, the more difficult it'll be to handle. And just because Bort wants to get rid of player cash doesn't mean we should sit back and let the blatent cheaters exploit until that new plan is in place.

I honestly believe that the users will self police this. Some owner will not get a player max XP for three games in a row, and that guy will come forward and rat on the whole operation.

As Jed said, we heavily rely on the userbase to spot multi accounts. We now heavily rely on them to use the report button to help us mod. There's no reason to think those tattle tales won't snitch on someone colluding.

Originally posted by tpaterniti
Team equipment is probably the best way,


Always been a fan of this. It will promote teams to stay together more, imo. Right now, you have people coming on board, getting a big EQ upgrade then splitting without ever saying a word to the owner about why even though they were treated fairly.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
For anyone who doesn't have access to the test server or doesn't frequent it often, if you have an idea to make equipment team-owned without fucking up the rest of the game, please say so
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.